[Senate Hearing 119-537]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]
S. Hrg. 119-537
UPDATING AMERICA'S NUCLEAR WASTE
MANAGEMENT POLICY
=======================================================================
HEARING
before the
COMMITTEE ON
ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS
UNITED STATES SENATE
ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS
SECOND SESSION
__________
SEPTEMBER 23, 2026
__________
Printed for the use of the Committee on Environment and Public Works
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov
______
U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
65-521 WASHINGTON : 2026
COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS
ONE HUNDRED NINETEENTH CONGRESS
SECOND SESSION
SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West Virginia, Chairman
SHELDON WHITEHOUSE, Rhode Island, Ranking Member
KEVIN CRAMER, North Dakota BERNARD SANDERS, Vermont
CYNTHIA M. LUMMIS, Wyoming JEFF MERKLEY, Oregon
JOHN R. CURTIS, Utah EDWARD J. MARKEY, Massachusetts
DAN SULLIVAN, Alaska MARK KELLY, Arizona
PETE RICKETTS, Nebraska ALEX PADILLA, California
ROGER F. WICKER, Mississippi ADAM B. SCHIFF, California
JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas LISA BLUNT ROCHESTER, Delaware
JON HUSTED, Ohio ANGELA D. ALSOBROOKS, Maryland
DARLINE GRAHAM, South Carolina
Adam Tomlinson, Republican Staff Director
Dan Dudis, Democratic Staff Director
C O N T E N T S
----------
Page
SEPTEMBER 23, 2026
OPENING STATEMENTS
Capito, Hon. Shelley Moore, U.S. Senator from the State of West
Virginia....................................................... 1
Alsobrooks, Hon. Angela, U.S. Senator from the State of Maryland. 3
WITNESSES
Barrett, Lake, Chair, American Nuclear Society Nuclear Waste
Policy Task Force.............................................. 7
Prepared statement........................................... 9
Responses to additional questions from:
Senator Kelly............................................ 13
Senator Alsobrooks....................................... 15
McMurrian, Katrina, Executive Director, Nuclear Waste Strategy
Coalition...................................................... 19
Prepared statement........................................... 21
Responses to additional questions from:
Senator Kelly............................................ 35
Senator Alsobrooks....................................... 37
Huff, Kathryn, Ph.D., Professor and Department Chair, Department
of Nuclear Engineering and Engineering Physics, University of
Wisconsin-Madison.............................................. 41
Prepared statement........................................... 43
Responses to additional questions from:
Senator Whitehouse....................................... 48
Senator Kelly............................................ 51
Senator Alsobrooks....................................... 53
ADDITIONAL MATERIAL
Letter to Senator Capito and Senator Whitehouse from Nevada
Resort Association............................................. 5
UPDATING AMERICA'S NUCLEAR WASTE
MANAGEMENT POLICY
----------
WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 2026
U.S. Senate,
Committee on Environment and Public Works,
Washington, DC.
The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10 a.m. in room
406, Dirksen Senate Office Building, Hon. Shelley Moore Capito
(chairman of the committee) presiding.
Present: Senators Capito, Alsobrooks, Lummis, Curtis,
Husted, Markey, Blunt Rochester.
OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO,
U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
Senator Capito. Good morning, everybody. Good morning to my
Ranking Member, Senator Alsobrooks. Thank you. She remarked, as
we both know, that we are both Blue Devils, both graduates of
Duke University. If we start slipping into basketball talk, you
will understand that.
Welcome to today's hearing, to everybody. This morning, we
will discuss the status of and the need to update our Nation's
nuclear waste management policy. Nuclear energy is a
foundational part of America's energy systems that provides
reliable, clean power to our electric grid. This committee has
done quite a bit in this area in terms of nuclear.
However, nuclear power generation produces spent nuclear
fuel as a byproduct, which then must be safely managed and
disposed of. Who manages and disposes of this material and how
and where they do it has been a subject of national policy
discussions for 60 years. More than four decades ago, Congress
passed the Nuclear Waste Pokily Act, formalizing a national
framework to address the challenging issue.
While much progress has been made over multiple
administrations of both political parties, the Obama
administration illegally halted the program in 2010. Since
then, the Obama, Trump, and Biden administrations have all
considered different formulations and structures to a nuclear
waste program.
To work with States on nuclear waste disposal, the current
administration proposes to create Nuclear Lifecycle Innovation
campuses, or NLICs. This concept would co-locate nuclear
facilities that play a role in the entire nuclear supply chain,
as well as potentially other industrial facilities in
interested States. In return for the economic benefits
associated with these facilities, the host State would agree to
be the permanent disposal site for a portion of our Nation's
nuclear waste inventory.
To date, the Department of Energy has signed memorandums of
understanding with six States, including my State of West
Virginia, to further talks on the NLICs. This initial step is a
good conversation starter, and I appreciate the leadership of
the Department of Energy's Office of Nuclear Energy for this
effort.
Importantly, any new approach, including the NLIC
initiative, requires Congress to update the law. Today, we will
explore key principles that must be considered in future
legislation. First and foremost, history has shown that nuclear
waste management is a multi-generational infrastructure
project. A successful policy must be built for the long term,
and durable, with strong bipartisan buy-in from Congress.
Should West Virginia or any other State proceed forward and
sign an NLIC agreement, the full terms of the deal must be
clearly understood and legally enforceable. My constituents
need to know the answers to such question as, what is the
Federal Government's long-term commitment to the State. What is
the State's long-term commitment to the Federal Government?
What mechanisms are available to all parties to enforce an
agreement?
What are the forms and characteristics of the nuclear waste
that will be disposed in the State? What storage and disposal
facilities will be developed and how will these be safely
regulated? Last, how will the different provisions of the
agreement be funded?
Second, it is imperative that each potential host State has
confidence that nuclear waste will be safely managed, managed
alongside the numerous nuclear facilities that could compose
their innovation campus. For example, in moving away from a
single national nuclear waste repository, it must be clear what
disposal options are available to the many forms of radioactive
material.
New disposal technologies will also require clear
regulatory standards that can be relied upon to protect health
and safety for generations to come. The Nuclear Regulatory
Commission will be integral to this conversation.
For private entities that sign up to join an innovation
campus, the NRC will be responsible for licensing and
regulating these facilities, and must continue to prioritize
nuclear safety.
Finally, for potential host States, the private sector, and
the Federal Government, we must address the challenge of
properly funding a nuclear waste disposal program. Ratepayers
have paid the Federal Government to dispose of the spent
nuclear fuel generated at nuclear power plants. That fee was
collected and is accounted for, over $50 billion to date.
However, Congress did not appropriate sufficient funding
and the license, regulatory and program costs were never fully
covered. Ultimately, this lack of appropriated funding was the
reason that the Nuclear Waste Policy Act failed to achieve its
goals, and why we are here today.
We must ensure that there is a funding structure that gives
a new policy the best chance for success.
I look forward to exploring these issues today so I can
better understand how to deliver an effective, durable update
to our nuclear waste policy.
I will now recognize Senator Alsobrooks for her opening
statement.
OPENING STATEMENT OF HON. ANGELA ALSOBROOKS,
U.S. SENATOR FROM THE STATE OF MARYLAND
Senator Alsbrooks. Thank you so much, Madam Chair, and
thank you as well to all of our witnesses for joining us today.
Given the prevalence of nuclear in Maryland and the role
that it can play in lowering energy costs for consumers, I am
pleased to be standing in for our Ranking Member this morning.
The past 2 years have seen a major uptick in nuclear
activity from the passage of the ADVANCE Act to new NRC
licenses issued for advanced reactors and fuel facilities, to
dozens of projects and investment announcements from American
nuclear developers.
It is an exciting moment for American nuclear leadership,
and a new deployment. Let me say, not a moment too soon as the
Nation and world face a duel energy crunch and a worsening
climate crisis.
As we enter an age of new nuclear opportunity, we have yet
to address an old nuclear liability: the permanent disposal of
nuclear waste. Spent nuclear fuel from today's commercial
reactors can continue to be stored safely for decades. A
permanent solution is crucial if nuclear deployment is to
continue with credibility.
New coolants and fired-fuel types used in advanced nuclear
reactors will require new waste management approaches and
technical reviews to ensure safe disposal. Nuclear fuel
reprocessing can help reduce our waste problem by recovering
about 90 percent of the energy still contained in spent nuclear
fuel, reducing the amount and radioactivity of the waste left.
Reprocessing cannot fully eliminate the need for waste
disposal. Responsible development of nuclear power requires
durable solutions for waste management that have support from
all stakeholders. Current U.S. law under the Nuclear Waste
Policy Act, currently allows only Yucca Mountain to be
considered as the site of a repository, is not sufficient to
address the long-term challenges of nuclear waste disposal.
Updating our nuclear waste policy to incorporate the
technologies of the future and finally addressing the waste of
the past and present will be a major undertaking. Such an
effort can only succeed with technical rigor, meaningful
community engagement and durable regulation.
Short-term political decisions or shortcuts cannot drive a
process for developing disposal solutions that must last for
millennia. DOE can play an important role in spurring private
sector investment, but it cannot alone ensure the storage or
disposal of commercial nuclear waste. Long-term durability and
technical credibility in the licensing of waste storage and
disposal facilities can only be possible with an NRC license.
The legitimacy of any nuclear waste strategy and the
legitimacy of America's nuclear industry as a whole requires
NRC independence. I have raised concerns about efforts that
could undermine the NRC's independence as well as the need to
protect jobs and retain the experienced staff needed for the
agency to carry out its mission.
As the committee of jurisdiction, it is our responsibility
to exercise continual oversight to ensure that the strength of
NRC independence and its expert staff endures. I appreciate the
expertise of today's witnesses in providing insight and clarity
on the complex problem of nuclear waste, and look forward to
their testimony.
At this moment, Madam Chair, I would like to also ask
unanimous consent to insert a letter from the Nevada Resort
Association into the record.
Senator Capito. Without objection, so ordered.
[The referenced information follows:]
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Senator Alsobrooks. Thank you.
Senator Capito. Okay, I thank our witnesses for being here,
I really do. I would like to welcome our first presenter, Lake
Barrett, who is Chair of the American Nuclear Society's Nuclear
Waste Policy Task Force.
Mr. Barrett has been involved in numerous major nuclear
projects, including serving as site director for the cleanup of
the Three Mile Island reactor, running the Department of
Energy's nuclear waste program, and now as an advisor to the
Japanese Government on recovering from Fukushima.
Welcome, Mr. Barrett. You are now recognized for your
opening statement.
STATEMENT OF LAKE BARRETT, CHAIR, AMERICAN NUCLEAR SOCIETY
NUCLEAR WASTE POLICY TASK FORCE
Mr. Barrett. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman, Ranking Member
Alsobrooks, and members of the committee. I appreciate the
opportunity to testify before you today on behalf of the
American Nuclear Society about the opportunity that our Nation
has to update our nuclear waste management policies. Our
organization represents over 12,000 nuclear energy
professionals who have delivered safe, dependable and life-
saving nuclear technologies for over 70 years to the benefit of
our Nation and the world.
All energy-producing technologies generate waste that we
must manage responsibly for ourselves and future generations.
The good news is that used nuclear fuel from electricity
generation is a robust, compact and stable form that the
nuclear energy has a strong record of storing and transporting
very safely.
High level radioactive waste from reprocessing of spent
nuclear fuel can also be mobilized in robust, stable forms
suitable for geologic disposal. However, these materials do
remain highly radioactive for many years and must be isolated
from the environment for millennia.
The longstanding international consensus is that such
materials should ultimately be disposed of in stable geologic
formations and several countries are making very good progress
toward siting and actually constructing their repositories. We
in America have sadly fallen well behind and have accomplished
little for the past 16 years. We must now engage our great
American capabilities to revitalize and adapt to meet our
longstanding legal and moral obligations to the American
people.
Today, our U.S. electricity demand is rapidly rising, and
this makes sustaining nuclear energy expansion more important
than ever. This growth creates opportunity to break America's
longstanding stalemate over the permanent disposal of our used
nuclear fuel.
Growing State interest in an integrated nuclear fuel cycle
and disposal projects offers Congress an opportunity that can
advance our nuclear waste management disposal policy, help fuel
our next generation of nuclear reactors, and strengthen the
U.S. nuclear industrial base all at the same time.
The American Nuclear Society supports DOE's Nuclear
Lifecycle Innovation Campus initiative. This effort has helped
bring significant economic opportunities of the nuclear fuel
cycle into broad focus.
Potential host States and creative private industries are
now exploring the campuses that combine the nuclear fuel cycle,
recycling and disposal activities that are needed to support
our critically needed nuclear expansion and being able to find
actual geologic disposal sites.
Congress can assist in this work with a step-wise approach
that sustains willing State participation, begins to fulfill
Federal obligations for used nuclear fuel, and supports fuel
cycle innovation and protects affordability while maintaining
geologic disposal as an essential part of this effort as
recycling technologies and markets develop.
As this committee considers its near-term nuclear policy
agenda, the American Nuclear Society recommends a bipartisan
focus on these six priorities.
Enabling DOE to develop durable campus partnerships with
willing host States and private partners through business
agreements that define activities, milestones, benefits,
responsibilities and ultimate disposal pathways in a long-
lasting, durable manner.
Authorizing the investigation of permanent disposal
pathways beyond Yucca Mountain and advance the regulatory
framework needed to support different sites.
We have learned a lot from the Yucca Mountain and
international experiences, and this knowledge can improve our
regulatory framework for new potential geologic disposal sites
moving forward.
Enabling DOE to begin accepting and removing nuclear fuel,
especially that is stranded at permanently shut-down reactors,
through existing authorities and new authorities and resources
necessary to take title to that fuel, transport it, and store
it, including for potential recycling, within a program for
permanent, passive geologic disposal.
We should continue supporting recycling research and
development and early commercial deployment as these
technologies and markets mature.
We should also approach providing adequate resources for
DOE to carry out its statutory disposal mission, while relying
on private investment and other Federal and State support for
broader campus activities. This should include near-term robust
appropriations for DOE to start this process immediately.
Establishing clear organizational guidance for contractual
performance steps and sustainable durable partnership business-
like arrangements for the host States and their private
industry partners and local communities as well, utilizing our
Nation's exceptional commercial market, free market
capabilities.
In closing, our Society believes our Nation is now at a
point to be able to finally break out of a 16-year doldrum and
move forward with willing State and private industry partners
to work together to create a revised, integrated, innovative
nuclear waste management policy that can serve Americans now
and for hundreds of generations into the future. We can do this
as a nation if we have your support.
Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.
[The prepared statement of Mr. Barrett follows:]
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Senator Capito. Thank you.
Next, we will hear from Katrina McMurrian, Executive
Director of the Nuclear Waste Strategy Coalition, the NWSC. The
NWSC represents a broad membership of entities that advocate
for nuclear waste solutions, such as State utility regulators,
tribal and local governments, and electric companies that host
spent nuclear fuel onsite.
Ms. McMurrian, thank you for being here, and you are
recognized for your opening statement.
STATEMENT OF KATRINA McMURRIAN, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NUCLEAR
WASTE STRATEGY COALITION
Ms. McMurrian. Chairman Capito, Ranking Member Alsobrooks,
and members of the Environment and Public Works Committee,
thank you for this opportunity to testify on behalf of the
Nuclear Waste Strategy Coalition. I am Katrina McMurrian, the
Coalition's Executive Director.
The NWSC is an ad hoc organization formed in 1993 to
represent the collective interests of public and private
members on nuclear waste policy matters. Our work today remains
focused on, one, holding the Federal Government accountable for
its statutory and contractual obligations to secure a durable,
integrated waste disposal program for commercial spent fuel;
two, protecting electric utility customers; and three, securing
the leadership and sustainable funding for a decades-long
program to succeed.
We are member-led, bipartisan, purpose-driven, and will
happily disband when our mission is complete.
After enduring years of Federal failure, we are encouraged
by this hearing and by the administration's Nuclear Lifecycle
Innovation Campus initiative that reportedly includes the
critical waste disposal component. Having States as partners
should increase the likelihood of success.
As Congress considers next steps on nuclear waste policy,
the NWSC hopes the following will guide your work. First,
Congress must re-establish a national integrated nuclear waste
disposal program that includes four interconnected and
necessary components: removal, transportation, storage, and
essential permanent geologic disposal of spent nuclear fuel now
stranded at numerous operating and shut-down commercial reactor
sites in communities in 35 States. Yes, it is safely stored
onsite, but taxpayers are being charged millions each day
beyond the January 31st, 1998 checkout date established in
Federal law.
Second, evidence points to the need to form an independent
waste management organization outside of DOE. In the near term,
Congress should urge DOE's immediate reestablishment of an
internal office reporting directly to the Secretary that is
dedicated to a successful disposal program.
Not only does this comply with the Nuclear Waste Policy
Act, it prioritizes critical functions that have been neglected
to the detriment of existing host communities, electric
customers and all U.S. taxpayers.
Third, we call upon Congress to reform the Federal
budgetary treatment of the Nuclear Waste Fund, such that
sustainable access to the Fund is provided to support the
development of this multi-generational disposal program.
Congress has figured it out for other trust funds, and there is
no better time to restore the trust part for electric customers
who thus far have got nothing in return for the fund part,
meaning the part where they paid billions in fees until NARUC
and others sued to stop it.
In the interim, Congress can and should appropriately fund
DOE priorities that advance removal, transportation, storage
and permanent disposal through annual appropriations. The
Nuclear Waste Fund must only be used for its intended purpose,
which is to pay for the Federal waste disposal program. The
Nuclear Waste Fund's $51 billion balance, along with annual
interest accruals, provides more than sufficient funding for
virtually any program work for the foreseeable future.
Initiatives to restart the Nuclear Waste Fund fee should be
considered only after verified Federal performance and a
demonstration of need.
Finally, the NWSC recognizes that an integrated nuclear
waste program could include reprocessing or recycling, which we
view as complementary, not competing strategies with disposal.
While recycling may reduce waste volume, questions remain about
cost effectiveness and new waste streams. In any case, a
repository remains necessary under every scenario with
recycling or not.
In closing, permanent geologic disposal is foundational to
all effective nuclear waste policy approaches. The consequences
of prolonged Federal inaction to achieve disposal are
significant, but avoidable with timely action.
It is often said that the first question in any forum about
nuclear is, what about the waste? The experts have long had the
technical answers, but we have allowed those to be sidelined.
Nuclear waste storage and disposal facilities are critical
infrastructure that support an energy option that many of our
States are considering in real time to meet growing electricity
demand. Correctly and finally recognizing nuclear waste
disposal as critical infrastructure moves it from the nice-to-
have column to the must-have column.
We thank you for your leadership with respect to this call
to action. Thank you.
[The prepared statement of Ms. McMurrian follows:]
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Senator Capito. Thank you very much.
Our final witness is Dr. Kathryn Huff. She is a professor
and department chair for the Department of Nuclear Engineering
and Engineering Physics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Dr. Huff served as the Assistant Secretary for Nuclear Energy
at the DOE under President Biden, where she oversaw department
activity related to nuclear energy advancement, research and
development.
Welcome, Dr. Huff. Please proceed with your opening
statement.
STATEMENT OF KATHRYN HUFF, PH.D., PROFESSOR AND DEPARTMENT
CHAIR, DEPARTMENT OF NUCLEAR ENGINEERING AND ENGINEERING
PHYSICS, UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN-MADISON
Ms. Huff. Chair Capito, Ranking Member Alsobrooks, and
members of the committee, it is an honor to be with you today.
The United States safely manages over 90,000 metric tons of
used nuclear fuel in about 70 locations across the country. For
decades, electric consumers paid into the nuclear waste fee in
exchange for the Federal Government's acceptance and disposal
of that fuel. DOE was obligated to begin accepting it in 1998,
the year I turned 12, and has still not done so.
Consequently, taxpayers remain liable for continuing cost
of storage. Federal consolidated interim storage would begin to
solve both issues. During my time at DOE, Congress funded a
consent-based siting program that allowed us to begin
conversations with communities about hosting such a facility.
Those conversations confirmed that communities see greater
value in interim storage when it is connected to research,
laboratories, technology and sustained economic activity.
A campus that includes those advanced reactors and fuel
cycle research centers and recycling facilities would offer a
prospective host more than storage alone. DOE's vision of these
nuclear lifecycle innovation campuses has therefore inspired
productive engagement with States.
However, turning these conversations into operating
facilities will require authorization and appropriated funding
from Congress.
Sustaining public support will also require transparency
regarding ownership, costs, hazards and long-term
responsibilities, as well as accountability in case a
contractor withdraws or fails.
Recycling provides one productive purpose for these
campuses. We should recycle nuclear fuel for the same
sustainability reasons that we recycle aluminum and paper at
home. Used fuel contains recoverable energy and useful
isotopes.
Furthermore, recycling long-lived radionuclides can allow
radioactivity of the remaining waste to fall below that of
natural uranium ore in hundreds of years, rather than
thousands, simplifying the final repository.
Those benefits do not guarantee favorable economics.
Commercial scale civilian reprocessing has not developed
anywhere as a purely private market financed enterprise. La
Hague in France is operated by Orano, which is approximately 90
percent owned by the French government. Meanwhile, Rokkasho is
privately held but operates within a Japanese national
framework for consistent financing and regulation and waste
management more broadly.
Having visited both, I have seen the scale of the
infrastructure and management and government integration
involved. I would say that proposals of the U.S. facility that
can rely on market revenues alone for recycling should be
evaluated rigorously.
All that said, realizing the promise of these innovation
campuses will demand some clear division of institutional
responsibility. Research, development and demonstration may
appropriately proceed under DOE authorization, but facilities
intended to serve commercial purposes should follow NRC
licensing pathways from the beginning.
Independent regulation supports safety and public
confidence and continuity across administrations. Congress
separated nuclear promotion from nuclear regulation in 1974,
assigning DOE responsibility for authorized Federal missions
and NRC exclusive responsibility for commercial nuclear
facilities.
The credibility of both the licensing process and the
broader waste management program are strengthened when that
separation is preserved.
Finally, recycling can reduce the material requiring
disposal, but as has been said already, it cannot eliminate it.
With Yucca Mountain off the table, the Federal Government does
need a mission-focused organization to develop a consent-based
storage and disposal facility system, to transport the fuel, to
sustain that work across administrations. They will require
predictable access to the Nuclear Waste Fund.
Electricity consumers have already contributed more than
$51 billion to that Nuclear Waste Fund, and it could give the
organization the resources it needs to deliver a final
repository.
The United States knows how to store and transport used
nuclear fuel safely. We also know that this fuel contains
resources worth recovering for the public good. Congress, along
with DOE and NRC, has the opportunity to establish a coherent
program that can accept the fuel, support willing host
communities, recover valuable materials, provide permanent
disposal and preserve independent regulation.
Thank you. I look forward to your questions.
[The prepared statement of Ms. Huff follows:]
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Senator Capito. Thank you. Thanks to all three of you.
Great presentations. I am going to begin with the questions.
I will begin with you, Mr. Barrett. Our historic experience
with managing nuclear waste policy shows how State, local, and
Federal politics can change over time and undermine a multi-
generational project. As the Department of Energy looks to
enter into agreements with States, what are the key components
that Congress should consider to ensure that those agreements
can withstand that test of time and the political winds that
flow from time to time in the States?
Mr. Barrett. This would be a challenge for everyone to be
able to put this together. I believe it can be done with hard
work and good faith, to build the required trusted
relationships to sustain this very complex arrangement in
multi-states, dozens of billion-dollar facilities that have to
work together as a team.
Our Nation, with our commercial abilities and our
creativity and our free market fundamentals, we can pull this
together. We have done this before; we have created projects,
and we can do this now. It is going to have to work through a
lot of delicate issues of technology development, continued
safe performance under a rigorous safety and environmental
protection regime, which we have, and we will continue to have.
We can do this if we work together. It is going to take
teamwork, it is going to have to sustain itself past many
administrations, Congresses, Governorships as we go forward. If
we have a continued national vision that we have this
accountability and responsibility for energy that we need now
and also environmental protection for our great-great-
grandchildren in the future, we can do this.
It is going to take a lot of work by everyone, States, the
Federal Government, the Governors, to set that up to make this
happen.
Senator Capito. Right. I think we know from the failed 60
years of stop-and-go that this will be difficult.
I want to ask Dr. Huff, you talked about this in your
statement, the interplay between NRC and DOE. The Department of
Energy envisions that the NLIC initiative to consist of
multiple nuclear campuses with a range of privately owned
facilities to support our national commercial interests.
Based on your experience at the Department of Energy, will
you please describe the relevant licensing requirements that
could be applicable on these campuses?
Ms. Huff. Thank you, Senator. It is a critical question. If
an NLIC contains a collection of facilities, it will probably
fall under a number of different NRC requirements. Part 72 is
for spent fuel storage, whereas Part 71 is for transportation
of packages of spent fuel. Parts 50 or 52 are for reactors, et
cetera.
NRC has a number of these. It is not just NRC. NRC would be
the primary nuclear safety regulator, but not the only
regulator. Agreements States, EPA, the Department of
Transportation and other agencies also retain some
responsibilities.
NRC oversight will guide that kind of public evaluation.
Stable requirements and licensing of a variety of different
facilities at one location will not fall under one particularly
regulatory framework or even one particular regulatory agency.
Senator Capito. I think the Nuclear Regulatory Commission
obviously is, its No. 1 priority is safety. I think as
communities and States look to incorporate this as part of
their interests, I think the safety aspect is going to be the
most difficult one from a public perception.
That is where I see the value of the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission being, because that is their goal, is safety. Would
you agree with that statement?
Ms. Huff. Yes, ma'am.
Senator Capito. Okay. Mr. Barrett, the Nuclear Waste Policy
Act designated a sole location, as we know, Yucca Mountain. It
was also expected to dispose of nuclear waste resulting from
our national security programs, such as spent fuel from
submarines and aircraft carriers, and other waste that is
slightly less radioactive.
Based on your experience, can you describe what a system
would look like with respect to a number of disposal sites,
costs and regulations required to put this is leading on to
the last question I asked--protect public health and the
environment and to establish a suite of disposal options for a
multitude of waste forms and disposal sites?
Mr. Barrett. The NLIC approach would be much more complex
than what was envisioned 40 years ago with the Nuclear Waste
Policy Act. The Nuclear Waste Policy Act was one repository
first, and a second one to follow, and it would basically
contain all the high-level waste, all the spent fuels, and all
highly radioactive long-lived material. It is generally called
intermediate level waste or graded a Class C in other
countries.
All would be deeply disposed of. That was a simpler system.
The NLIC system, well a simpler system then, but it is not
working because of the socio-political situation that we are in
now.
The NLIC system is a much more complicated system, multiple
States, has the opportunity today to possibly include more
advanced technologies, possible recycling if it can be
demonstrated, and all that. It would be a much larger system,
probably considerably more expensive, but also doable. We
should go forward now and do what is plausible and achievable
in the timeframe we have.
For the last 60 years, we have done nothing. We need to
move forward now.
Senator Capito. All right, thank you. Senator Alsobrooks?
Senator Alsobrooks. Thank you. The Federal Government has
contractual obligations, and this first question, by the way,
is for Ms. McMurrian and Mr. Barrett. The Federal Government
has contractual obligations to take spent nuclear fuel from
utilities. However, Calvert Cliffs in my State, along with
other facilities throughout the Country, continue to store
spent fuel onsite.
My first question is, if Congress creates a pathway for
moving spent fuel to consolidated interim storage, what factors
do you believe the Department of Energy should consider when
determining which facility's spent fuel is accepted first?
Mr. Barrett. To achieve this, which is very important as to
what will be the order, we first have to find a place to take
it to. Assuming we have a place that is politically and
socially acceptable to take it to, a receiving facility that
can then start to process, which may include recycling and
eventual disposal, we have to have that place.
Now, the Secretary has the authority to move permanently
shut-down reactors to the front. There are many details that
are not yet worked out. For example, the Nuclear Waste Policy
Act lays out the rights of utilities under contracts for
basically the oldest fuel first. They have a slot in the
acceptance rate.
We have not yet as a Nation worked out little details such
as do they have to purchase these slots from one utility to
another, does the Secretary give a free pass to permanently
shut down reactors where the fuel is stranded there. Those
details we have not worked out yet.
I believe they are certainly solvable in good faith between
all the parties on how that would go.
Exactly the details of how you would compare a continuously
operating plant, as Calvert Cliffs has been an excellent one,
with a plant, say, the San Onofre Plant in California that is
shut down, which has stranded fuel there, how we are going to
balance that, and the quite order, we do not know that. I
suspect that the shut-down plants will have an earlier
acceptance rate than, say, an operating plant.
As we bring on new reactors, advanced reactors in this
Country, there will be different type fuel forms. If we are
successful with the recycling approaches, there is going to
need to be a mix between old fuels and new fuels and different
types of fuels to make them more economically viable going
forward.
We will have to work together on the details of exactly who
goes when and the campaigns, the shipping campaigns, and how
that will all work.
Senator Alsobrooks. Thank you.
How do you believe that DOE should ensure that the system
is fair to utilities and ratepayers, who have already paid into
the Nuclear Waste Fund?
Ms. McMurrian. Sure. I wanted to say with respect to the
other question as well, and I think it relates to this one,
that it is important we hit the start button. We can get
wrapped around the axle with respect to trying to figure out
who goes first, but we really need to make sure we start. We
also are supportive of priority for shut-down reactor fuel.
It is important for Congress and the administration to all
work together to try to make sure there is a transparent and
respected process. I think that you all, of course, have a huge
hand in that and can help make sure that customers are assured
that this is going to be a transparent process, a process that
they can ensure is going to be safe with respect to NRC
regulations.
I think we have an opportunity to show the public that the
DOE and the NRC and other agencies involved in this can get
prepared to make sure that everything is in place when it is
time to start moving. Again, it is time to do that today.
Senator Alsobrooks. Thank you.
Mr. Barrett. I could add, the contract holders that have
certain rights under their contracts for the money that they
have paid for decades, there is an arrangement to do that, and
I am very confident that we as a Nation can solve these
problems as we get on, once we start the process.
Senator Alsobrooks. Thank you.
Then for all of our witnesses, very quickly, the NRC is
ultimately responsible for determining whether a proposed
repository satisfies the applicable licensing requirements. The
credibility of that process will depend on public confidence in
the independence of the NRC.
To each of you, yes or no, do you agree that the NRC should
license any facility that stores or deposits spent nuclear fuel
from commercial reactors?
Mr. Barrett. Yes.
Ms. McMurrian. Yes.
Ms. Huff. Yes.
Senator Alsobrooks. Thank you. Nothing further.
Senator Capito. Senator Curtis?
Senator Curtis. Thank you, and thank you for this hearing.
Thank you to our witnesses.
This is very important. I have heard a lot of estimates
about how much energy we need. I do not think there is any plan
out there that gets us there without a considerable amount of
nuclear energy, far more than I think most people comprehend.
Utah wants to be a first mover in this field, and has
worked hard to place themselves in that position. We need a
clear regulatory path forward for us. As I think all of you
know, Utah has been down-selected as one of the six sites for
these Nuclear Lifecycle Innovation Campuses. A lot of my
remarks will be through those lenses today.
I would also note that Utah's participation is exploratory.
What I mean by that is there are some important questions that
have to be answered. Dr. Huff, you talked about the other
aspects of this.
The one thing that I would like to bring up that was not
really mentioned is, does the State stay as a participant in
decisionmaking, or does the State end up holding the bag for
what started as a pilot program of storage and then nothing
else comes along?
Also, does this keep pace with innovation? What we have
talked about today is based on what we know about recycling
today. I think we all know that we could get some innovation
out there that would dramatically change this, and does this
program keep pace with that or does it get locked in time.
You all have mentioned no matter what we do with recycling,
we are still going to have waste that has to be dealt with. I
would say, and I am speaking somewhat on behalf of Utah,
realizing that this really rests on the shoulders of our State
leaders, we are interested in this but we do not want to get in
that position of looking around and saying, well now what? We
did not quite have all these answers before we jumped into
this.
I think that means clear regulatory pathways, safety
standards, meaningful State participation, partnership, and a
critical path for managing nuclear material from generation all
the way through disposition of it.
Mr. Barrett, let me start with you. What does coordination
between DOE and the NRC look like as these projects move
forward?
Mr. Barrett. As far as between DOE and NRC, DOE is the
first mover. They are the promoters, as was mentioned by the
Chairwoman. The NRC is an independent safety regulator that
will oversee everything at the end, before it can go
commercial. They are the safety assurers. DOE and its partners
in industry and the State is a partner, too, propose it and the
NRC assures the safety.
That is basically----
Senator Curtis. Yes. What is your advice for what
protection levels, what Federal commitments should a State look
for as they consider these campuses?
Mr. Barrett. Well, Governors today I think are quite savvy
in this. Clearly, as I think the Governor from Wyoming said 30
some years ago, you are dancing with an 800-pound gorilla here,
the Federal Government. You need to protect yourself going
forward.
There are ways to do that through contractual
relationships, that there must be a true partnership between
the Federal Government, the host State and the private industry
participants who are really going to be doing the work. They
are probably going to be owning many of these facilities.
All of those, that work, will be under the safety umbrella
to give assurance to the American people that whatever is being
done is being done safely to protect the environment now and in
the future as well.
The States need to be very wise about how they do this.
These are not going to be Indian treaties from the 19th
century. That we are not going to have. We have to prepare
Senator Curtis. I am going to interrupt, because they give
me 5 minutes and I am going to use all of it. I do think all of
us here today can see a scenario much like Senator Alsobrooks
explained, like, we did not sign up for this and States very
likely could be saying, no, we did not sign up for a private
program that permanently leaves this with no jobs, no economic
development and everything else.
It is about accountability, I think, for the Federal
Government.
Ms. McMurrian, your organization represents States that
deal with these. This is a good opportunity for me to get some
free advice for my State.
What would you advise States as they look at these
opportunities?
Ms. McMurrian. I think there is a lot that can be done
short of legislation, actually. I think the Nuclear Waste
Policy Act lays out a good framework and I think you can look
at that. I think there are things that DOE could be doing in
the short term, and you all can encourage them, or direct them
to do some of these things.
I think that a program plan similar to how we think of it
in the public utility space is almost like an integrated
resource plan where you ask DOE to put together a plan for this
multi-generational program, see how your Sates and other
contender States fit into that, give input and hopefully have
an engaging dialog with them.
Have them set up an independent office again that focuses
strictly on these issues, so that you have a more direct line
person to go to to have this engagement. You have great people
at DOE now. I think it would be nice to revert back to that
plan that was set up in the Nuclear Waste Policy Act to have a
dedicated office to this, again, that would facilitate States'
engagement.
Then also, making sure that there is money for DOE to
engage with you all properly and to make sure that we do not
get down the road and there is not sufficient funding. Of
course, fixing the Nuclear Waste Fund, getting access to that
money for a disposal program would really facilitate all of
these things.
Senator Curtis. As you can see, I would love to monopolize
this whole hearing, but I am out of time and I will yield.
Thank you, Chair, for this hearing and our witnesses for
being here. You can see this is a clearly important topic for
Utah.
Ms. McMurrian. Thank you.
Senator Capito. Thank you.
Senator Blunt Rochester?
Senator Blunt Rochester. Thank you, Chair Capito. Thank you
so much to the panel for this important hearing.
Delaware often ranks last among U.S. States in energy
production, and produces only a fraction of the energy that we
consume.
In response, our general assembly created a 25-member
bipartisan task force to look at whether small, modular
reactors could be developed in the State. One of the main
concerns is the lack of a long-term solution for high-level
nuclear waste. Despite the fact that there has been a law on
the books for decades, that requires the Federal Government to
take ownership over this kind of waste.
States like mine then have to weigh whether to invest in
nuclear energy against doing it without a long-term solution.
It is a real risk for our communities. This is an issue of
public safety and public trust.
Dr. Huff, what can the Federal Government do to build trust
in communities interested in pursuing nuclear energy?
Ms. Huff. Thank you, Senator. I think a key component is an
independent organization like the one that has been described.
Another is to provide resources for independent technical
oversight from those communities.
A part of the consent-based system that we put together in
the previous administration and those that have succeeded in
other nations, like Finland and Canada, includes providing
resources directly to communities to help to evaluate those
claims and safety assessments, and work together with the
government as they plan and design those facilities.
Senator Blunt Rochester. As a followup, are there benefits
to continuing to pursue new reactors while determining a long-
term waste disposal solution?
Ms. Huff. Thank you, Senator. Yes, there are absolutely
are. As a carbon-free source of energy, we absolutely need more
nuclear. Of course, it is reasonable for communities to want to
see progress on the front of waste management before they do
so.
Senator Blunt Rochester. Thank you.
I am going to ask a question of the entire panel. Many of
you may know that Delaware is the lowest-lying State in the
Country. Just a few days ago there was an article in the
newspaper about California and just the waves and the impact of
climate on particularly creating more fears about this nuclear
waste that is stored 100 feet below.
To the panel, what should coastal States like Delaware
consider if storing spent nuclear fuel onsite?
Mr. Barrett. I will start, quickly. I think the near-term
safety, and when I say near-term, I mean up to 100 years,
clearly, we have the engineering capability to handle that.
That is not an immediate concern that people should, the public
should worry about----
That does need to go in parallel with developing new
reactors, small modular or not, that there is a long-term
disposal project that will complement and support that in the
long term and the short-term safety for climate change or
whatever I think can be handled through engineering of whoever
is running it.
Senator Blunt Rochester. Got it. Ms. McMurrian?
Ms. McMurrian. Thank you, Senator. While not an engineer or
a safety expert, we have been assured by those who are that
this is safe where it is. It has proven to be safe where it is
for a long time. We have experience with respect to, or at
least through articles and such about the experience, even in
Fukushima, that even in a tsunami that nothing was released
with respect to the spent fuel that was there onsite.
We have tremendous assurance that it is safe where it is. I
would also say that an important thing to keep an eye on would
be to make sure that the administration and Congress, in
facilitating these NLIC campuses, make sure that permanent
disposal is a necessary part of that program, so that you keep
your eye on the ball that there is going to be a place for this
to go to long-term.
Senator Blunt Rochester. Thank you. Dr. Huff?
Ms. Huff. From a practical perspective, I will add that
maintenance of the rail spurs on the way to those storage
facilities is one of the things that separates a facility ready
to move that fuel in the event of changing climate and a
facility that may not be ready.
Senator Blunt Rochester. I feel like you were thinking
about my next question.
Although Delaware does not host any commercial nuclear
reactors or high level waste storage repositories, it does
serve as a vital transportation hub for the mid-Atlantic
region. What measures must be considered regarding the
transportation of spent fuel from its current site to a
consolidated storage or permanent disposal facility? Are there
transportation issues that can be addressed simultaneously to
siting a storage or disposal facility?
Ms. Huff. Thank you, Senator, yes. I will add there are
certified packages that need to be certified for advanced
transfer of fuels, if we move in that direction. Fuel
characterization and route planning is always underway at DOE
and does so in collaboration with TRMTC, a tribal coordination
body that helps to make sure that tribal nations are involved
in the transportation. Engagement with corridor communities as
well is really pivotal to those processes.
Senator Blunt Rochester. Thank you.
Ms. McMurrian. I would just ask that Congress continue to
fund those key components that are necessary to ensure that
transportation infrastructure is there and to support the
States and tribes who also can add a lot of confidence, and do
add confidence to this whole program.
Senator Blunt Rochester. Thank you.
Mr. Barrett. Continuing the institutional informational
aspects are very important, as my colleagues have mentioned.
Also, we are building on a 50-plus year experience of safely
transporting this globally, of tens of thousands of shipments,
and they have all been done safely without any nuclear
problems.
Senator Blunt Rochester. Okay, thank you so much, and thank
you, Madam Chair, for indulging my time. I yield back.
Senator Capito. Senator Husted?
Senator Husted. Thank you, Chair Capito. I appreciate
everybody being here. My question is going to go to all of you,
so as you hear me talk about it, then I am going to ask each of
you to respond to this.
America is going to need more baseload electricity. Every
estimate says that is true for the foreseeable future.
There is a desire for that to be as low of a carbon
footprint as possible. I think most people agree on that goal,
too.
Nuclear, right now, with all of the existing technologies
to be considered, is the best tool to do that. Recycling
nuclear fuel is one of the great ways that we can both solve
the problem that we are discussing today and meet our future
energy needs. Based on the research I have done, there is
95,000 tons of spent nuclear fuel. We create about 2,000 more
tons a year.
At current rates, if you recycled all of it, it would
provide electricity sufficient to power America for 160 years.
Quibble about my years, but you get the point. It is a lot.
I sponsored, and this committee passed, the Nuclear Fuel
Act, which created a regulatory and licensing framework to help
get that done. Hopefully we can get it passed through the
entire Senate.
It would make recycling a viable option for spent nuclear
fuel, and America, as they do, has been mentioned in other
nations, I have every reason to believe if we get the
regulatory component right that we will see private investment
come off the sidelines to help make this all happen, and solve
a great portion of the problem that we are discussing today.
I ask each of you, what additionally do you believe that we
need to do to get this accomplished? I will start down there,
and come this way.
Mr. Barrett. Recycling holds great promise for a lot of
things. There is a lot of work to do to assure that it is going
to be commercially viable and support this.
With recycling, without recycling, there is still going to
be high-level waste that needs to be disposed of.
Senator Husted. I recognize that.
Mr. Barrett. That continues. There is value, and I think
the Federal Government, through its development in R&D, can
certainly help and assist that to hopefully bring forward the
vision that people have that you just described very well, sir.
Yes, there is promise. We have a lot of details and work to
do yet.
Senator Husted. No doubt. That is why we should not delay.
Yes.
Go ahead.
Ms. McMurrian. Being a non-expert, but I guess what I would
say is maybe demonstrations and showing support and a
commitment that we are going to take care of what is left after
the recycling process is done. I think all those would support
recycling endeavors.
Senator Husted. I know that there are plans to go with
Tennessee and Ohio to get some of these things going in terms
of the recycling, and then the new small scale nuclear reactors
that can help and that can use the fuel.
Dr. Huff?
Ms. Huff. I will just add that DOE has had a strong fuel
cycle research and development program throughout the whole
last many decades, even when we did not have a real policy
toward recycling, boosting that program at the national labs
and the universities. Public-private partnerships with
companies can help make sure that all of the learning that we
have been doing over these last many decades contributes to
some of those innovations.
I would say, strengthen that research and development
program, and we will be on our way.
Senator Husted. There is no doubt that this is a private-
public partnership that is in great need. If you listen to what
the others have had to say, how long has this been going on? It
is stunning to me how slow this place operates. It really is.
We have known that this has been a problem for decades, but
everybody always had a reason about why they can not do this,
can not do that. Even though they will disagree about a detail,
but while the whole thing goes down. We do not move ahead on
it.
This is a topic, the idea of recycling, most people
probably do not know that you can do it, they think, well, this
is spent nuclear fuel out there, but it is still 95 percent
viable for what it can be reused to do to power our future. It
is just sitting there, nothing is being done with it. We can do
this, the technology is available. It has been well-documented.
We need to go forward.
I thank you, Chair Capito, for hosting this hearing.
America can not wait. We keep saying we want low-carbon options
for electricity. We know that demand is going up. Yet we do
nothing. Nothing to get that accomplished.
I hope that we can get the Nuclear Refuel Act through the
Senate, through the Congress and on the President's desk so
that we can begin this process of powering our Country and
recycling the very waste product, as we call it, that we want
to bury in the ground instead of using it to turn our lights
on.
Thank you for being here today.
Senator Capito. Thank you, Senator Husted.
As you can see, it is just me and the Senator here.
Before I close, I do want to ask, I want to take license
here and ask an additional question, because everybody has
talked about this. This is the funding source.
We know there was a funding source set up 60 years ago. I
like the way you put it, trust and fund. We have a Highway
Trust Fund, we have a Harbor Trust Fund, we have experience
with this.
I do not know, some of the estimates are $50 billion, $51
billion. Well, it tells me it is not just sitting there, I can
tell you that. It has probably already been spent in some form
or fashion. It has not been spent where it is properly
designated for.
How do we, do we continue with that system to be able to
give predictable and adequate funding? Do we put more
guardrails on it? How would you suggest that? I will just kind
of go through the panel here.
Mr. Barrett, do you have any ideas on that?
Mr. Barrett. The Federal IOUs are sitting there in the
Treasury. Turning IOUs into cash is a challenge for the
Congress and the administration. That has to go forward.
I think there are arrangements that can be done. One of the
things that does not come into discussion that should is the
taxpayer liability for paying judgment funds, which is off-
budget, basically. The liability to the taxpayers is almost $60
billion, on a new report that will be coming out shortly.
That needs to come into it as well. We do need to get the
funding to move to make this happen. It is a Federal, the
government owes that money. We have to find a way to generate
that. There are ways to do it.
Senator Capito. Ms. McMurrian?
Ms. McMurrian. Thank you for this important question. I
will say that we have been told over the years that if we fix
your fund, or the Nuclear Waste Fund, we would have to fix
others. This is a big problem for Congress. Then since then we
have watched as Congress has addressed getting access to the
Land and Conservation Fund and the Harbor Maintenance Trust
Fund.
We know that Congress knows how to do it. We just need the
leadership. You all are of course showing that here today. We
are excited about the prospects of perhaps finding a way to
return access to that money that is in the fund, that $51
billion with $1.7 billion and up billion accumulating every
year, and allow DOE to use that to make progress and really
build trust among the communities to make sure that as they
look at new nuclear endeavors, that they have trust that this
is going to be resolved and that the money will be there to do
it.
Senator Capito. Dr. Huff?
Ms. Huff. I would like to associate myself with all the
comments of my colleagues here. They are completely right, and
I would say furthermore, Congress has also in small amounts
been able to begin funding things like the consent-based siting
program out of that fund. That work can start off a little bit
in the very near-term, even before we figure out how to make a
sort of more permanent access to that fund possible.
Senator Capito. Okay. Let me ask a technical question. Mr.
Barrett, in your opening statement, I wrote down something,
just so I understand, I understand recycling, I understand
reprocessing. Is all nuclear waste, it is not all the same.
I am thinking if you are a State such as mine, would you
have, keep in mind we do not have any nuclear facilities, would
you, if you are doing permanent disposal, do you have to have
different facets to dispose of it or can you put it all in one
singular disposable geologic formation?
I am kind of curious about that.
Mr. Barrett. There is nominally three types of nuclear
waste. There is low-level waste, which is currently disposed of
in the United States and worldwide on surface facilities.
Basically, it lasts 100 years or so, or 200 years, medical
waste is a primary part of that.
Then there is high-level waste, that is the highly
radioactive part, like spent fuel or the residue from
recycling. That goes into a deep geologic repository worldwide.
There is potentially a third level that is known as
intermediate level waste internationally which would be some of
the less active residue from recycling primarily. Defense waste
transuranics that are disposed of in New Mexico in a deep salt
formation is an example of that sort of thing. We do not have
that in the commercial world here of any significant amount.
You can always put them in, always can go into a very deep
repository if you wish to do so. You do not necessarily
economically need to do it.
Now, the countries that are doing this, like Sweden and
Finland, and all, and the French, they are putting all their
intermediate-level and high-level waste deep underground. You
could put it less to the surface, which might be less
expensive. You have to have the proper regulations for it----
The NRC is reviewing those, their current low-level waste,
and looking at potentially having intermediate-level waste in a
near-surface disposal, sort of in between. There are different
types of waste. They all can be disposed of safely now, and
have long-term performance to protect future generations
according to the type of waste it is, and its toxicity and its
character.
Senator Capito. Okay. Well, thank you for that. I am
reflecting back to when I was a child and I would ask my dad
for something, and he would say, ``Well, I do not have to be a
nuclear scientist to tell you this.'' I might have to be a
nuclear scientist to understand all this, so I appreciate that
clarification.
While we were chatting, Senator Lummis, whose State I
believe is affected by this as well is here. As soon as she is
ready, I will let her begin her questioning.
Senator Lummis. Chairman, thank you. I am so glad I get a
chance to ask a couple of questions of our witnesses. Thank you
for your patience.
The cost of spent fuel storage, as I understand it, is
about $8 million per site per year for each year we do not have
a permanent storage solution.
Ms. McMurrian, thanks for being here. Can you please speak
to the significance of that number?
Ms. McMurrian. Absolutely. As a former public utility
commissioner, we have been focused on this for a long time,
about the cost of this and trying to make sure that the
government, of course we are excited about the leadership of
this committee and others in working on this problem.
Yes, these costs continue to mount. Those have consequences
not only on the electric customers who have paid in to make
sure that there is a solution, but also on taxpayers who are
paying for the liability that is accumulating and that is paid
out of the judgment fund.
Also, of course, on the host communities who, we do believe
that the spent fuel is safe where it is. They were promised
that in return for payments and in return for their service in
keeping this onsite that the government would start picking
this up in 1998. Of course, that has not happened.
We are hoping that going forward, and with these NLIC
States and other States who are interested in new nuclear
endeavors, that we can get this right next time and ensure that
we have the program in place to support all of these States and
all of these new investments.
Senator Lummis. Thank you.
I understand that some of our European countries have
geological repositories, France, Finland, Sweden. Finland has
constructed something called a nuclear waste tomb, which passed
safety tests last month.
Mr. Barrett and Dr. Huff, is there anything the U.S. can
learn from these countries with regard to site selections and
licensing processes? Are there technical or regulatory reasons
those approaches could not be replicated here? Mr. Barrett?
Mr. Barrett. We have worked with those countries for
decades technically. That is not an issue. The issue here is
one of our socio-political establishment versus theirs. Let us
take Finland, which is the leader. They are actually building a
new emplacement shortly. They have no states. It is basically
the central government and local people.
If we had that situation here in America, this would have
been done years ago. We are the United States of America. That
is a big difference.
We have to adjust our policies to work in our culture. We
have learned a lot, we know a lot, and many of the concepts of
consent-based siting and collaboration work is exactly what
they do in Finland and France and Canada as well.
We have learned that, we know that, and we now have to
better balance our program. In the past, with Yucca Mountain,
it was almost all technical and it was not enough socio-
political side to it. Now we must have a balanced program that
has both. Without the socio-political viability, we are not
going anywhere.
Senator Lummis. Dr. Huff?
Ms. Huff. I agree completely, and I would add that the
example of Canada, which Mr. Barrett mentioned, is a good one
in the context of this lack of states and other examples. The
nuclear waste management organization there in Canada has
successfully sort of down-selected to a final repository site.
I think it is a promising example. I am grateful DOE and
NWMO have MOUs to work together and understand each other much
like they do with Finland and other nations. There is great
hope there.
Senator Lummis. Okay. My State of Wyoming is exploring,
specifically Gilette, Wyoming, Campbell County, is exploring
TRISO Fuel. It is my understanding that it takes the shape of
poppyseed size particles or even some designs are using liquid
fuel.
Mr. Barrett, can you elaborate on the technical
considerations for including these fuel types in a nuclear
waste disposal plan?
Mr. Barrett. That is a very robust fuel form. It is
probably the best we have. It was very compatible with geologic
disposal, as other forms as well. It does not really change
much. It is a very good thing, it is very safe and has great
economic promise as well. It is not a big issue as far as
disposal. It goes very nicely into any type of disposal system.
Senator Lummis. Thank you.
Madam Chairman, may I ask one more question? Thank you.
DOE's Nuclear Lifecycle Innovation Campus program would put
fuel fabrication and used fuel disposition on a single site.
Ms. McMurrian and Dr. Huff, can you speak to the value of
letting States decide for themselves which roles they can play
in advanced nuclear energy and the fuel cycle? We already
discussed the advantages of having not to deal with States, as
is true in Finland and Canada.
What do we do, given the fact that we have a 10th
Amendment, we have States, we have at least theoretically
robust State rights. What role can they play in advanced
nuclear energy and fuel cycle?
Ms. McMurrian. I would say, we have definitely learned the
value of having States as partners and working with the
government hand-in-hand on these things. I would encourage any
States looking at being a campus or moving forward with respect
to new nuclear investment to really encourage the permanent
disposal aspect that I think that having that solution for the
Country is going to serve all the States interested in new
nuclear endeavors as well. It will definitely address the trust
issues that have been questioned.
Senator Lummis. Thank you.
Dr. Huff?
Ms. Huff. One practical benefit of having States pretty
integrally involved in defining their own rules is that States
are often the centroid of State regulators and permitting, and
that can help smooth the path to successful licensing of such
facilities or hinder the path of successful such licensing.
Direct involvement with those States that have the power
and engagement from their communities to see that path go
smoothly is a real benefit.
Senator Lummis. Are you aware of some States that are
interested in exploring this?
Ms. Huff. My understanding is that there are six. Five were
announced on July 1st and then West Virginia shortly
thereafter.
Senator Lummis. It sounds like States that are accustomed
to coal, oil, gas, uranium, nuclear culturally are adapted to
those technologies are embracing it. I am grateful for that.
Mr. Barrett, if Nuclear Lifecycle Innovation Campuses are
intended to support fabrication and other activities, what
regulatory or statutory uncertainties need to be resolved
before companies or the government can justify investments in
these facilities?
Mr. Barrett. I think the conventional fuel fabrication
enrichment is pretty well established fact for decades. That I
think can continue sort of in a normal way.
I think for the disposal aspect of things we do not have,
we only have modern standards for Yucca Mountain, and Yucca
Mountain is not being considered here. We need to establish a
regulatory process from that for other sites. That can be done.
We at American Nuclear Society proposed a report on how to do
that.
If the regulatory, EPA and the NRC, need to pick that up to
work with the States to assure that that will, the disposal
part will be safe.
As far as recycling, the NRC I think has the capability to
support that from a regulatory safety point of view, and the
DOE has technologies with its national laboratories to assist
applicants as they are working together to develop recycling
technologies and others that will meet all the safety
requirements.
I think there is a robust system there and I think it can
serve our Nation well.
Senator Lummis. I thank our witnesses and Madam Chairman, I
want to thank you for a little extra time. I get to tee up Mr.
Markey, because I was taking too much time.
Senator Capito. Senator Markey?
Senator Markey. Thank you so much, Madam Chair, thank you,
Senator Lummis.
Yucca Mountain was never going to be a permanent repository
for nuclear waste, for many reasons. One major mistake was
Congress' failure to ask for permission. Not only does proper
nuclear waste management require a great deal of scientific and
engineering prowess, which was missing, by the way, you should
not be building a nuclear waste site on an earthquake vault
next to a river. It also requires social buy-in and public
consent. That can take a long time to build, but it can be lost
in an instant.
If we are going to ask a community to host radioactive
waste, they need and deserve to be informed of the risks and
have a role in planning and decisionmaking, whether it is
interim or permanent storage. The consequences of this misstep
have been massive.
The current State of nuclear waste management is de facto
onsite storage that has forced communities to host waste for
longer than they planned for. Decades and decades longer than
they planned for. It is endless and it is expensive.
We are spending $2 million every day of your taxpayer
dollars for the government's failure to figure out an adequate
solution. The Trump administration just proposed new interim
storage facilities in five different States, although many
details remain unresolved. The Department of Energy signed
memoranda with five Governors. It has not clarified how its
vision will be developed in tandem with affect communities.
Dr. Huff, do you think community level stakeholders will
need to participate in the discussion around lifecycle campuses
in addition to State governments, in order to avoid consent-
based disagreements?
Ms. Huff. Yes, I do, very much so.
Senator Markey. You do. What will happen if they do not get
that social buy-in, Dr. Huff?
Ms. Huff. Long term, there is no robustness to a system
that has a lot of lack of local support or State support or
Federal. You have to have all three, and you have to have
tribal nations engaged in a government-to-government activity
as well.
Senator Markey. These are, for all intents and purposes,
going to be permanent interim storage. Once they are there,
those sites are never going anywhere. The community has to
understand that it is an interim permanent location in five
places in our Country. You will have that nuclear waste for the
rest of that State's history.
Without radical transparency and public consent, we are
bound to repeat the very same mistakes which we did 40 years
ago. Americans can not keep paying for this mistake in their
taxpayer dollars and in compromised safety.
This administration has fired members of the Nuclear Waste
Technical Review Board, our independent scientific watchdog
over DOE's waste management policy. It has infiltrated and
undermined the independent Nuclear Regulatory Commission by
firing the former chair, sending DOGE into the headquarters and
issuing executive orders that have led to fast and furious
deregulations that create new limitations on the commission's
ability to ensure the safety and security of our reactor fleet.
The Department of Energy is asking communities to trust it
on storing nuclear waste, as well as on regulating enrichment,
recycling and other activities that have major safety and
national security implications. Much like consent, trust takes
years to build, but only seconds to lose.
Ms. McMurrian, you have previously served at the NRC and on
the Nuclear Waste Technical Review Board. Can you explain the
importance of maintaining an independent NRC and scientific
oversight of DOE's waste management policies?
Ms. McMurrian. I think you might have meant to direct that
question to Mr. Barrett, with respect to the Nuclear Waste
Technical Review Board. I will say that independence is very
important in all of these processes.
It is why the Nuclear Waste Strategy Coalition has
certainly supported getting the program out of DOE over the
long term, that all of this program's entirety of being subject
to every 4 years, every 8 years, having the goalpost kind of
move in a different strategy has not served this program well.
We think that ultimately getting that kind of independence that
you speak of would definitely make progress on this entire
issue.
Senator Markey. I apologize. Again, public trust is
paramount. If the Trump administration is serious about finding
a real solution to nuclear waste in this Country, it would
relinquish its chokehold over the NRC and the review board. If
it is not clear to the public that safety is being given
priority and instead utilities or others are compromised in
those safety protections, then the community will just turn on
a facility in a nanosecond because of the danger.
That is ultimately what we are talking about. The DOE's
Nuclear Lifecycle Innovation Campus initiative would set up
integrated full cycle nuclear ecosystems that could collocate
and support the entire nuclear value chain. This includes
interim storage for intermediate and high-level waste, fuel
reprocessing, reactors and even onsite manufacturing and data
centers.
However, we received little or no detail on how the agency
and host States plan to prevent and mitigate the many security
risks that come with fuel reprocessing. Once plutonium is
separated from spent nuclear fuel, it can be used to produce
nuclear weapons.
Again, Dr. Huff, are there nuclear proliferation risks that
would be created by siting reprocessing facilities on a large
campus like those proposed by DOE?
Ms. Huff. I believe that nuclear material security can be
managed, but it is costly. We store and manage very dangerous
nuclear materials across this Nation.
However, the process of enabling a private entity, for
example, to conduct that work also has to include strict
regulations with regard to nuclear material security at those
facilities, which will need government oversight and is likely
to be costly.
It will have to incorporate itself into the economics.
Senator Markey. Okay. There is definitely going to be big
questions on personnel access, how it is going to be managed,
reprocessing.
If DOE is going to change the campus plan to change
traditional personnel and security measures, we are going to
have big nuclear proliferation risks. That uranium, the
plutonium is the only thing missing from the ability to build a
nuclear bomb. The security will have to be intense.
Thank you, Madam Chair.
Mr. Barrett. Senator, if I could, let me add to that. I
agree with much of what you just said about the importance of
the independence and the connection. DOE needs to work with the
States and the communities to develop what good rules are, so
DOE cannot initially say, here is how it is going to be, the
details, which you well spoke to that we have to do.
It has to be done in a partnership with the host State and
with the communities. As to the Technical Review Board, I was a
Republican on the Technical Report appointed by President
Biden. I was fired on the first full day of the Trump
administration. I have confidence that in the Federal system of
the NRC and others and my one remaining colleague on the
Technical Review Board that safety rules be given to the
American people no matter what goes forward, and that the
American people should have confidence in what is going
forward, as some of these political things play their way out.
I believe the safety is there and we are now on our
approach that will address the issues of the social side, that
we have got to do better on. We are on our way to do that.
Thank you.
Senator Markey. I would just say, over-confidence breeds
complacency and complacency breeds disaster. To the extent to
which everybody turns into a cheerleader and we have lost that
sense of responsibility to make sure that it is safe, then we
are sighting up a consequence where you go another 30 years,
with Chernobyl and Three Mile Island as a shadow over the
nuclear industry.
Thank you, Madam Chair.
Senator Capito. Thank you.
Thank you all very much. With no further questions, I would
like to thank the witnesses, as I just did, and all of my
colleagues for participation in today's hearing.
Senators who wish to submit written questions for the
record have until 5 p.m. on Wednesday, October 7th, to do so.
The witnesses' responses to these questions are due back to the
committee no later than 5 p.m. on Wednesday, October 21st and
will be submitted for the record.
With that, this hearing is adjourned. Thank you.
[Whereupon, at 11:19 a.m., the hearing was adjourned.]
[all]