[Senate Prints 115-19]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]
115th Congress } { S. Prt.
1st Session } COMMITTEE PRINT { 115-19
_______________________________________________________________________
CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
ON THE BUDGET
FISCAL YEAR 2018
----------
COMMITTEE PRINT
to accompany
S. CON. RES. 25
together with
ADDITIONAL VIEWS AND MINORITY VIEWS
COMMITTEE ON THE BUDGET
UNITED STATES SENATE
Michael B. Enzi, Chairman
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
October 2017
Prepared for the use of the Committee on the Budget. This document has
not been officially approved by the Committee and may not reflect the
views of its members.
115th Congress } { S. Prt.
1st Session } COMMITTEE PRINT { 115-19
_______________________________________________________________________
CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
ON THE BUDGET
FISCAL YEAR 2018
__________
COMMITTEE PRINT
to accompany
S. CON. RES. 25
together with
ADDITIONAL VIEWS AND MINORITY VIEWS
COMMITTEE ON THE BUDGET
UNITED STATES SENATE
Michael B. Enzi, Chairman
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
October 2017
Prepared for the use of the Committee on the Budget. This document has
not been officially approved by the Committee and may not reflect the
views of its members.
______
U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
27-001 WASHINGTON : 2017
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Publishing
Office Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512-1800;
DC area (202) 512-1800 Fax: (202) 512-2104 Mail: Stop IDCC,
Washington, DC 20402-0001
COMMITTEE ON THE BUDGET
MICHAEL B. ENZI, Wyoming, Chairman
CHARLES E. GRASSLEY, Iowa BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont
MIKE CRAPO, Idaho PATTY MURRAY, Washington
LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina RON WYDEN, Oregon
PATRICK TOOMEY, Pennsylvania DEBBIE STABENOW, Michigan
RON JOHNSON, Wisconsin SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island
BOB CORKER, Tennessee MARK R. WARNER, Virginia
DAVID A. PERDUE, Georgia JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon
CORY GARDNER, Colorado TIM KAINE, Virginia
JOHN KENNEDY, Louisiana ANGUS S. KING, Jr., Maine
JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas CHRIS VAN HOLLEN, Maryland
LUTHER STRANGE, Alabama KAMALA D. HARRIS, California
Elizabeth McDonnell, Republican Staff Director
Warren Gunnels, Minority Staff Director
C O N T E N T S
----------
Page
I. Overview...................................................... 1
II. Resolution Levels............................................ 7
III. Reconciliation and Enforcement.............................. 23
IV. Economics.................................................... 27
V. Reserve Funds................................................. 35
VI. Summary Tables............................................... 37
VII. Committee Votes............................................. 49
VIII. Views and Estimates........................................ 63
IX. Additional and Minority Views................................ 303
OVERVIEW
----------
Current-Law Projections--More Deficits, More Debt, Slow Growth
Earlier this year the Congressional Budget Office (CBO)
released An Update to the Budget and Economic Outlook: 2017 to
2027. The report showed that under current projections the
Federal Government will spend over $10 trillion more than it
takes in during the next 10 years. This projection is the
byproduct of Washington's chronic overspending and the
economy's anemic growth. According to CBO, annual deficits will
surpass the $1 trillion mark in 2022 and grow each year
thereafter. At the same time, annual economic growth is
projected to settle at a paltry 1.9 percent.
Over the next decade, CBO projects that spending will
increase from 20.5 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) in
2018 to 23.6 percent of GDP, well above the 50-year average of
20.3 percent. During the same period, however, revenues will
remain at record highs. CBO currently projects revenues of 17.7
percent of GDP in 2018, growing to 18.4 percent of the economy.
That is a full percentage point higher than the 50-year average
of 17.4 percent.
Continual overspending and its resulting deficits will
expand the Federal debt. During the next 10 years, debt held by
the public is slated to rise from 77 percent of GDP ($15
trillion) to 91 percent of GDP ($26 trillion), the largest
since the immediate aftermath of World War II. In March, CBO
released The 2017 Long-Term Budget Outlook, which discusses the
consequences of unchecked rising Federal debt if there is no
fiscal course correction. These effects include:
--Reduced national savings and income--increasing interest
rates, lowering private investment, economic output, worker
compensation, and incentives to work.
--Increased Federal interest cost and its crowd-out effect
on the rest of the budget--interest costs are projected to
triple over the next 10 years and surpass all discretionary
spending by 2044.
--Imposed limitations on the ability of the Government to
respond to dramatic events--a large debt reduces flexibility to
respond to or plan for fiscal, humanitarian, or international
crises.
--Increased likelihood of a fiscal crisis--as CBO states
plainly, ``the larger a government's debt, the greater the risk
of fiscal crisis.''
This forecast is bad news for American families, American
businesses, and America's standing in the world. This
resolution puts forth another path--and it begins with tax
reform.
Fiscal Year 2018 Senate Budget Resolution
the first step for tax reform
The fiscal year 2018 Senate budget resolution is the start
of the process to achieve historic, pro-growth tax reform so
the U.S. economy grows again. That begins with changing the tax
policies that are holding back investment and productivity. The
United States needs a simpler, fairer, and more transparent tax
system, which leaves more dollars in the average American's
pockets.
Comprehensive tax reform should broaden the base while
lowering marginal tax rates, streamline U.S. tax laws, and
limit Government distortion of market-based decisions.
America's tax policy should provide for a globally competitive
corporate tax rate and an international tax system that does
not penalize U.S. companies.
Tax policy affects the decisions of individuals and
corporations, including whether to work an additional hour or
invest an additional unit of capital. The outcome of these
decisions has real consequences for our broader economy. The
three key factors that contribute to overall economic growth
are labor, capital, and technology. The Joint Committee on
Taxation states: ``[t]ax policy can directly influence the
level of labor supply, physical capital, human capital, and
technology in an economy by changing the after-tax returns to
certain economic activities or changing the cost of pursuing
such activities.''
Pro-growth tax policy should reward work, savings, and
investment. Marginal tax rates on individuals influence labor-
force participation and hours worked. Corporate investment in
capital is impacted by the tax code's competitiveness and by
tax policy effects on a company's cash-flow, cost recovery, and
financing options. Technological innovations increase
productivity, allowing labor and capital to produce more output
with less input. Additionally, a competitive international tax
system has a direct impact on the choice to invest
domestically.
The current tax code can favor certain industries and
decisions, so it is biased in terms of investment allocation.
Tax reform should eliminate special deductions, loopholes, and
credits that distort the marketplace. Pro-growth reform that
removes distortion would allow for resources to be reallocated
toward their highest economic use, instead of the use that
produces the best tax outcome. This efficiency will lead to
increased investment, growth of businesses, and higher economic
output, or GDP.
A more efficient tax system can produce the same level of
revenue with lower rates, as long as tax expenditures are
minimized and the economy grows through efficient market-based
decisions. If tax reform can stop the projected economic
decline, income and profits will rise, along with Federal
revenues to the Treasury. A return to historic average growth
would decrease projected deficits by over $2 trillion in the
10-year window, more than sufficient to pay for the decrease in
revenues assumed under static scoring conventions that do not
fully account for economic growth.
CBO has examined how growth in real output per unit of
combined labor and capital services might affect GDP, income
(including wages), and interest rates. Under the budget
office's simplified rule of thumb, policies that increase
productivity by one-tenth of a percentage point ultimately
reduce Federal deficits by $273 billion over 10 years. As
economic growth rises in each year as a result of that higher
productivity, taxable income would also grow more quickly than
projected, and tax revenues would be higher.
CBO explains that if workers produce more, they earn more,
so total wages and labor income are higher. If capital
production were higher, the returns on that capital would also
rise. Because Treasury securities compete with other
investments for investors' money, higher private returns imply
that rates on Treasury securities would also be higher.
The Joint Economic Committee (JEC) has provided the Senate
Budget Committee with a Views and Estimates letter on the state
of the U.S. economy. JEC notes that every year since 2007, CBO
has downgraded its projection of potential GDP and points to
policies that have contributed to this decline. Heavy taxation
on business owners and higher taxes on capital have left ``a
growing reserve of untapped potential not reflected in the
current output gap.''
The Senate Finance Committee's Views and Estimates letter
states, ``[t]ax reform should focus on broad-based economic
growth and job creation, fairness, simplification, and
certainty.'' The Finance Committee's objectives for tax reform
include:
--Lowering the U.S. statutory corporate tax rate from the
current highest in the world.
--Eliminating or changing various special provisions and
preferences of the tax code that are inconsistent with an
efficient allocation of capital.
--Reforming the corporate tax base, including so-called
expensing provisions and provisions that provide the current
bias toward debt financing, along with examining parity between
businesses that organize as pass-throughs and as C
corporations.
--Strengthening American manufacturing and innovation.
--Boosting wage growth for American workers.
--Boosting economic growth on a sustained basis.
--Strengthening the international tax system to encourage
investments and innovation in America.
The tax-reform-writing committees of the Senate and House
are tasked with developing and drafting legislation that will
result in the first comprehensive tax reform in over a
generation. Their joint statement with Senate and House
leadership, Treasury, and the White House's National Economic
Council earlier this summer sets expectations that legislation
will move through the committees this fall, under regular
order, followed by consideration on the House and Senate
floors.
As the first step toward historic, pro-growth tax reform,
this budget provides the tools necessary to the Finance
Committee to complete its work.
resolution details
The fiscal year 2018 Senate budget resolution is first and
foremost about reforming the tax code and expanding the economy
for all Americans.
But it also is a serious reform budget.
If Congress and the administration adhere to this
blueprint, the Government will be back on track to fiscal
responsibility--balancing the budget with a combination of
restrained spending, reduced tax burdens, and a growing
economy. In doing so this budget invests in a strong national
defense and provides for the care of the Nation's most
vulnerable citizens. It serves as a framework to expand
economic opportunity for all Americans.
The Senate budget presents a way forward with this budget,
one geared toward creating a more effective, efficient, and
accountable government. To accomplish this goal, the budget
proposes $5.1 trillion in spending savings over the next 10
years. (This figure climbs to $6.4 trillion if compared to the
CBO June 2017 Baseline, which incorporates $1.3 trillion in
funding that qualifies for budget enforcement cap exceptions
and related interest.) The spending policies of this budget are
discussed in the Resolution Levels portion of this report.
The Senate budget also assumes more than $1.6 trillion in
tax cuts, of which $1.5 trillion can be processed through fast-
tracked reconciliation procedures. These figures are based on
static current-law estimates of tax cut and reform policies
assumed in the resolution. In addition, the budget assumes that
with these policies, the coffers of the Federal Government will
benefit from increased economic growth not envisioned under
current-law projections. The resolution anticipates that
enactment of tax reform will generate economic growth at a
significant enough level to compensate for the initial decrease
in revenues assumed under a static scoring convention.
This budget honors the special off-budget status of Social
Security. This treatment also reflects the understanding that
the congressional budget resolution is an on-budget document
and that the Congressional Budget Act imposes certain
limitations on what a resolution can contain, display, and
support changing. From the start, this budget was focused on
achieving on-budget balance by the end of budget window. By
2026, the resolution--with economic feedback included--would
generate a $79 billion on-budget surplus. This surplus would
grow to $197 billion by 2027.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
In addition to the fiscal reforms proposed by the budget,
this resolution continues efforts to respond to concerns about
the broken budget process. The plan takes important steps to
curtail budget gimmicks, increase honesty and accuracy by
Government scorekeepers, and end the ``spend now, pay later''
mentality of Washington. These changes are discussed in depth
in the Enforcement section of this report.
RESOLUTION LEVELS
----------
Budget Function 050: NATIONAL DEFENSE
The National Security function includes funds to develop,
maintain, and equip the military forces of the United States.
Historically, about 95 percent of these funds go to Department
of Defense military activities, with remaining funding
dedicated to atomic energy defense activities within the
Department of Energy and other defense-related activities.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $557.3 billion in budget authority and $569.3 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $549.1
billion, with $560.8 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $8.2 billion in budget authority and $8.5 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $6,232.4
billion, with $6,107.8 billion in outlays, corresponding to
baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
After years of defense budget brinkmanship under the
previous administration, this budget resolution promotes much-
needed fiscal stability to provide the foundation for effective
and efficient defense planning. The resolution removes the
specter of across-the-board sequestration cuts and allocates as
much base Pentagon funding as possible under current law. The
resolution also includes a mechanism to increase funding levels
for defense accounts, once there is a final resolution of
defense spending later this year.
This budget further provides for the national defense with
$76.6 billion in budget authority for the Overseas Contingency
Operations war-funding account, which can be found in budget
function 970. This is the same level of OCO funding requested
by the Trump administration earlier this year. Under law, OCO
funding does not count against the discretionary spending caps
contained in the 2011 Budget Control Act, as amended.
The Pentagon's overall base budget remains near the average
of defense spending during the Reagan buildup. Yet reforms
still are required to combat wasteful spending. The department
needs to pursue fundamental reforms in its organization,
business operations, work force management, and compensation
structure, all of which have been goals of the recent
leadership of congressional defense committees. In a positive
development, the Armed Services Committee now has a partner in
the current administration that has pledged to steward taxpayer
dollars more carefully by increasing efficiency and
accountability.
Recently the Senate Armed Services Committee has promoted
reforms including streamlining the acquisition system, updating
departmental organization for a new era, rationalizing the
whole Defense Department work force, and modernizing the
department's business operations. These efforts build on
reforms spearheaded by the Armed Services Committee in recent
years, including mandated savings and efficiency targets, new
authorities for acquisition and personnel management, and
repeal of unnecessary laws or regulations. This resolution
remains supportive of those efforts to reform the department
and restore taxpayer trust.
Budget Function 150: INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS
The International Affairs function contains spending on
international humanitarian and development assistance;
international security assistance; the conduct of foreign
affairs; foreign information and exchange activities; and
international financial programs. Funding contained in the
function supports operations at major agencies including the
Departments of State, Treasury, and Agriculture; the U.S.
Agency for International Development; and the Millennium
Challenge Corporation.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $45.2 billion in budget authority and $45.0 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $39.5
billion, with $48.7 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $5.7 billion in budget authority and $^3.7 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $451.9
billion, with $437.7 billion in outlays, corresponding to
baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
This budget resolution supports the funding of U.S. foreign
policy, including diplomatic efforts, the promotion of American
ideals abroad, and global humanitarian aid and development
assistance. The level of funding in the budget resolution is
near the average spending for international affairs in the
post-9/11 era. Still, management and implementation of
international affairs activities is ripe for reform.
Bipartisan coalitions and a wide variety of independent
analysts have consistently called for rationalizing the State
Department's organizational and management structure,
revitalizing its regional bureaus, revamping food aid and
development assistance, improving public diplomacy, and
reassessing American contributions to international
organizations. This budget supports the efforts of the Senate
Foreign Relations Committee, as the committee of jurisdiction,
to approve a new authorization bill for the department and
related agencies.
Additional funding for programs in this function is assumed
to occur with spending designated as overseas contingency
operations. OCO funding in this resolution can be found in
budget function 970.
Budget Function 250: SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
The Science and Technology function includes the National
Science Foundation, programs other than aviation programs at
the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, and general
science programs at the Department of Energy.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $32.6 billion in budget authority and $31.9 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $32.5
billion, with $31.8 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $0.1 billion in budget authority and $0.1 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $358.7
billion, with $351.1 billion in outlays, corresponding to
baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
This function, largely consisting of Federal discretionary
spending, supports NASA, the National Science Foundation, and
the Energy Department's Office of Science in their core
missions, while allowing emphasis on such national priorities
as basic research. As with all areas of Federal spending,
programs funded under this portion of the budget can be
reformed. According to the Government Accountability Office,
areas for reform include NASA's acquisition management, which
remains on the agency's high-risk list. The agency recommended
specific actions to better evaluate the agency's human-
exploration programs, in particular. GAO also recommends in its
annual report that NASA, the Energy Department, the Department
of Health and Human Services, and the Science Foundation better
coordinate their research activities.
To that end, the American Innovation and Competitiveness
Act, enacted in January 2017, created an interagency working
group addressing GAO's concerns, as well as improved the
administration and oversight of agency grant-making processes.
Implementation of the act should enhance science and technology
program efficiency, maximizing Federal investments. This budget
remains supportive of those efforts and the role of appropriate
Senate committees to report reforms.
Budget Function 270: ENERGY
The Energy function concerns the production, development,
and use of energy for the country. This function contains
civilian energy programs at agencies including the departments
of Energy and Agriculture, Tennessee Valley Authority, Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission, and Nuclear Regulatory
Commission.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $^0.8 billion in budget authority and $2.7 billion in
outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $5.4 billion,
with $5.1 billion in related outlays. Mandatory spending is
$^6.1 billion in budget authority and $^2.4 billion in outlays.
Over 10 years, budget authority totals $32.0 billion, with
$25.9 billion in outlays, a divergence of $8.8 billion from
baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The budget resolution allows authorizing committees to
focus taxpayer dollars on the modernization and reform of
America's energy generation and transmission assets. The
Federal Government can devote taxpayer investments to key
mission areas including nuclear security, basic scientific
research, energy innovation and security, and nuclear waste and
environmental cleanup.
In recent years, programs related to the commercialization
of energy technology have expanded beyond the Energy
Department's intended role as a catalyst of basic research and
development. Federal loan and loan-guarantee programs to
subsidize early commercial development of certain technologies
have cost taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars when
products prove uncompetitive on the open market.
The resolution allows a renewed focus on the department's
historic strength: early stage scientific research and
development. Later-stage development, adoption, and deployment
of technologies can return to the private sector.
This budget supports a focus on utilization of current
energy supply and assets, rather than the previous
administration's efforts to pick market winners and losers.
Federal agencies should promote abundant and secure
American energy resources, while supporting the Nation's
financial security and stability. This budget supports the work
of the committees of jurisdiction as they consider policies to
improve Federal energy programs.
In addition, the resolution contains a reconciliation
instruction for the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural
Resources. Provided at the request of the committee, the
instruction will allow Congress to consider policies to unlock
the Nation's energy production capacity.
Budget Function 300: ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
The Environment and Natural Resources function focuses on
the management, development, and maintenance of the Nation's
natural heritage. This function includes conservation of land
and water resources; development of water power and
transportation infrastructure; and agencies and resources
associated with the management and regulation of pollution,
public and recreational lands, and natural resources.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $40.5 billion in budget authority and $40.6 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $37.4
billion, with $38.0 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $3.1 billion in budget authority and $2.6 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $451.4
billion, with $445.5 billion in outlays, a divergence of $14.3
billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The Federal Government owns roughly 28 percent of the land
in the United States, or 640 million acres, according to the
Congressional Research Service. Much of that land is
disproportionately concentrated in western States. Many
agencies covered by this function are tasked with the
preservation of those Federal lands, as well as the responsible
development and management of its natural resources.
The budget resolution encourages the continued stewardship
of Federal lands and assumes a greater return for American
taxpayers on natural resources bountiful on those lands. This
budget also supports recent efforts by Congress and this
administration to reduce regulatory burdens that have for too
long discouraged energy development and production on Federal
land.
The budget resolution also allows committees of
jurisdiction to pursue opportunities to achieve savings for
taxpayers without harming the Nation's land and water
resources. The budget supports authorizing committee review of
timber production from Federal lands, coupled with forest-
management reforms focused on wildfire prevention.
To reduce inefficiencies and combat waste, fraud, and abuse
of taxpayer resources, agencies should strive to implement
improvements identified by the Government Accountability
Office.
Budget Function 350: AGRICULTURE
The Agriculture function includes the Department of
Agriculture and the Farm Credit Administration, and only deals
with programs concerned with agricultural production.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $22.1 billion in budget authority and $22.0 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $6.5 billion,
with $6.4 billion in related outlays. Mandatory spending is
$15.6 billion in budget authority and $15.6 billion in outlays.
Over 10 years, budget authority totals $200.6 billion, with
$192.1 billion in outlays, a divergence of $20.6 billion from
baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The Farm Bill is subject to reauthorization in 2018. This
budget resolution supports the committee of jurisdiction as it
moves forward with efforts to reexamine the farm safety net,
ensure domestic food production, and improve Federal
agriculture programs.
Budget Function 370: COMMERCE AND HOUSING CREDIT
The Commerce and Housing Credit function includes the
regulation and promotion of commerce and certain housing
policies and agencies. Agencies concerned with the economy as a
whole fall under this function. In addition, general-purpose
subsidies and credit subsidies are recorded here.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $7.6 billion in budget authority and $^5.9 billion in
outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $^4.2 billion,
with $^3.8 billion in related outlays. Mandatory spending is
$11.8 billion in budget authority and $^2.1 billion in outlays.
Over 10 years, budget authority totals $^2.2 billion, with
$^113.1 billion in outlays, a divergence of $173.1 billion from
baseline levels. These figures reflect the combined on- and
off-budget amounts associated with this function.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The budget resolution supports efforts by committees of
jurisdiction to reform a system that exposes taxpayer dollars
to undue risk into one that provides productive support to
industry.
Under the previous administration, Federal bureaucrats
gained excessive authority over industry, which impedes
private-sector economic growth and job creation. The Federal
Government should retain regulation that reduces systemic risk
and helps to prevent another financial crisis, and remove over-
regulation that places a costly burden on the U.S. economy and
American workers.
At the same time, housing should become more growth-
oriented rather than Government-focused, with taxpayers
protected from undue risk. Reforming the U.S. housing industry
would significantly reduce taxpayer subsidization of the
secondary mortgage market and provide appropriate, effective
oversight of Federal programs. In June 2017, the Government
Accountability Office noted that absent modernization ``the
Federal role in housing finance is one of the highest risks
facing the Government,'' and thus Congress has a duty to ensure
that any reform proposals ``protect taxpayers from absorbing
avoidable losses to the maximum extent possible.''
This resolution supports financial safeguards to ensure
that federally subsidized telecommunications access for
Americans in rural or underserved areas is free from waste,
fraud, and abuse. Furthermore, the budget supports any efforts
by the appropriate committees to examine policies to give the
private market more freedom to provide these services.
Budget Function 400: TRANSPORTATION
The Transportation function focuses on aid and regulation
for ground transportation (including roads and highways,
railroads, and urban mass transit), air transportation
(including aeronautical research conducted by the National
Aeronautics and Space Administration), and maritime commerce.
The major agencies included in this function are the Department
of Transportation (including the Federal Aviation
Administration, Federal Highway Administration, Federal Transit
Administration, and Maritime Administration), the Department of
Homeland Security (including the Transportation Security
Administration, United States Coast Guard, and the Federal Air
Marshal Service), and the National Railroad Passenger
Corporation.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $89.1 billion in budget authority and $92.9 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $33.7
billion, with $91.9 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $55.4 billion in budget authority and $1.0 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $749.7
billion, and outlays are $812.1 billion, a divergence of $207.7
billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The Federal Government has a fundamental interest in the
transportation and infrastructure systems necessary for local,
national, and global commerce, as well as the efficient
movement of people. Maintaining safe and secure systems while
promoting innovation and competition benefits American workers,
businesses, and the economy. This budget supports efforts by
the appropriate authorizing committees to maximize taxpayer
resources by prioritizing infrastructure spending, streamlining
project delivery, and facilitating beneficial public-private
partnerships.
This resolution supports the idea that investments in
transportation and infrastructure would benefit from improved
project delivery and grant management processes, starting with
a thorough review of Federal rules and regulations associated
with infrastructure development. By streamlining these
requirements through statutory and administrative changes,
investments will be maximized and benefits realized sooner.
Furthermore, the Government Accountability Office recommends
that the Transportation Department implement a department-wide
directive on the consistent administration of discretionary
grant awards and strengthen oversight of awards through updated
single audit policies and procedures. All these changes would
stimulate continued investment in America's infrastructure
while promoting efficiency and fiscal responsibility.
As Congress continues to work with the executive branch,
State and local governments, and the private sector on
legislation related to transportation and infrastructure
advancement, it should encourage enhanced partnerships among
all stakeholders. While not appropriate for every project,
furthering public-private partnerships, as well as promoting
private investments, can help leverage appropriate Federal
resources as recommended by appropriate authorizing committees.
Budget Function 450: COMMUNITY AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
The Community and Regional Development function includes
Federal programs to improve community economic conditions,
promote rural development, and assist in Federal preparations
for, and response to, disasters. This function provides
appropriated funding for the Community Development Block Grant,
Department of Agriculture rural development programs, Bureau of
Indian Affairs, Federal Emergency Management Agency, and other
disaster mitigation and community development-related programs.
It also provides mandatory funding for the Federal flood
insurance program.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $19.0 billion in budget authority and $21.7 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $18.5
billion, with $21.1 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $0.5 billion in budget authority and $0.6 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $200.6
billion, with $193.6 billion in outlays, a positive divergence
of $32.6 billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
This budget supports efforts by committees of jurisdiction
to better target existing Federal grant programs and eliminate
ineffective, wasteful programs, as well as those that encourage
an over-reliance on the Federal Government. In concert with
appropriate local and State efforts, the Federal Government has
the opportunity to be a better and more successful partner.
The budget provides ample resources for disaster relief and
mitigation and assumes at least $7 billion annually for
responses to natural disasters. This additional funding is
assumed to be provided on top of the regular funding
constrained by statutory limits.
Budget Function 500: EDUCATION, TRAINING, EMPLOYMENT, AND SOCIAL
SERVICES
The Education, Training, Employment, and Social Services
function includes funding for the Department of Education, some
social services programs within the Department of Health and
Human Services, and employment and training programs within the
Department of Labor.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $90.2 billion in budget authority and $99.3 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $95.4
billion, with $96.0 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $^5.1 billion in budget authority and $3.4 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $1,017.0
billion, with $1,030.3 billion in outlays, a divergence of
$131.7 billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
Postsecondary education has become less affordable in
recent years, despite the steady growth in the maximum Federal
Pell Grant program award and the loosening of student-loan
borrowing limits. In order to increase access to postsecondary
education in a fiscally responsible way, the Federal Government
should reform programs that promote unreasonable higher-
education tuition increases and encourage student over-
borrowing. The complex system bred over the past decade needs
to be streamlined to ensure American students and their
families have access to concise and distinct financing options.
In promoting choice, it is imperative that the information
received from the Federal Government by education consumers is
accurate and reliable. The budget resolution supports important
steps to ensure that student borrowers receive important and
valid information upfront. Providing greater transparency for
students will promote better decisionmaking and improve their
finances as they begin their careers, rather than saddle them
with decades-worth of debt.
Budget Function 550: HEALTH
The Health function contains spending on a variety of
health care services administered by the Department of Health
and Human Services. It also includes health research conducted
by the National Institutes of Health; public health and safety
programs conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention; primary health care services conducted by the
Health Resources and Services Administration; and the
regulation of pharmaceuticals, medical devices, and food
products conducted by the Food and Drug Administration. The
most significant drivers of spending in this function are the
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act--commonly known as
Obamacare--and Medicare.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $546.6 billion in budget authority and $558.3 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $64.0
billion, with $63.5 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $482.6 billion in budget authority and $494.8
billion in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals
$5,958.1 billion, and outlays are $5,952.4 billion, a
divergence of $1,316.2 billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
Federal health care spending comprises nearly 30 percent of
all Federal spending and is growing far more rapidly than other
areas of the budget. This rapid expansion is due to the rising
cost of health care, aging of the population, and substantial
increase in the number of people who receive Federal subsidies
under Obamacare.
Based on Congressional Budget Office estimates, Obamacare
will be the chief driver of spiraling health spending over the
next decade--this despite promises prior to passage of the 2010
health care law that it would improve the Nation's budgetary
outlook and ``bend the cost curve.'' Despite this pledge,
independent assessments by CBO and the non-partisan actuary at
the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services affirm that
Obamacare has increased Federal health spending.
Americans face skyrocketing premiums and soaring
deductibles, and many families are left with higher costs and
fewer options than they had before the law's enactment 7 years
ago. Clearly, the status quo is unsustainable.
Against this backdrop, the budget resolution supports
continued efforts to repeal and replace Obamacare. It enables
efforts by authorizing committees to lower health care costs
and improve the quality of care for all Americans. It empowers
committees to work to modernize and improve Federal health care
programs, increase State flexibility, and protect the most
vulnerable. In addition, the budget supports an extension in
funding for the State Children's Health Insurance Program, the
highly successful effort to create a strong and durable
partnership between the Federal Government and States to
provide the Nation's children with appropriate and sustainable
health care resources.
Budget Function 570: MEDICARE
The Medicare function includes only the Medicare program,
which provides health insurance to senior citizens and certain
persons with disabilities. Nearly 99 percent of spending in
this function occurs on the mandatory side of the budget, and
almost all of the mandatory spending consists of payments for
Medicare benefits. The balance of spending is discretionary
annual appropriations covering the cost of administering and
monitoring the Medicare program.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $586.2 billion in budget authority and $586.0 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $7.4 billion,
with $7.5 billion in related outlays. Mandatory spending is
$578.8 billion in budget authority and $578.5 billion in
outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $8,153.7
billion, and outlays are $8,151.4 billion, a divergence of
$472.9 billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
Medicare spending is on an unsustainable course. Without
changes, Medicare's Hospital Insurance Trust Fund will become
insolvent in 2029, according to the Medicare Trustees' current-
law projections, and potentially as early as 2023 under the
trustees' high-cost scenario. The Congressional Budget Office
estimates the trust fund will be fully exhausted within less
than a decade, or by 2025.
In addition, the independent actuaries at the Centers for
Medicare and Medicaid Services project that over a 75-year
period the Federal Government has promised $33.5 trillion in
Medicare benefits in excess of dedicated sources of revenue to
support the program.
Given this untenable situation, the budget resolution
supports work by the authorizing committees to recommend
legislative solutions extending Medicare's solvency in the near
term, while pursuing policies that place the program on a
sustainable long-term path.
Budget Function 600: INCOME SECURITY
The Income Security function covers a range of income
security programs that provide cash or near-cash assistance to
low-income persons and benefits to certain retirees, persons
with disabilities, and the unemployed.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $492.0 billion in budget authority and $477.5 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $66.9
billion, with $66.3 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $425.1 billion in budget authority and $411.2
billion in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals
$5,123.1 billion, with $5,029.8 billion in outlays, a
divergence of $653.0 billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
Participation in programs funded through this area of the
budget typically increase during a recession and decrease
during a recovery. But the most recent recession-recovery trend
has been different: Participation rates in some programs have
increased more than poverty or unemployment rates and have
remained at elevated levels.
Over the past several years, many States relaxed
eligibility standards and increased enrollment for persons
above the poverty level, threatening the fiscal sustainability
of these programs.
Additionally, waste, fraud, and abuse continue to plague
some programs. The Treasury Department's Inspector General has
reported that millions of people not authorized to work in the
United States have claimed billions of dollars in refundable
child tax credits.
According to the Government Accountability Office,
eligibility rules for Federal income-security programs are
complex and confusing to applicants and administratively
burdensome to Government agencies. The lack of a standard
definition of eligible family members and variations in
countable income and allowable deductions result in disparate
treatment of similarly situated individuals.
The budget resolution assumes that Congress will make
improvements to the programs in this function, ensuring
programs for vulnerable populations will be protected. This
budget supports authorizing committees acting on reforms
providing States with flexibility so that they can target
assistance to those most in need. In addition, the budget
assumes that the committees of jurisdiction will exercise
fiscal discipline and work to reduce spending on duplicative
and wasteful programs.
Regarding Federal retirement programs, this budget
prioritizes fiscal sustainability, specifically as it relates
to the benefits that Federal employees have earned over a
lifetime of service. It is imperative that the Federal employee
benefit system be reformed to ensure fairness to both
recipients and taxpayers.
Budget Function 650: SOCIAL SECURITY
The Social Security function consists of the payroll-tax-
financed programs collectively known as Social Security: Old-
Age and Survivors Insurance and Disability Insurance. These
programs provide monthly cash benefits to approximately 61
million retired and disabled workers and their spouses,
dependents, and survivors. This function includes both benefit
payments and funds to administer the programs and ensure
program integrity.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $999.0 billion in budget authority and $994.0 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $5.6 billion,
with $5.6 billion in related outlays. Mandatory spending is
$993.4 billion in budget authority and $988.4 billion in
outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $13,219.8
billion, with $13,154.7 billion in outlays, corresponding to
baseline levels. These figures reflect the combined on- and
off-budget amounts associated with this function.
Budget Function 700: VETERANS BENEFITS AND SERVICES
The Veterans Benefits and Services function includes health
administration and health services for veterans (majority of
the discretionary spending), their pensions and disability
compensation (majority of the mandatory spending), and other
services our Nation provides to veterans.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $176.4 billion in budget authority and $177.4 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $78.2
billion, with $76.5 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $98.2 billion in budget authority and $100.9
billion in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals
$2,157.0 billion, with $2,138.3 billion in outlays,
corresponding to baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The Committee-reported budget resolution assumes no changes
for the Veterans Benefits and Services function and is focused
on providing America's veterans with the care and resources
they have earned and need.
This budget supports the work of the committees of
jurisdiction as they consider common-sense proposals to ensure
benefits are delivered in a manner that upholds fidelity to
veterans and taxpayers alike.
Anticipating reauthorization of the Veterans Choice
Program, authorizing committees should focus on prompt delivery
of care to eligible veterans, along with measurable health
outcomes. A thoughtful examination of VA benefit programs--many
of which have not been reformed for several decades--could take
into account contemporary economic and labor-market criteria,
as well as advances in medical technology, in order to better
match benefits to veteran needs.
In a positive development, Congress has acted to grant the
VA additional authority and oversight to ensure veterans are
served by the best possible work force. The VA should continue
its work to implement reforms that will increase service and
efficiency for veterans, including a focused standardization of
care, modernization of health information technology,
appropriate management of Federal real property assets, and
vigilance in human-capital management.
Budget Function 750: ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE
The Administration of Justice function includes programs to
provide judicial services, police protection, law enforcement,
civil rights, rehabilitation and incarceration of criminals,
and the general maintenance of domestic order.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $65.0 billion in budget authority and $61.0 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $58.0
billion, with $57.1 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $7.0 billion in budget authority and $3.9 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $688.8
billion, with $691.4 billion in outlays, a divergence of $21.4
billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The Federal Government has a duty to maintain domestic
order, ensuring the safest possible community for all
Americans. To that end, the Government provides and supports
law enforcement activities; affords a judicial system to
peacefully adjudicate disputes and protect rights; and
rehabilitates and incarcerates persons found guilty of criminal
conduct. At the same time, the Government must carry out these
duties in a fiscally responsible way.
In order to achieve both a proper administration of justice
and stewardship of taxpayer dollars, the resolution supports
work by the appropriate committees of jurisdiction. The
Government Accountability Office recommends that the Department
of Justice better address the incarceration challenges of
crowding, rising costs, and offender recidivism, as well as
improve collaboration among the Department of Justice, the
Department of Homeland Security, and the Office of National
Drug Control Policy to streamline activities. In addition, GAO
offers several ways for the Federal Bureau of Investigation to
better handle whistleblower retaliation complaints, as well as
for the Bureau and Justice to update technology to improve
privacy, accuracy, and efficiency of computer systems.
Furthermore, GAO urges Homeland Security to better focus on
border security efforts by improving acquisition management,
controlling fraud, and investing in tactical infrastructure.
Committee recommendations to reform or eliminate
underperforming, wasteful programs could allow the Justice
Department to focus on vital services that spend American
taxpayer dollars wisely for good results.
Budget Function 800: GENERAL GOVERNMENT
The General Government function includes the activities of
the White House and the Executive Office of the President, the
legislative branch, and programs to carry out the
administrative responsibilities of the Federal Government,
including personnel management, fiscal operations, and property
control.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $24.7 billion in budget authority and $24.9 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $17.4
billion, with $17.7 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $7.3 billion in budget authority and $7.2 billion
in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $276.7
billion, with $274.4 billion in outlays, a divergence of $0.1
billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The General Government function encompasses many of the
programs and activities that constitute the operational
responsibilities of the Federal Government. It also funds the
salaries of Federal lawmakers and White House officials, as
well as those who staff Congress and the Executive Office of
the President. The budget resolution supports reforms, subject
to the discretion of committees of jurisdiction, for these
entities to help contribute to Federal fiscal discipline.
Budget Function 900: NET INTEREST
The Net Interest function contains the interest paid to
private and foreign government holders of U.S. Treasury
securities. This function includes interest on the public debt
less the interest received by the Federal Government from trust
fund investments and loans to the public. It contains mandatory
payments, with no discretionary components.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $307.0 billion in budget authority and $307.0 billion
in outlays, all of which is mandatory spending. Over 10 years,
budget authority totals $5,223.4 billion, with $5,223.4 billion
in outlays, a divergence of $259.0 billion from baseline
levels. These figures reflect the combined on- and off-budget
amounts associated with this function.
FOCUS ON REFORM
Outlays in this function respond entirely to the changes in
annual total budget deficits and borrowing from the public to
meet or pay those deficits. The changes in spending and revenue
levels described elsewhere in this budget account for all
changes in net interest outlays.
Budget Function 920: ALLOWANCES
The Allowances function displays the budgetary effects of
proposals that cannot be easily distributed across other budget
functions.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $^68.6 billion in budget authority and $^51.1 billion
in outlays. Discretionary budget authority totals $^38.5
billion, with $^21.1 billion in related outlays. Mandatory
spending is $^30.1 billion in budget authority and $^30.0
billion in outlays. Over 10 years, budget authority totals
$^2,356.5 billion, with $^2,217.5 billion in outlays, a
divergence of $^1,793.2 billion from baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
Spending levels in the Allowances function reflect policy
assumptions that have an impact across Federal agencies or are
not easily distributed across budget functions. This is a
similar approach used by the Congressional Budget Office in its
budget projections. This year changes to the nondefense
discretionary topline are included in this function to better
reflect the operation and realities of the congressional budget
and appropriations process. Also included is the fiscal benefit
scored by CBO for the budget resolution's deficit trajectory.
Budget Function 950: UNDISTRIBUTED OFFSETTING RECEIPTS
The Undistributed Offsetting Receipts function comprises
major offsetting receipts items that would distort the funding
levels of other functional categories if they were distributed
to them.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $^112.6 billion in budget authority and $^112.6
billion in outlays, all of which is mandatory spending. Over 10
years, budget authority totals $^1,292.7 billion, with
$^1,292.7 billion in outlays, a divergence of $217.3 billion
from baseline levels. These figures reflect the combined on-
and off-budget amounts associated with this function.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The Undistributed Offsetting Receipts function captures the
receipt effects of proposals in the budget. This function
comprises major offsetting receipts items that would distort
the funding levels of other functional categories if they were
directly distributed, including asset sales, fees, and
royalties.
Budget Function 970: OVERSEAS CONTINGENCY OPERATIONS//GLOBAL WAR ON
TERRORISM
This function includes funding for overseas contingency
operations, the global war on terrorism, and other closely
related activities.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $76.6 billion in total budget authority and $43.1
billion in total outlays. All spending in this function is
discretionary. Over 10 years, budget authority totals $163.6
billion, with $160.3 billion in outlays. The baseline used to
construct this resolution does not include an extrapolation of
war costs.
FOCUS ON REFORM
Besides the regular budget authority for national defense
and international affairs, the budget resolution includes $76.6
billion in overseas contingency operations funding for fiscal
year 2018, matching the president's request. This resolution
also includes outyear placeholders for OCO funding. While there
are no policy options associated with this funding, this
resolution is consistent with previous budget resolutions in
assuming outyear placeholders.
This function was first included in the fiscal year 2016
congressional budget resolution.
Revenues
Federal revenues are comprised of taxes and other
collections from the public that result from the Government's
sovereign powers to impose levies under Article I, section 8,
clause 1 of the U.S. Constitution. Federal revenues include
individual and corporate incomes taxes, social insurance taxes,
excise taxes, estate and gift taxes, customs duties, and
miscellaneous receipts.
SUMMARY OF COMMITTEE-REPORTED RESOLUTION
The Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget resolution
calls for $3,364.2 billion in revenues ($2,490.9 billion on-
budget, $873.3 billion off-budget). Over 10 years, revenues
total $41,381.0 billion ($31,171.5 billion on-budget, $10,209.5
billion off-budget), a divergence of $1,635.4 billion (on-
budget) below baseline levels.
FOCUS ON REFORM
The budget resolution assumes the tax-writing committees
will adopt a pro-growth tax reform proposal.
American taxpayers need a simpler, fairer, and more
transparent tax system. Comprehensive tax reform should broaden
the base while lowering marginal rates, streamline U.S. tax
laws, and limit the Government's distortion of market-based
decisions. A tax overhaul would increase private investment,
business expansion, U.S. economic output, and job creation.
Furthermore, accelerated economic growth would raise taxable
income and profits, thereby increasing Federal revenues through
taxation.
Subject to the discretion of the authorizing committees,
pro-growth tax reform should eliminate special deductions,
loopholes, and credits that distort investment in the
marketplace. A more efficient tax system would produce the same
level of revenue with lower rates, provided tax expenditures
are minimized and the economy grows by allowing for market-
based decisions.
U.S. businesses need tax reform to remain competitive at
home and abroad and to provide more American jobs. There should
be parity for small and pass-through business, as compared to
corporations. A globally competitive corporate tax rate and an
international tax system that does not penalize U.S. companies
are essential to promote domestic investment.
RECONCILIATION AND ENFORCEMENT
----------
To help achieve the goals of this budget, the resolution
includes reconciliation instructions and budget enforcement
tools that will help bring Federal spending programs in line
with the blueprint, allow for comprehensive tax reform, and
generate economic growth.
Reconciliation
This title includes two reconciliation instructions to
Senate committees. The first would allow the Finance Committee
to reduce revenues and change outlays to increase the deficit
by not more than $1.5 trillion over the next 10 years. The
second instructs the Energy and Natural Resources Committee to
save at least $1 billion over the next 10 years. This title
also includes instructions to the appropriate House committees
to mirror the Senate instructions.
Enforcement
Updates Advance Appropriations.--This section updates an
existing point of order against appropriations legislation that
would provide an advance appropriation for a discretionary
account. This point of order is extended regularly in budget
resolutions, and provides an exception for programs or
activities identified in the manager's joint explanatory
statement, the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, and several
accounts at the Department of Veterans Affairs. In addition to
the accounts in the legislative text, other accounts eligible
for advance appropriations include: Payment to Postal Service,
Employment and Training Administration, Education for the
Disadvantaged, School Improvement, Special Education, Career,
Technical and Adult Education, Tenant-Based Rental Assistance,
and Project-Based Rental Assistance.
Extends and Restates CHIMPS Points of Order.--This
resolution includes two points of order against changes in
mandatory programs (CHIMPS). The first point of order is an
extension of a currently enforced point of order. The provision
prohibits consideration of any measure that provides full-year
appropriations that includes CHIMPS above a certain limit. This
resolution restates the existing limits for 2018 and 2019, and
extends the 2019 level through 2020. Additionally, this
resolution closes an enforcement loophole on CHIMPS with net
costs.
Reinstates a Limit on the Crime Victims Fund CHIMP.--This
resolution protects the Crime Victims Fund by reinstating a 60-
vote point of order against any provision that would cause the
total budget authority of the Crime Victims Fund in fiscal year
2018 to be more than $11.2 billion.
Overseas Contingency Operations Designation.--This
resolution establishes a 60-vote point of order against
provisions that designate spending as funding for overseas
contingency operations. Similar in operation to emergency
designation points of order, this point of order would allow
solely the designation to be struck.
Protects the Integrity of the Reconciliation Process.--If
the Chairman of the Budget Committee, in his role as
scorekeeper, cannot determine the budgetary effects of an
amendment to a reconciliation bill, then the resolution
establishes a 60-vote point of order against the amendment. In
order to use this point of order, the Chairman will need to
file a statement in the Congressional Record after consultation
with the Ranking Member.
Creates a New One-Year Senate PAYGO Test.--Currently,
Senate PAYGO is enforced on a 6- and 11-year test. This section
repeals the previously enforced Senate PAYGO rule, and instead
restates the 6- and 11-year tests with new current year and
budget year tests. Consistent with past practice, the Senate
PAYGO scorecard will be reset to zero following a final
agreement on the fiscal year 2018 budget resolution.
Reactivates Dynamic Scoring Authority.--This resolution
directs the Congressional Budget Office and the Joint Committee
on Taxation to incorporate the budgetary effects of
macroeconomic variables when each produces estimates of major
legislation. These estimates will be used for informational
purposes only. These more accurate assessments will help guide
the Senate in its work both as a legislative body and financial
steward of the United States.
Adjustment Authority for Discretionary Cap Deal.--If a
measure becomes law that amends the discretionary limits
established under the Balanced Budget and Emergency Deficit
Control Act of 1985, then the Chairman of the Budget Committee
has the ability to adjust committee allocations.
Allows for Adjustments for Wildfire Suppression Funding.--
This resolution allows for adjustments to committee allocations
to account for any legislation that would provide for wildfire
suppression.
Improves Oversight of Spending.--This resolution allows the
Chairman of the Budget Committee to adjust direct spending
levels in the resolution following enactment of legislation
that would change a program from a mandatory to a discretionary
account. This adjustment will ensure savings generated on the
mandatory side of the ledger are not used to then offset new
spending.
Lifts Previous Constraints on Senate Consideration of
Certain Legislation.--The fiscal year 2016 budget resolution
established two points of order that constrained the Senate's
ability to consider certain types of legislation. In operation,
these points of order were unnecessarily restrictive to the
deliberative nature of the institution. As such, this
resolution repeals them.
Provides a Technical Correction Relating to Emergency
Provisions.--This section repeals the previously enforced
emergency designation process, and restates it with a technical
correction.
Provides for Enforcement Filing in the Senate.--Under this
resolution, the Chairman of the Budget Committee has the
ability to file committee allocations if this resolution passes
both the House and Senate, in identical form, and a conference
committee is not convened, and a joint explanatory statement is
not produced. This is important for committee allocation budget
enforcement procedures contained in the Congressional Budget
Act of 1974.
Encourages Oversight of Government Performance.--This
resolution directs Senate committees to identify waste, fraud,
abuse, and duplication in Federal programs. The resolution also
leads the committees to review recommendations offered by the
Government Accountability Office, so Congress can better
exercise its important oversight function. Committees are asked
to provide their ideas for reform in their annual Views and
Estimates report.
Establishes the Budgetary Treatment of Discretionary
Administrative Expenses.--This resolution requires that the
committee allocations found in the joint explanatory statement
accompanying the conference report on the budget resolution
include amounts for the discretionary administrative expenses
of the Social Security Administration and the United States
Postal Service. These amounts are crucial because these
expenses are subject to the discretionary spending caps.
Allows for Changes in Allocations and Aggregates.--This
section provides three necessary provisions relating to the
timing and mechanics of budget enforcement. First, if any
adjustments are made pursuant to a reserve fund or other
directive, the adjustments will apply while a measure is under
consideration, take effect once the measure is enacted, and be
published in the Congressional Record. Second, any revisions to
allocations and aggregates will be considered as if they were
contained in this budget resolution. Third, Budget Committee
estimates will serve as the basis for determining new levels of
budget authority, outlays, direct spending, new entitlement
authority, revenues, deficits, and surpluses.
Allows for Changes in Concepts and Definitions.--If
Congress were to enact a bill or joint resolution that changes
a concept or definition, then the resolution provides the
Chairman of the Budget Committee the authority to change levels
and allocations in the resolution, accordingly.
Allows for Adjustments to Reflect Legislation Not Included
in the Baseline.--This section allows the Chairman of the
Budget Committee to make adjustments to levels and allocations
in the resolution to accommodate legislation enacted before
bicameral agreement of this resolution, if the legislation was
not yet incorporated into the June 2017 Congressional Budget
Office's baseline. CBO's June 2017 baseline is the basis for
enforcement of this resolution.
Exercises in Rulemaking Power.--This section provides that
the Senate has the constitutional authority to adopt the rules
of this resolution, and the adopted rules shall be treated as
Senate rules. Further, these rules supersede any prior,
inconsistent rules.
ECONOMICS
----------
Table 1 shows the assumed levels and rates of change for
key economic variables that constitute the economic assumptions
of the Senate Budget Committee-reported fiscal year 2018 budget
resolution. The Budget Committee adopted the Congressional
Budget Office's (CBO) economic forecasts and projections as
published in its June 2017 An Update to the Budget and Economic
Outlook report in order to maintain consistency with its
baseline selection. The CBO assumptions are based on current
law, with regulations and major policies remaining as in
statute over the budget period, and do not include the impact
of proposed policy changes in the resolution.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Comparison with Other Forecasters
Table 2 shows how CBO's assumptions compare with economic
forecasts made by private sector economists (as reported by
Blue Chip Economic Indicators) and with the White House Office
of Management and Budget, or OMB (as reported in the Analytical
Perspectives, Budget of the U.S. Government, Fiscal Year 2018).
Table 2 differs slightly from Table 1 in that it contains
calendar year forecasts, while Table 1 shows fiscal year
forecasts. It was necessary to move to calendar year annual
rates of change for Table 2 due to Blue Chip's convention of
only publishing calendar year forecasts. The publication dates
of the various forecasts also differ. While the forecasts put
out by OMB and the Blue Chip were finalized around March 2017,
the CBO forecast was updated with its June 2017 publication.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
State of the Economy
Real, inflation-adjusted, growth in gross domestic product
(GDP) has averaged 2.1 percent (fourth-quarter-on-fourth-
quarter) since 2010. This is in contrast to historical annual
growth rates, which have averaged 2.9 percent over the past 50
years and 3.2 percent in the postwar era. Under the policies in
current law, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects
U.S. economic growth will decline to a long-term trend of 1.9
percent annually.
Following the November 2016 U.S. presidential election,
market confidence has experienced sustained growth. All three
major stock indexes (Dow Jones, S&P 500, and Nasdaq) hit record
highs. Consumer spending, which accounts for more than two-
thirds of economic activity, matched market confidence with
consistent growth month-to-month.
Economic growth was boosted in the second quarter of 2017,
with the Commerce Department showing an annual rate of 3.1
percent GDP growth, as compared to the first quarter of 2017
with only 1.2 percent growth. This increase reflects rising
personal consumption expenditure (PCE), nonresidential fixed
investment, exports, Federal Government spending, and private
inventory investment.
Growth in consumer spending, business investment, and
residential construction are expected to continue boosting the
economy in short-term predictions. But weak productivity growth
and demographic shifts in the labor market are expected to
create a drag on the supply side in the long term.
The August 2017 Bureau of Labor Statistics report shows
unemployment remains at 4.4 percent, with 1.7 million long-term
workers unemployed and 1.5 million marginally attached.
Frictional unemployment is a growing concern, as job openings
persist or increase. The current labor-participation rate of
62.9 percent has changed only slightly over the last year,
remaining at a persistently low level.
Total real private investment has rebounded past pre-2008
levels. Business investment is bolstered by confidence in the
economic outlook and higher consumer spending. Nonresidential
fixed investment has risen in 2017, and the rebuilding
following Hurricanes Harvey and Irma may raise residential
investment in the latter half of the year. The appreciation of
home values since the crash incentivizes further investment,
with housing permits and construction completions increasing.
Real Government consumption and expenditures may increase
in the latter half of 2017 in response to hurricane recovery
efforts. Real imports and exports continue to rise, and
predicted faster global growth could improve U.S. performance.
The value of the U.S. dollar has appreciated over the last few
years, making imported goods cheaper for consumers.
Oil and gas prices have stabilized somewhat after a period
of variability caused by supply controls abroad. U.S.
production of oil has trended toward levels last seen in 2015.
Hydraulic fracturing and new technologies that increase U.S.
oil and natural gas production have also moderated price
fluctuation in the global market.
The Federal Reserve continues to normalize monetary policy.
The Federal funds rate has risen to 1.25 percent, as officials
monitor inflation. Core PCE inflation remains below the target
rate of 2 percent. Net interest rates remain below average, but
the yield on the 10-year Treasury note increased in 2017.
Post-Policy Economic Growth
As mentioned above, CBO's economic assumptions do not
include the dynamic effects of the proposed policy changes in
the budget resolution. Instead, they are based on current law,
which reflects how the economy is expected to perform if
Congress fails to extend expiring tax provisions, reduce the
regulatory burden, or slow the growth of Federal spending. As
such, the continued anemic growth since the last recession can
be attributed in part to a failure to pursue more robust, pro-
growth policies.
While the numbers presented in the text of the budget
resolution rely on CBO's assumptions, the Budget Committee
expects that enactment of pro-growth policies could generate
sufficient economic growth to offset the static cost of the
$1.5 trillion in higher deficits allowed under the
reconciliation instruction. Assuming average economic growth of
2.6 percent over the next decade, rather than CBO's 1.8
percent, would reduce the annual deficits assumed in the budget
resolution, resulting in an on-budget surplus by the end of the
10-year budget window.
America has seen a dramatic decline in the rate of economic
growth since the last recession. The chart below shows the 10-
year period ending in 2016 had the lowest average annual growth
rate of any 10-year period since the end of World War II. The
ability to achieve a higher rate of growth depends on Congress
enacting the right policies. Those policies are supported by
this budget and include a combination of tax reform, regulatory
reform, budget reform, and fiscal discipline.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Encouraging Americans to work, save, and invest by reducing
regulatory barriers and improving economic incentives will
boost economic growth and create additional jobs, wages, and
profits. These dynamic effects, along with the elimination of
excessive tax loopholes, will help offset the projected static
cost of tax reform assumed in the reconciliation instruction.
RESERVE FUNDS
----------
The Senate Budget Committee does not have the authority to
make policy recommendations in a budget resolution--that is the
role of the authorizing committees. Committees often make their
policy priorities known in their Views and Estimates letters,
and reserve funds are a way to accommodate those requests.
Reserve funds allow the Chairman of the Budget Committee to
revise the committee allocations, budgetary aggregates, and
other appropriate levels in the budget resolution to
accommodate legislation described in the reserve fund--as long
as the budgetary effects of that legislation satisfy the
requirements enumerated. The Senate budget resolution includes
deficit-neutral reserve funds for legislation that would:
--Allow Congress to address Obamacare with legislation to
repeal or replace the program.
--Reform the American tax system--includes a revenue-
neutrality requirement.
--Extend the State Children's Health Insurance Program.
--Strengthen American families--including making it easier
to save for retirement; addressing the opioid epidemic;
assisting victims of domestic abuse; supporting foster care,
child care, marriage, and fatherhood programs; extending
expiring health care provisions; and improving housing
opportunities.
--Promote innovative educational and nutritional models and
systems for American students--including amending the Higher
Education Act, ensuring State flexibility in education,
enhancing job training, and reforming child nutrition programs.
--Improve the American banking system.
--Promote American agriculture, energy, transportation, and
infrastructure improvements.
--Restore American military power--including improving
military readiness and strengthening cybersecurity efforts.
--Improve benefit and services delivery for veterans and
service members.
--Relate to public lands and the environment--including
wildfire prevention and firefighting.
--Secure the American border.
--Promote economic growth and the private sector, and
enhance job creation.
--Reform statutory budget controls--including the Budget
Control Act's discretionary caps.
--Prevent bailouts of private pension plans.
--Implement work requirements in means-tested Federal
welfare programs.
--Protect Medicare.
--Make child and dependent care more affordable.
--Provide support for worker training programs.
The budget resolution includes a reserve fund for
legislation that would provide disaster funds for relief and
recovery efforts to areas devastated by hurricanes and flooding
in 2017.
The resolution includes a reserve fund that allows the
Chairman to make the adjustments necessary to accommodate
legislation considered as a result of the reconciliation
instructions.
SUMMARY TABLES
----------
Page
Table 1. Total Spending and Revenues............................. 38
Table 2. Spending by Function, Discretionary, Mandatory.......... 40
Table 3. Components of Deficit Reduction......................... 45
Table 4. Discretionary Topline................................... 46
Table 5. Allocation of Spending Authority to Senate Committee on
Appropriations for Fiscal Year 2018............................ 47
Table 6. Allocation of Spending Authority to Senate Committees
Other Than Appropriations...................................... 48
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
COMMITTEE VOTES
----------
On September 29, 2017, the ``Chairman's Mark'' for the
fiscal year 2018 budget resolution was provided to Budget
Committee Member offices.
On October 4, 2017, the Committee met to commence the
markup of the resolution and hear opening statements from
Members.
On October 5, 2017, the following votes were taken during
the Committee markup of the fiscal year 2018 budget resolution:
1. An amendment offered by Senator Sanders to create a
point of order against legislation that would provide a tax cut
for the top 1 percent wealthiest individuals.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. A motion to table the appeal of the ruling
of the Chair was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and 11
noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. An amendment offered by Senator Kennedy to establish a
deficit-neutral reserve fund relating to implementing work
requirements in all means-tested Federal welfare programs.
The amendment was agreed to by a voice vote.
3. An amendment offered by Senator King to establish a
deficit-neutral reserve fund relating to determining the impact
of work requirements on the economic security and health
coverage of recipients of Federal means-tested programs.
The amendment was not agreed to by a voice vote.
4. An amendment offered by Senator Sanders to create a
point of order against legislation that would cut Social
Security, Medicare, or Medicaid benefits.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. A motion to table the appeal of the ruling
of the Chair was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and 11
noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. An amendment offered by Senator Wyden to strike the
reconciliation instructions.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. An amendment offered by Senators Harris, Sanders,
Murray, Wyden, and Stabenow to increase spending in the
Medicare Function (570) by $473 billion.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. An amendment offered by Senator Gardner to establish a
deficit-neutral reserve fund to protect Medicare and repeal the
Independent Payment Advisory Board.
The amendment was agreed to by a voice vote.
8. An amendment offered by Senators Stabenow, Sanders, and
Van Hollen to increase spending in the Health Function (550).
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
9. An amendment offered by Senators Harris and Van Hollen
to create a point of order against legislation that would
increase taxes on taxpayers whose annual income is below
$250,000.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. A motion to table the appeal of the ruling
of the Chair was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and 11
noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
10. An amendment offered by Senator Kennedy to ensure tax
reform protects middle-income taxpayers
The amendment was agreed to by a voice vote.
11. An amendment offered by Senators King, Sanders,
Whitehouse, Warner, and Kaine to create a point of order
against budget reconciliation legislation that would increase
the deficit or reduce a surplus.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
12. An amendment offered by Senator Stabenow to create a
budget point of order against any legislation that would give a
tax cut to companies that offshore American jobs.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. A motion to table the appeal of the ruling
of the Chair was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and 11
noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
13. An amendment offered by Senators Kaine, Murray, Wyden,
Warner, King, and Harris to reinstate and expand the
requirement that a Congressional Budget Office (CBO) score be
publicly available for 28 hours prior to a vote on certain
legislation.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
14. An amendment offered by Senator Warner for the use of
CBO baseline to determine budgetary effects.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
15. An amendment offered by Senator Warner to strike pay as
you go (PAYGO) and short-term deficits exceptions.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
16. An amendment offered by Senator Van Hollen to create a
point of order against legislation that would repeal the estate
tax.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. A motion to table the appeal of the ruling
of the Chair was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and 11
noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
17. An amendment offered by Senator Kaine to make the
deficit-neutral reserve fund for tax reform revenue-neutral.
The amendment was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and
11 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
18. An amendment offered by Senators Merkley and Sanders to
create jobs by investing to rebuild our infrastructure paid for
by closing tax loopholes.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
19. An amendment offered by Senator Merkley to create a
point of order against legislation that would allow for a net
reduction of taxes paid by persons with income of more than a
million dollars.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. A motion to table the appeal of the ruling
of the Chair was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and 11
noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
20. An amendment offered by Senator Stabenow to create a
point of order against legislation that would turn Medicare
into a voucher program.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. A motion to table the appeal of the ruling
of the Chair was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and 11
noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
21. An amendment offered by Senator Wyden to strike the
deficit-neutral reserve fund for repeal of the Affordable Care
Act.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
22. An amendment offered by Senator Sanders to create a
deficit-neutral reserve fund for campaign finance reform.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. The amendment was not agreed to by a roll
call of 11 ayes and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
23. An amendment offered by Senators Kaine, Murray, Warner,
and King to provide relief from sequestration and to provide
adjustment authority for security and non-security spending.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call of 11 ayes
and 12 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X .....
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
24. An amendment offered by Senator King to establish a
deficit-neutral reserve fund for legislation that relates to
making the cost of child and dependent care more affordable and
useful for American families.
The amendment was agreed to by a voice vote.
25. An amendment offered by Senator Murray to ensure the
timely and adequate provision of disaster and other assistance
for relief and recovery efforts to Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin
Islands, Texas, Florida, and other areas of the United States
devastated by hurricanes and flooding in 2017.
The amendment was agreed to by a voice vote.
26. An amendment offered by Senators Van Hollen and Harris
to create a point of order against legislation that would
eliminate the deduction for State and local taxes.
The amendment was ruled out of order by the Chair. The
ruling was appealed. A motion to table the appeal of the ruling
of the Chair was agreed to by a roll call of 12 ayes and 11
noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
27. An amendment offered by Senator King to require the
Congressional Budget Office and the Joint Committee on Taxation
to produce estimates of certain distributional effects across
income categories resulting from major legislation.
The amendment was agreed to by a voice vote.
28. An amendment offered by Senator Kaine to establish a
deficit-neutral reserve fund relating to career and technical
education.
The amendment was not agreed to by a voice vote.
29. An amendment offered by Senator Harris to establish a
deficit-neutral reserve fund relating to worker training
programs, such as training programs that target workers that
need advanced skills to progress in their current profession or
apprenticeship or certificate programs that provide retraining
for a new industry.
The amendment was agreed to by a voice vote.
Following the vote on the Harris amendment, Senator Enzi
made a motion to report the resolution. The motion was agreed
to and the resolution was reported by a roll call vote of 12
ayes and 11 noes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name & Answer Name & Answer
State Aye No Present State Aye No Present
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ENZI (WY) X SANDERS X
(Chairma (VT)
n) (Ranking
)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRASSLEY X MURRAY X
(IA) (WA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRAPO X WYDEN X
(ID) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAHAM X STABENOW X
(SC) (MI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOOMEY X WHITEHOUS X
(PA) E (RI)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOHNSON X WARNER X
(WI) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORKER X MERKLEY X
(TN) (OR)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PERDUE X KAINE X
(GA) (VA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
GARDNER X KING (ME) X
(CO)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
KENNEDY X VAN X
(LA) HOLLEN
(MD)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOZMAN X HARRIS X
(AR) (CA)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
STRANGE X
(AL)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
VIEWS AND ESTIMATES
----------
The Views and Estimates for fiscal year 2018 received from
the various committees follow:
Page
Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry............................. 64
Appropriations................................................... 67
Armed Services................................................... 75
Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs.............................. 79
Commerce, Science, and Transportation............................ 96
Energy and Natural Resources..................................... 122
Environment and Public Works..................................... 124
Finance.......................................................... 133
Foreign Relations................................................ 145
Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions........................... 151
Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs....................... 188
Indian Affairs................................................... 222
Intelligence..................................................... 231
Joint Economic................................................... 232
Judiciary........................................................ 241
Rules and Administration......................................... 277
Small Business and Entrepreneurship.............................. 279
Veterans' Affairs................................................ 286
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
ADDITIONAL AND MINORITY VIEWS
----------
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Opening Statement of Senator Bernard Sanders
Mr. Chairman, let me begin by thanking you for doing what
no other previous Budget Committee Chairman has done: You have
released your budget resolution 5 days prior to our markup. And
I appreciate that very much.
At a time when the American people are dealing with the
horrible mass murder in Las Vegas, when we're dealing with the
incredible destruction that has taken place in Texas, Florida,
Puerto Rico, and the Virgin Islands because of the recent
hurricanes, people are asking, ``What else can go wrong? What
else do we have to worry about?''
And I am sorry to say that I have to inform the American
people that they do have something else to worry about--and
that is that this Republican budget we're dealing with today
is, in my view, the most unfair and destructive budget in the
modern history of this country. And, if it were to be passed,
it would do incalculable harm to tens of millions of working-
class and middle-class families.
In almost every instance this budget ignores the needs of
ordinary Americans and what the American people want while at
the same time it bends over backward to protect the interests
of the wealthiest and most powerful people in this country and
the largest campaign contributors.
This is a budget that moves this country rapidly into the
direction of oligarchy. It constitutes nothing less than a
massive transfer of wealth from working families, the elderly,
the children, the sick, and the poor to the top 1 percent.
It is the Robin Hood principle in reverse. It takes from
those in need and gives to those who are already living in
incredible opulence.
Many Americans thought that we finally ended the Republican
effort to throw millions of people off of the health insurance
they have when we defeated their effort to repeal the
Affordable Care Act. Unfortunately, if you believe that you are
wrong. The Republican attempt to destroy health care benefits
for millions of Americans continues in this document.
This Republican budget cuts Medicaid by more than $1
trillion over 10 years--throwing some 15 million Americans off
of the health insurance they currently have.
Further, this budget does what the Senate Republicans have
yet attempted to do this Congress and that is to make a $473
billion cut to Medicare.
Some of you may remember that during his campaign for
president Donald Trump told the American people that he would
not cut Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid.
For example, on April 18, 2015, Trump said: ``Every
Republican wants to do a big number on Social Security, they
want to do it on Medicare, they want to do it on Medicaid. And
we can't do that. And it's not fair to the people that have
been paying in for years and now all of the sudden they want to
be cut.''
Well, Mr. President: Tell your Republican friends around
this table that they should respect your campaign promises that
helped win you the election and that you will veto any
legislation that breaks those promises.
Mr. Chairman, at a time of massive wealth and income
inequality in this country, this budget makes a bad situation
worse, by providing huge tax breaks to the very rich.
According to the Tax Policy Center, by the end of the
decade, nearly 80 percent of the tax benefits of the Republican
plan would go to the top 1 percent--$1.9 trillion in tax
breaks.
Unbelievably, the top one-tenth of 1 percent would receive
some 40 percent of the tax breaks by the end of the decade.
Donald Trump claims that his tax plan helps the middle
class. But by repealing the personal exemption and the
deductions for State and local income taxes, his plan increases
taxes for about 30 percent of middle-class families--those that
are earning between $50,000 and $150,000 a year.
By repealing the estate tax this budget would give $269
billion in tax breaks to the Walton family, the Koch brothers'
family, the Trump family, and other multi-billionaire families.
And here's the rub. In order to pay for these huge tax
breaks for millionaires and billionaires, this Republican
budget makes savage cuts to the life and death programs that
mean so much to ordinary Americans--above and beyond the
disastrous cuts to Medicare and Medicaid.
If you are a lower income senior citizen, you may no longer
be able to keep your home warm in the winter because of a cut
of about $4 billion to the Low Income Home Energy Assistance
Program.
If you are a working-class student trying to figure out how
you could possibly afford college, your dream of a college
education could evaporate along with 8 million other students
because of more than $100 billion in cuts to Pell Grants and
other student financial assistance programs.
If you are a low-income pregnant woman, please know that
Republican budget would make about $6.5 billion in cuts to the
Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) eliminating nutrition
assistance to over 1.2 million pregnant women, new moms,
babies, and toddlers in Vermont and all over America.
At a time when millions of Americans are paying 40 or 50
percent of their limited incomes on housing, this budget
eliminates housing assistance for more than 1 million families
due to a cut of about $37 billion to the Section 8 rental
assistance program and other housing programs.
At a time when the cost of childcare has skyrocketed, the
Republican budget eliminates Head Start services for 25,000
children each and ever year by cutting this program by $3
billion.
In total, the Republican budget would cut more than $5
trillion from education, health care, affordable housing, child
care, transportation, and other programs that working people
desperately need over the next decade.
Why are the Republicans bringing forth such an absurd
budget which in almost every instance is diametrically opposed
to what the American people want?
Poll after poll after poll tells us that the American
people do not want us to cut Medicare or Medicaid or provide
tax breaks to the wealthy or large corporations.
A recent Pew Foundation poll finds that 85 percent of
Republicans and 94 percent of Democrats want to either maintain
or increase funding for Medicare. But they propose cutting it
by $473 billion.
Sixty percent of Americans oppose slashing Medicaid,
according to Quinnipiac poll from last week. But they cut
Medicaid by a trillion dollars.
A recent Wall Street Journal and NBC poll finds that only
12 percent of the American people believe the wealthy should
receive a tax cut; while 62 percent of Americans believe the
wealthy should pay more in taxes. But they are providing $1.9
trillion in tax breaks to the top 1 percent.
So how do these unfair and terribly unpopular policies come
about? And that my friends takes us into a whole other area
beyond the jurisdiction of this Committee. And that is the
corrupt campaign finance system which enables multi-billionaire
families like the Koch brothers to contribute many hundreds of
millions of dollars every campaign cycle to Republican
candidates.
This Republican budget is not a budget for the American
people. This is a budget for the Koch brothers and for the
billionaire class. This is a budget that makes the very rich
much richer and does devastating harm to some of the most
vulnerable people in this country. It must be defeated and
replaced by a budget that works for all of us, not just the 1
percent.
------
Opening Statement of Senator Kamala D. Harris
NO TAX INCREASES AMENDMENT
``To create a point of order against legislation that would increase
taxes on taxpayers whose annual income is below $250,000.''
Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Sanders, and colleagues, I
rise to offer Harris amendment #2. I ask unanimous consent for
Senator Van Hollen to be added as a cosponsor.
This amendment would ensure we are protecting middle-income
families from unfair tax increases.
This budget includes reconciliation instructions that would
increase the deficit by $1.5 trillion over the next decade.
Despite all of that new spending, it would do nothing to help
our struggling middle class.
In a new report, the Federal Reserve concluded that the top
1 percent now own nearly 40 percent of the Nation's wealth,
while the bottom 90 percent own 23 percent. The Republican
budget focuses on growing this imbalance between the wealthiest
Americans and the rest.
According to another recent report, from the Tax Policy
Center, the bottom 80 percent of households would receive only
13 percent of the tax cut in 2027. Most low- and middle-income
households would likely lose more from the budget cuts than
they would gain from the tax cuts.
My amendment would ensure that no additional harm is done
to the people who are working harder than ever to put food on
the table and provide for their families, secure a quality
education for their children, and have a chance to retire with
dignity.
Congress has the ability to make the tax code work for
middle and low income families. Instead, the Republican budget
wants to create more income inequality and transfer more wealth
from the middle class to the rich and to corporations--even
though one out of every five corporations pay nothing in income
taxes.
The budget cuts $5 trillion from programs that working
families desperately need. I hear from Californians daily
requesting better housing and nutritional assistance programs.
Yet, the Republican budget eliminates housing assistance for
more than 1 million families and nutrition assistance for
nearly 2 million women, infants and children.
This budget does very little for families and working
Americans. I say we instead keep our commitment to low and
middle-income taxpayers and protect them from tax hikes. I urge
my colleagues to vote YES on this amendment.
VOTING ON NO TAX INCREASES (ONE MINUTE RE-INTRODUCTION)
This amendment would create a point of order against
legislation that would increase taxes on taxpayers whose annual
income is below $250,000.
This budget does very little for families and working
Americans. Any tax reform legislation should be done in a
bipartisan way and in a way that does not raise taxes on the
middle class.
I urge my colleagues to vote YES on this amendment.
[all]