[Senate Hearing 117-244]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]
S. Hrg. 117-244
PREVENTING TRAGEDIES AND
PROMOTING SAFE, ACCESSIBLE,
AND AFFORDABLE HOMES
=======================================================================
HEARING
BEFORE THE
SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING
UNITED STATES SENATE
ONE HUNDRED SEVENTEENTH CONGRESS
SECOND SESSION
__________
WASHINGTON, DC
__________
MARCH 31, 2022
__________
Serial No. 117-15
Printed for the use of the Special Committee on Aging
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.govinfo.gov
__________
U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
47-366 PDF WASHINGTON : 2022
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON AGING
ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., Pennsylvania, Chairman
KIRSTEN E. GILLIBRAND, New York TIM SCOTT, South Carolina
RICHARD BLUMENTHAL, Connecticut SUSAN M. COLLINS, Maine
ELIZABETH WARREN, Massachusetts RICHARD BURR, North Carolina
JACKY ROSEN, Nevada MARCO RUBIO, Florida
MARK KELLY, Arizona MIKE BRAUN, Indiana
RAPHAEL WARNOCK, Georgia RICK SCOTT, Florida
MIKE LEE, Utah
----------
Stacy Sanders, Majority Staff Director
Neri Martinez, Minority Staff Director
C O N T E N T S
----------
Page
Opening Statement of Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman...... 1
Opening Statement of Senator Tim Scott, Ranking Member........... 2
PANEL OF WITNESSES
Anand Parekh, M.D., Chief Medical Advisor, Bipartisan Policy
Center, Washington, D.C........................................ 5
Denise Cleveland-Leggett, Senior Vice President of Business
Development, The Integral Group, Atlanta, Georgia.............. 7
Tracey Kelly, US Safer Life at Home Development Manager, IKEA
USA, Trappe, Pennsylvania...................................... 9
Janet McGee, Director, Parents Against Tip-Overs, Eagan,
Minnesota...................................................... 10
APPENDIX
Prepared Witness Statements
Anand Parekh, M.D., Chief Medical Advisor, Bipartisan Policy
Center, Washington, D.C........................................ 29
Denise Cleveland-Leggett, Senior Vice President of Business
Development, The Integral Group, Atlanta, Georgia.............. 36
Tracey Kelly, US Safer Life at Home Development Manager, IKEA
USA, Trappe, Pennsylvania...................................... 39
Janet McGee, Director, Parents Against Tip-Overs, Eagan,
Minnesota...................................................... 44
Questions for the Record
Anand Parekh, M.D., Chief Medical Advisor, Bipartisan Policy
Center, Washington, D.C........................................ 49
Denise Cleveland-Leggett, Senior Vice President of Business
Development, The Integral Group, Atlanta, Georgia.............. 53
Tracey Kelly, US Safer Life at Home Development Manager, IKEA
USA, Trappe, Pennsylvania...................................... 57
Janet McGee, Director, Parents Against Tip-Overs, Eagan,
Minnesota...................................................... 59
Statements for the Record
Consumer Reports Letter.......................................... 63
PREVENTING TRAGEDIES AND
PROMOTING SAFE, ACCESSIBLE,
AND AFFORDABLE HOMES
----------
THURSDAY, MARCH 31, 2022
U.S. Senate,
Special Committee on Aging,
Washington, DC.
The Committee met, pursuant to notice, at 10:04 a.m., via
Webex, Hon. Robert P. Casey, Jr., Chairman of the Committee,
presiding.
Present: Senators Casey, Gillibrand, Blumenthal, Rosen,
Kelly, Warnock, Tim Scott, Braun, and Rick Scott.
OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR
ROBERT P. CASEY, JR., CHAIRMAN
The Chairman. Good morning. The hearing will come to order.
Today, we will discuss a topic of bipartisan interest:
promoting home safety for seniors, children and people with
disabilities, as well as families in general. This has been a
longstanding priority of the Special Committee on Aging. In
October 2019, the Committee released a bipartisan report on
falls and held a hearing on the same topic.
We know that a quarter of all older adults, one quarter,
fall every year, and that the majority of these falls occur
within the home. I witnessed the struggles that accompany a
fall firsthand when my mother experienced a fall just December
2021, early December. She is doing well now and recovered, but
it was two long and difficult months between and among surgery,
and then rehabilitation, and then returning home, so many
families have had this experience.
For some, a fall can be prevented by installing a grab bar
in their home or making other modifications. For others, it
might be participating in, for example, evidence-based
programs, like a program called a Matter of Balance, which
offers small group activities and exercise training.
Investments in home modifications and prevention programs
are a really small price to pay, considering that senior falls
contribute to $50 billion, that is 50 with a B, $50 billion, in
medical costs per year and unfortunately lead to 34,000 deaths
among seniors.
In some cases, home modifications alone are not enough.
Every year, emergency rooms across the country treat over
22,000 preventable injuries caused by falling furniture, like
dressers or television sets. Annually, over 3,000 of those
injured by tip-overs are older adults. It is not only seniors,
of course, who are harmed. Children are also put at great risk,
and tragically, of those killed by furniture tip-overs, 81
percent are children.
My home State of Pennsylvania was touched by these
devastating losses. We lost Katie Lambert and Curren Collas to
these tip-overs. Katie was 3 years old when she died due to
injuries sustained from a furniture tip-over in her family's
home in Huntingdon Valley, Pennsylvania, just outside of
Philadelphia, and Curren, from West Chester, Pennsylvania as
well, close to the city of Philadelphia, outside of the city.
Curren, when he passed away, was only 2 years old.
There is no reason for any family to endure this
unspeakable loss. Compounding the grief and the loss for these
families and what they experience is the fact that these deaths
might have been prevented by stronger standards. We will talk
more about this today. Mandatory stability standards would make
our homes safer overall, but especially for children.
I am proud to lead a bipartisan bill, the STURDY Act,
alongside Senators Klobuchar, Blumenthal and Cotton. This Act
would require the Consumer Product Safety Commission to create
a mandatory stability standard for furniture. It would require
companies to ensure their products are tested for safety before
that product is sold. It is a simple, commonsense requirement
that will save lives.
Today, we will learn more about what Congress can do to
keep our children, our seniors and our families safer.
Let me turn now to our Ranking Member for his opening
remarks.
OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR
TIM SCOTT, RANKING MEMBER
Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Chairman Casey, for holding
another truly important hearing and thank you to each and every
witness for investing your time, your energy and, frankly, your
expertise on a topic that is so important to all Americans, but
specifically our senior population.
I remember one of my earliest goals in life was to make
sure that my mother had a safe place to live, with a garage,
and so I spent a lot of time and energy trying to make sure
that instead of living in apartments or, as she did growing up,
in the projects, that she would have an opportunity to own her
own home, live in it, and feel the safety and the security that
comes with home ownership.
In addition to that, I wanted to make sure that not only
did she have that opportunity, but so many others in
communities that are too often living from paycheck to paycheck
or are living in marginalized communities, they would have that
opportunity as well.
Over half of public housing today, public housing
residents, are seniors or people with disabilities, but less
than 20 percent live in accessible units. All residents deserve
the choice to have housing that meets their needs.
I am working on a bill to give older Americans and those
with disabilities the resources they need to leave their public
housing units and find a home on the market if they want, also
releasing a report, this is the report here, Housing for the
Golden Years, that explores senior housing needs and what we
can do to help seniors meet those needs that they have in a way
that shows dignity and respect for our seniors during their
golden years.
South Carolina is one of the most popular retirement
destinations in the country. I am sure that it will continue to
grow in its popularity, but seniors in our State still face an
uphill climb in so many ways as it relates to housing and we
want to find ways to bridge that gap.
I am inspired by the efforts to help older Americans in my
home State of South Carolina. A group called Homes of Hope in
Greenville builds affordable houses for working people in need.
They strive to integrate seniors and people with disabilities
into communities with younger adults so they can also help
support each other. Daniel Holloway was his family's primary
earner until he, unfortunately, developed kidney failure,
because of that, he could no longer afford the place that he
was living, so you can imagine the bread winner, supporting a
family, no longer being able to do so. Thankfully for him,
Homes of Hope, they were able to step in to help him out during
the challenging times that he went through.
The good news is that he was able to see his health
improve, and as his health improved, he was able to, once
again, take on the responsibilities of caring for his family
and providing the resources necessary for his home.
Thank God there was an organization, however, that was
there during the most challenging and difficult times of his
adult life. There needs to be more organizations like the Homes
of Hope in Greenville to help support our older Americans.
For older Americans and people with disabilities, falls are
one of the largest threats in the home. Over 30,000 folks,
somewhere around 36,000 falls a year, are seniors and people
with disabilities experience every single year.
Home modifications can help prevent this from happening, so
the focus on making sure that homes are equipped with the
necessary support systems is so vitally important for longevity
and health.
I am so thankful that the Chairman's mother was able to
overcome the fall and Bob, I am so thankful that she is doing
well and seems like her recovery has been complete. That is a
blessing and it is good to hear, Chairman Casey.
For example, in Charleston, South Carolina, we are now
building something called the ``granny flats'' which allows for
people to use a part of their property to build a place
accommodating their seniors, typically their parents or their
grandparents, on their property. This actually adds more stock
to a very scarce resource which, of course, are the homes that
people can live in.
I am looking forward to seeing more innovation and more
creativity in the marketplace so that we can take advantage of
the opportunity to love and to care for our family members on
our own property.
In addition to that, opportunity zones we passed just a few
years ago now provides another opportunity for the utilization
of real estate in a cost effective way to provide more senior
housing. The fact is that in just 2019 we saw nearly $30
billion invested in opportunity zones in America. That is a
great opportunity for us to provide senior housing at a lower
price point and something that I look forward to discussing
throughout this hearing.
Thank you, so much, Chairman Casey, for holding this
hearing and I look forward to hearing the testimonies of our
witnesses.
The Chairman. Ranking member Scott, thank you for your
opening statement. I want folks listening or watching this
hearing today, as well as our witnesses, to know that we will
have various senators in and out. It is a day when senators
have other hearings or other commitments, so they are in and
out, but I know earlier, and he might still be with us, we were
joined by Senator Rick Scott and so as we go we will try to
weave in senators and their questions when they are available.
I wanted to start with our witness introductions. I will do
the first one and then I will turn to Ranking Member Scott to
introduce our second witness. Our first witness is Dr. Anand
Parekh, who is the Chief Medical Advisor of the Bipartisan
Policy Center. Dr. Parekh is a board-certified internal
medicine physician. Prior to joining the Bipartisan Policy
Center, he served as Deputy Assistant Secretary in the
Department of Health and Human Services in the Senior Executive
Service at the Department from 2008 to 2015. Dr. Parekh will
share his medical and public health expertise today on topics
of home safety and unintentional injury prevention.
Ranking Member Scott?
Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Chairman Casey. It is my
privilege to introduce today Ms. Denise Cleveland-Leggett. She
is the Senior Vice President of Business Development for
Integral, an Atlanta real estate development organization.
Integral is an innovative enterprise helping connect people to
the American dream, as well as focusing some of the time that
she has and her expertise on seniors reaching their American
dream, too.
I am really excited to have her with us today. Ms.
Cleveland-Leggett previously served as a Southeast Region
Administrator for Dept of HUD and managed over 800 employees
while overseeing programs throughout South Carolina and 11
states. She has wide ranging insights into housing policy at
every level, from the Federal Government to on-the-ground needs
and how our policies impact real estate.
She has also been widely recognized for the many talents
and gifts she brings to the community. She received in 2021 the
Women of Influence award and the Justice Robert Benham Award
for Exemplary and Unparalleled Community Service and was
recognized in Who's Who in Black Atlanta. Under her thoughtful
and dedicated guidance, HUD was better able to meet the needs,
the housing needs, of seniors and people with disabilities
across the entire region, including the Palmetto State.
We look forward to hearing your testimony and thank you for
investing your time in this hearing.
The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Scott.
Our third witness today is Ms. Tracey Kelly, who is
Director of Corporate Communications and Public Affairs for
IKEA USA. Ms. Kelly leads IDEA's Safer Life at Home Initiative
focusing on development and innovation related to product
safety.
I must acknowledge Ms. Kelly's Pennsylvania connection. She
graduated from Penn State University and currently lives in
Trappe, Pennsylvania. She will testify to Ikea's work and
support of initiatives to increase home safety.
Our fourth and final witness today is Ms. Janet McGee.
Janet is joining us from St. Paul, Minnesota. She is the
director of Parents Against Tip-overs, a nationwide network of
parents founded in 2018 to advocate for an end to furniture
tip-overs. Ms. McGee's testimony will shed light on the urgent
need to pass the STURDY Act to make our children in our homes
safer.
Now we will turn to our witnesses for their statements, and
I will just call on each witness in the order we introduced
them. I will start with Dr. Parekh.
STATEMENT OF ANAND PAREKH, M.D.,
CHIEF MEDICAL ADVISOR, BIPARTISAN
POLICY CENTER, WASHINGTON, D.C.
Dr. Parekh. Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott and
members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to
appear before you.
I applaud the Committee for hosting this hearing this
morning to shine a light on preventable harm to vulnerable
Americans in the home setting.
My testimony today is based on my perspective as a
physician, former public servant, and currently Chief Medical
Advisor at the Bipartisan Policy Center where I, along with my
colleagues, have spent the last several years concentrating on
the intersection between housing and health. I have concluded,
based on my experience, that housing is health, given the
significant evidence that housing affordability, neighborhood
conditions, and conditions within the home impact health
outcomes.
With respect to the safety and accessibility of the home
setting, I would like to start out by recognizing that this is
an important issue across the life span, from childhood to old
age, and thus I appreciate the Committee's broad focus today.
That being said, I will concentrate my testimony on the older
adult population.
BPC's past report Healthy Aging Begins at Home noted that
while virtually all seniors would like to stay in their homes
for as long as possible, only 1 percent of homes today have the
five universal design features necessary to make them
accessible for those with impaired mobility: no-step entries,
single-floor living, accessible electrical controls and
switches, extra-wide doorways and halls, and lever-style door
and faucet handles. This is despite 38 percent of households 65
and older having at least one person living with a disability.
The reason that home modifications are so important is
they, as the Chairman said, contribute to reductions of tragic
events such as falls. Each year millions of Americans over the
age of 65, more than one out of four, experience a fall. Tens
of thousands of adults die from falls each year, making it the
leading cause of injury-related death in older adults. The
estimated medical costs attributable to fatal and non-fatal
falls is approximately $50 billion.
In sum, most falls happen in the home and most falls are
preventable. In spite of this, there are no comprehensive
programs or policies currently in place across the Federal
Government to tackle this public health challenge.
Given these findings, I offer two recommendations to
the Committee on how the Federal Government can be a better
partner to states, localities, families and individuals in
reducing older adult injuries in the home setting.
First, the Administration should better coordinate Federal
home modification programs to maximize their impact. Given that
multiple departments such as HUD, HHS, USDA, the VA, the
Department of Energy have a role across the executive branch,
the White House should take the lead and create a new
interdepartmental home modification task force.
In recent years, Congress has authorized home modification
grants through HUD and directed GAO to conduct a study of
Federal programs which support home assessments and
modifications for older individuals and individuals with
disabilities.
In addition, the Administration for Community Living at HHS
awarded a grant to the University of Southern California to
create and implement a Home Modification Information Network,
an online searchable data base of home modification tools and
resources.
All of these actions align with or were recommended in
BPC's previous report and we are pleased to see recent progress
to date. That being said, it will be incumbent upon Congress
and the Administration to act on the GAO's upcoming findings as
well as take stock of the work done to date to ensure that
Federal home modification initiatives are coordinated and
yielding maximum impact.
An analysis of these discretionary programs should also be
coupled with a review of how public insurance programs such as
Medicare and Medicaid are covering home modifications.
Finally, a new national partnership with states,
localities, the national Aging Network, and private sector
entities offering modification services should also be
launched. Second, the U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services should make falls prevention a top departmental
priority. A coordinated action plan should be developed to
catalyze research, surveillance, implementation of evidence-
based programs, and a delivery and financing of proven
interventions. This will require building on existing evidence-
based falls prevention programs and necessitate strengthening
partnerships between agencies such as ACL, CDC, NIH, and CMS.
The plan should also include a public awareness component and
could buildupon the CDC's Still Going Strong campaign and the
National Council on Aging's National Falls Prevention Resource
Center.
In addition to facilitating home modification, there are a
number of key actions that should be taken, many of which will
require leadership from CMS. First, CMS should require that
CDC's STEADI falls prevention screening tool, which assesses
for difficulty with walking, balance, or vision and reviews
medication lists, is used by providers conducting an annual
wellness visit for Medicare beneficiaries. Second, CMS should
also include the number of falls-related admissions, as opposed
to simply the number of patients screened, as a quality measure
for alternative payment models and Medicare Advantage plans.
This will further incentive health care entities to focus on
falls prevention, and third, Medicare and Medicaid should
identify ways to scale evidence-based community falls
preventions programs such as the CAPABLE model and A Matter of
Balance through new or existing alternative payment models for
the Medicare Advantage program.
In conclusion, thank you for your leadership in addressing
these issues and I look forward to your questions.
The Chairman. Doctor, thanks very much. Before turning to
our second witness, I want to acknowledge Senator Blumenthal
has joined our hearing. We are grateful for his presence.
Our next witness, our second witness will be Ms. Cleveland-
Leggett.
STATEMENT OF DENISE CLEVELAND-LEGGETT,
SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT OF BUSINESS
DEVELOPMENT, THE INTEGRAL GROUP, ATLANTA, GEORGIA
Ms. Cleveland-Leggett. Good morning, Chairman Casey and
Ranking Member Scott and other members of the Special Committee
on Aging.
Thank you for the introduction, Senator Scott. I am very
proud and happy to be with you today.
I am happy to be with you for a number of reasons, one of
which, I lost in December 2021 my 94-year-old mother. She lived
a life of dignity. Like many people, she met and married the
love of her life. He, unfortunately, passed in 2007. After
that, we had to make a decision. My father wanted my mother to
live in her house as long as she was able to, but as many
people face, failing health makes you have to make changes and
makes you make decisions as to where your parents go, and so we
had to make a decision. We were fortunate as a family to
provide her with fantastic living arrangements until her death.
As we stood around her casket, my siblings and I held hands
and we said we did mom proud. She would have been happy the way
that we allowed her to live out her life with dignity.
Unfortunately, there are many Americans who do not have that
privilege, who do not have the opportunity, not from any fault
of their own, not from any mistakes that they made, because
life happens sometimes unfairly, but life happens and does not
give you the options and the choices that you would want to
make for your loved ones.
I want to tell you a little bit about my company, Integral.
Integral was founded in 1993 by a gentleman by the name of
Egbert Perry. The thing that is so amazing about Integral is
that it is a company that is a development company but it is
one that pushes changing the trajectory and the lives of
people, not just free houses but it is built to make things
better and change the lives of the individuals that they serve.
What they did in 1993 was unparalleled. There was, in this
country, many people who lived in the cities. There was
concentrated poverty and people did not know really what to do.
Through innovation and working with the Housing Authority
Director Renee Glover, they worked to build public-private
partnerships that would change people's lives so that you now
have the public sector and the private sector working together
to make a change.
With that change, they created something called the Atlanta
Model. That Atlanta Model is a community development strategy,
incorporates multiple public-private partnerships to deliver
several elements to planned communities. It was such an amazing
feat that then-Secretary Cisneros took the Atlanta model and
codified it into HUD's programs and pushed it out to over 3,400
housing authorities for them to implement.
At HUD, I was able to see tremendous work that had come
about, not just from the Atlanta Model but things like the
Opportunity Zones.
A non-partisan Joint Committee on Taxation found 42.4
percent of $24 billion invested in Opportunity Zone funds went
to low-income housing and developments and communities in 2019.
I also was able to see the benefits of Choice Neighborhoods
and what that funding does. It changes the lives of people. I
have gone from house to house and the opportunities that I have
had with seniors who have come up to me, given me a hug, and
said thank you, I never thought that this was possible. I never
thought these living conditions were possible. They showed me
their kitchens, where they now can walk in because the kitchens
were made appropriate. They had hallways that were wide enough
to get a wheelchair through. They had showers that did not have
barriers for them to get in and out of.
We saw a number of different amazing things happen while I
was at HUD, but despite all of that, and the things that were
accomplished, $70 billion in backlog repairs still existing in
most public housing units. Much of the public infrastructure is
more than 80 years old and has been utilized for decades and
has weathered many years of normal wear and tear with
fluctuating levels of funding for maintenance and
rehabilitation. Only 20 percent of housing units are accessible
to persons who use walkers, canes and wheelchairs.
We are on a collision course with reality. In 1950, when
much of the Nation's current public housing stock was
constructed, only 8 percent of the U.S. population was 65 or
older. By 2019, the number more than doubled, to 16.5 percent.
By 2050, the population over the age of 65 is expected to be at
least 22 percent. In the next 30 years, one in five Americans
will be a senior citizen and a significant portion of them will
be on fixed incomes.
Some estimates calculate 53 percent of all of today's
public housing residents are either elderly or disabled. It is
becoming increasingly apparent that our Nation's public housing
asset, as fragile as it is, has become one of the Nation's
largest senior housing programs and catering to the market
niche of low-income housing. I am speaking of the many
teachers, of clerks, mechanics, and others who find themselves
in their communities and their governments, their tax dollars
to support when they retire.
Many of them, as I said earlier, this is nothing due to any
negative things that they did or they did not do. There are so
many things such as health, loss of job, loss of income, lower
income that allows these circumstances to overtake our seniors.
It is up to us to make a difference.
Older adults are looking for safe homes on private markets
where onerous zoning regulations sometimes prevent that housing
from occurring. For seniors on fixed incomes looking to age in
place, these regulations can leave them with too few options.
I believe that these individuals look to us, look to you as
their legislators, look to us who participate today as their
voice. We are the voice of the voiceless. We are the voice of
those people who need assistance and there are many mechanisms
that we can utilize to make things better. Working together
collectively public-private partnerships can make a difference,
can make a change, which I have seen through my time at HUD and
now in the private sector. I believe that we, again, have to be
the voice of the voiceless.
Thank you very much.
The Chairman. Thank you, Ms. Cleveland-Leggett, for your
testimony.
We will turn next to Ms. Kelly.
STATEMENT OF TRACEY KELLY, US SAFER LIFE
AT HOME DEVELOPMENT MANAGER, IKEA USA,
TRAPPE, PENNSYLVANIA
Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott,
and the Senate Special Committee on Aging, for inviting IKEA to
join in this important conversation.
We share your commitment to creating a safer home for
everyone, especially the most vulnerable: young children and
seniors. That is why we support the STURDY Act. This
legislation will decrease the risk of furniture-related tip-
over incidents and make homes safer by strengthening safety
standards for clothing storage units, and it will accomplish
two important objections.
First, it encourages industry to invest in research and the
development of furniture safety innovations and it ensures that
safety and testing standards can be adapted to incorporate such
innovations in the future. That is a vital component of a
comprehensive approach to reduce the risk of tip-over.
Second, STURDY provides a rulemaking process that has
proven to produce final rules at the Consumer Product Safety
Commission without delay. By avoiding delays of 2 years or
more, brands like IKEA will be able to introduce new safety
innovations and bring new products to market with confidence.
In short, the STURDY Act promotes innovation and regulatory
clarity. This will be good for families, parents, children, and
seniors. This will be good for business, for our business and
other businesses. Most importantly, this will be good for
safety.
IKEA has been engaged in the prevention of furniture tip-
over for years. This is not just an issue for IKEA. It is an
industry-wide issue. It is a worldwide issue and it is an issue
for all ages.
When we look at furniture related accidents across all age
groups, more children tragically lose their lives, but as was
mentioned before, far too many people age 60 and over also
fatally are injured by falling furniture and appliances. From
2000 to 2019, seniors were the second largest age group who
sustained a fatal injury caused by tip-over accidents, 14
percent of all reported fatalities. A total of 3,200 seniors,
an average of 60 a week, were seriously injured by tip-over
accidents and required medical attention.
At IKEA, we believe that everyone has the right to feel
safe at home, from children to seniors and everyone in between.
We are investing in research, innovation, product development,
and testing for furniture stability. For us, as for so many
others, our interest and our innovations are intensely
personal.
When one of our furniture designers was recovering from a
debilitating stroke, she gained a new perspective on
maintaining an independent life at home. Her life-altering
event inspired our collection OMT'NKSAM. That is a mouthful,
but it is Swedish for caring. The products in this collection
are designed to help seniors to remain in their homes and
includes a beautiful wing-backed chair that would look great in
any house. The hidden feature is in the design, as the chair
makes it easier to both sit and to stand.
Promoting safety is a big job and none of us can do it
alone. IKEA has a long history of collaborating with others on
challenging topics. To introduce another Swedish word, our term
for togetherness is KRAFTSAMLA. We collaborate with others on
standard-setting, solution development, and with STURDY,
advocating for important legislation.
We are grateful for our partnership with organizations such
as Parents Against Tip-Overs, Kids in Danger, and the Consumer
Federation of America who share the same goal to make homes
safer.
From our retail stores and website, through to our social
media channels, we regularly update and inform our customers on
how we can help them reduce safety risks in the homes.
During this pandemic, we have all been reminded that
everyone deserves a home where they are safe and where their
loves ones are safe. Let us work together to pass the STURDY
Act and let us continue to work together to create a safer home
for everyone, from children to seniors.
Thank you for your time today and for bringing us together
around this important topic.
The Chairman. Ms. Kelly, thanks for your testimony.
We will turn now to our fourth and final witness, Janet
McGee. Ms. McGee, you may begin.
STATEMENT OF JANET McGEE, DIRECTOR,
PARENTS AGAINST TIP-OVERS, EAGAN, MINNESOTA
Ms. McGee. Chairman Casey, Ranking Member Scott, and
members of the Special Committee on Aging, thank you for
allowing me to share my story with you today.
My name is Janet McGee and I am a mom from Minnesota.
When I was 20 years old, I graduated from the University of
Minnesota with my degree in Mortuary Science. I served families
for many years as a mortician. You might imagine the schedule
of night calls, embalmings, night and weekend funerals.
When the call schedule became too much for me, a single mom
at the time, I decided to change careers to create a more
consistent and stable lifestyle for my son.
I started working at a Fortune 500 company, worked my way
through attaining my MBA, and grew a whole new career. By 2016,
I finally had what I had always wanted, a stable career, a
balanced life, a husband, and a precious new child, Ted, who
was born in 2014. Life was finally good.
On Sunday, February 14, 2016, I put Teddy down for a nap
while the rest of our family went about our quiet Sunday
afternoon. I was checking on him every 15 to 20 minutes,
waiting for him to finally fall asleep. When I did not hear him
after a while, I went into his room to confirm he had finally
drifted off. What I saw next is something I cannot unsee. Ted
was not in his bed and the dresser in this bedroom had fallen
forward.
In a panic, I screamed for someone to call 911, somehow
stood the dresser back up, and started digging through a pile
of drawers and clothes. My dear 22-month-old son Ted was at the
bottom of the pile. His face was purple. He had blood coming
out of his nose and mouth and his feet were starting to feel
cold.
I started CPR immediately while my 11-year-old son, the one
that I had worked so hard to create a better life for, ran into
the room, saw Ted in this State, and called 911. Despite being
near his room this whole time, I did not hear his dresser fall
and I could not understand how this happened.
The paramedics got Ted to the hospital and while they found
a faint heartbeat, there was simply nothing more that could be
done. Ted died that day, about 4 hours after I found him, from
what I came to know as a furniture tip-over incident.
Being a former mortician, I put on his last diaper, I
dressed him, I put on his Thomas the Train light-up shoes, and
I placed him in his casket at the funeral home. His shoes would
never light up again and all I could think is that I should be
planning his second birthday party, not his funeral.
While I thought Ted's death was a completely isolated
incident, I learned shortly after he died that he was not
alone. His dresser did not meet the safety standard for
clothing storage units and, worse yet, it did not have to
because it is a voluntary standard.
Thousands of children, adults, and seniors are sent to the
ER every year from tip-over related incidents and sadly, over
570 people have died from tip-overs in the last two decades.
According to the Consumer Product Safety Commission, 82 percent
of these fatalities were children and 14 percent were seniors.
In 2014, I helped form a national parent coalition called
Parents Against Tip-Overs, which is comprised of parents from
across the Nation who have all lost their children to tip-
overs. Each one of us thought our child was the only one this
had happened to, and each one of us learned shortly after their
death that they were not.
While you are hearing my story today, I hope you can
understand my voice is one of many. Today, I represent the
parents out there who cannot bring themselves to speak publicly
about their tip-over incident or have been shamed, sometimes
publicly, by others to believe they are somehow responsible for
their child's death.
I represent all the parents out there who are now full-time
caregivers for their children because of a brain trauma or loss
of oxygen caused by a tip-over, and I represent adults who are
helping care for their elderly parents due to medical issues
stemming from a tip-over.
While the ASTM F15.42 Subcommittee that sets the safety
standard for clothing storage units has been in existence for
over two decades, very little has changed with the way these
units are tested. The safety standard remains voluntary, not
mandatory. The testing does not account for real-world use
scenarios such as multiple drawers being open at once or a unit
being used on a carpeted surface.
Additionally, it does not test for drawers being loaded
with clothing and does not account for the dynamic force a
child might put on a dresser while they yank out drawers to get
dressed.
Today, I come before you to ask for your support in passing
the STURDY Act. This piece of legislation would require these
gaps between real-world use and current testing to be accounted
for and would finally make the safety standard mandatory. It
would give power back to the CPSC to do what it was designed to
do, which is protect the public from unreasonable risks of
injury or death associated with consumer products, especially
when the standard setting process has proven to be
insufficient.
We are on a race against the clock to get more stable
clothing storage units on the market. Since my son died in
2016, 52 more people that we know of have been killed by a tip-
over and this, unfortunately, will continue to happen until
clothing storage units can be designed inherently stable
following the passage of the STURDY Act. After years of hard
work, all stakeholders are finally in agreement on the language
of the STURDY Act. We have done the legwork for you, now I urge
you to offer your full support for this life saving bill.
Thank you for hearing my testimony today.
The Chairman. Ms. McGee, thank you for your testimony and
your courage in coming forward to talk not only today but I
know on many other days to stand up for other children and to
stand up for families.
The fact that you are willing to share your son Ted's story
I know will give and continue to give inspiration to other
families, but it has also helped us with policy changes and
advancing legislation so I want to thank you for that.
I cannot even begin to imagine what you and your family
have lived through but we are grateful to you for your
willingness to be here today and on so many other days to help
move this legislation forward.
I know that just last night I was talking to one of my
colleagues here, one of your two home State senators, Senator
Klobuchar, who has been working with us since the beginning of
this legislation to move it forward and I want to thank you for
working with her and working with so many others to make this
happen.
As you said in your statement, you said that you hoped that
we could understand that ``my voice is one of many.'' And that
is true. Your voice and the voices of those families have not
been fully heard yet, but they are about to be because we are
going to get this legislation passed.
I wanted to ask you just a basic question about the nature
of the bill and why passage of the legislation is important. I
know you have addressed that already in your statement, but
what passage of this bill would mean to you and the families
you work with through Parents Against Tip-Overs.
Ms. McGee. Thank you for that question, Chairman Casey.
For all of us parents in PAT, passing the STURDY Act would
be a huge milestone in the fight to finally stop tip-overs.
Some of the parents in our group have been advocating for tip-
over prevention for well over a decade, some almost two, and it
would mean we finally will have a timeline for when we can
expect to see more stable clothing storage units on the market.
It would mean that we can finally rest, knowing that all
manufacturers are going to be held accountable to the new
mandatory standard, so essentially, it will finally mean that
we can see a light at the end of the tunnel.
The Chairman. Again, I want to thank you. As you and others
will note today, we have had a breakthrough recently to get
agreement so we are working with senators in both parties. The
House has already acted, as you know.
We are on a pathway. We are not done yet, but we are going
to get there. Again, I want to thank you for that help.
I wanted to turn, in the remaining time that I have in this
block of questions to Dr. Parekh. As you know, it is estimated
that a quarter of all adults ages 65 and older will fall each
year. As I mentioned, the death number that is related to these
falls among seniors is 34,000 seniors pass away due to
complications from falls every year. We know that most of the
falls occur within the home. We also know that evidence-based
programs can prevent the harms that result from these falls.
I am a cosponsor of a piece of legislation introduced by
Senator Angus King of Maine, the Preventive Home Visit Act,
Senate Bill 2175, which would enable people with Medicare to
receive personalized home and safety recommendations from a
trained medical professional and it may reduce falls.
Doctor, in your written testimony you State that ``housing
is health.'' Why is it important for us to promote home safety
for older adults.
Dr. Parekh. Senator, thank you so much for that question.
You know, I think the answer is this is an opportunity for
all of us to save lives, to save lives, reduce suffering,
increase independence. The demographics warranted with the rise
of seniors, aging of the U.S. population, more seniors living
alone, more seniors living in rural America, more seniors with
disabilities needing long-term services and supports, home
modifications is just so critical to reduce injury and to save
lives.
I think home modifications and falls prevention go
together. Low-come, high-impact home modifications can reduce
falls. Community-based programs like A Matter of Balance, which
you alluded to, the Capable Program, those can also reduce
falls, and then there are things that we can terms in terms of
clinically, better screening and assessing individuals at high
risk for falls.
The legislation that you have mentioned, I think that can
be important, particularly having qualified providers like an
occupational therapist being able to assess inside the home,
individuals at high risk for falls, you can certainly see how
that could reduce suffering, reduce falls, as well as save
lives.
I think making sure we get the right qualified
professional, making sure we focus on high-risk individuals,
and then connecting them with the home modifications they need,
as well as the medical care they need, I think is critical.
The Chairman. Doctor, thanks very much.
I will turn next to Ranking Member Scott.
Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Chairman Casey.
Ms. Cleveland-Leggett, a question for you as relates to
achieving the American dream. It seems like the American dream
is synonymous with home ownership and the fact of the matter is
as we watch down payments, the value of home goes up, therefore
the amount of the down payment also goes up. We see that,
without any question, seniors and families who struggle to
afford a home seem to be heading in the same direction, higher,
and higher, and higher.
Can you talk about the critical role Opportunity Zones can
play in expanding access to safe, affordable housing?
Ms. Cleveland-Leggett. Yes, Senator.
The Opportunity Zones can play an absolutely critical role.
When you have the public and private partnerships, when you
have private developers at the table trying to do what they can
in order to increase housing, it makes a difference. I have
seen it. I have seen housing that has come about through
Opportunity Zones, allows people to live in a dignified
location in a manner--not only seniors but non-seniors have
housing now because of the Opportunity Zones and the investment
that developers are willing to make into these communities.
As I said earlier, the finding from the nonpartisan Joint
Committee found that 24 percent of the $24 billion invested in
Opportunity Zone Funds went to low-income communities, and it
is not just low-income communities. I have seen where they are
invested in workforce housing in a city like Birmingham where
there is an old factory and an Opportunity Zone developer came
in, tore well, did not tear it down but revitalized it. It
became a beautiful workforce housing development.
Housing is critical and Opportunity Zones allows this to
happen through developers who are allowed to invest and create
new housing in these communities.
Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, ma'am.
Another question for you. I served on County Council in a
prior life it feels like at this point in my career. In that
life, I will say without any question, watching the zoning
decisions and land use restrictions that are sometimes placed
from the local level, whether it is the municipal or the county
levels, really does restrict the amount of homes on the market,
so to speak. 39 percent of seniors say that unaffordable
housing is a major problem and a reality, and you cannot have a
safe home if you cannot afford a home at all.
Could you explain how land use regulations hurt the poorest
and most vulnerable Americans and what impact reforms like
accessory dwelling units can have on vulnerable populations?
Ms. Cleveland-Leggett. Yes, Senator.
Zoning which, as you have indicated, is a local issue, it
is a State and municipal and local issue, they make the zoning
rules but they can have long-term and wide reaching effects. I
have seen communities, and particularly when you are dealing
with low-income and even the homeless population where you have
restrictions on the type of dwellings that can go in a
particular location. It does not allow certain multifamily
housing to come up, which would be beneficial to seniors and,
as I said, even the homeless population.
Cities where you see the homeless population burgeoning,
which could include seniors who no longer have a place to
dwell, are limited because of the zoning regulations that limit
what kind of dwelling can be erected, so absolutely.
It would behoove us to reach out to our local communities,
local decisionmakers, to understand what wide-reaching effect
their regulations have on the ability of individuals to sustain
a life. Housing is critical for our seniors. Everyone is not in
a position to have their relatives live with them, but the ADUs
or accessory development units can be beneficial. That also is
regulated locally, so where you can put them, what you can do--
but for those of you who do not know what they are, they are
basically additions in your home.
Say I had a house and I want to widen my house and to
create new housing for someone to come in and live, those
accessory dwelling units are permissible if the local
legislators allow this to happen. More and more, it is an
option. If you have got the land, or if you can even
rehabilitate your own existing house where you could create
something, it could create an ADU, as well.
Things like that are important. Changing the regulations
and also expanding the regulations so that they allow for ADUs
in our communities.
Senator Tim Scott. Thank you so much.
Chairman Casey, I turn it back to you, sir.
The Chairman. Thank you, Ranking Member Scott.
I know we are awaiting one or two senators right now but in
the interim, maybe I will get a question and then we will
transition as we go.
I wanted to turn to Ms. Kelly regarding the work that you
have done at IKEA. You made reference in your testimony to
IKEA's Safer Life at Home initiative, focusing on safety and
innovation. Part of this work includes IKEA's work to advance
the legislation I made reference to, the STURDY Act, and
promote furniture stability.
As you note in your testimony, IKEA believes the STURDY Act
promotes ``innovation and regulatory clarity'' and is good for
families and businesses alike. I want to thank IKEA for the
work you have done and the partnership in this effort.
Here is a two-part question. What has driven IKEA's
interest in leading by example on these product safety issues
and innovation? That is kind of part one of the question.
Part two is why is it important for the industry more
broadly to be involved in this kind of work?
Ms. Kelly. Thank you, Chairman Casey.
Our knowledge at IKEA about life at home and the resources
that we have in product development and design and our
understanding of how customers engage lets us contribute to
these topics and, in some cases, we can lead. As a major
retailer and manufacturer, we feel it is our responsibility to
do that. We have a reach of millions of customers around the
world, so when we decide to take action we can actually make a
meaningful difference, but while we continue to improve in our
own business, we know that if we want to make change that is
wider, that is industry wide, then we need to work with other
stakeholders and we need to work with stakeholders who are
leaders in this area. We believe that the best solutions happen
when you bring together a diverse group with different
perspectives, sometimes unlikely groups of people and
organizations, but with a common goal.
We believe that as a business we have an important
perspective to bring to these conversations and that, by
working together, we can come to solutions that work to promote
safety but at the same time work for business.
Thank you.
The Chairman. Ms. Kelly, thanks very much.
I wanted to turn to our next senator, but I also want to
acknowledge that Senator Warner has joined us.
I will now turn to Senator Gillibrand.
Senator Gillibrand. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman.
In comparison to the population at large starting at age
65, older Americans are more than twice as likely to be killed
or injured by firs. Many older Americans experience poor
eyesight, loss of hearing, arthritis, dementia, and side
effects from medicine that can make it difficult to react to a
fire.
I have introduced legislation, the Housing Temperature
Safety Act, which would require the installation of heat
sensors in federally subsidized housing. I am also a cosponsor
of the Public Housing Fire Safety Act, which would provide
funding for public housing agencies to install automatic
sprinkler systems.
Dr. Parekh, what impact would requiring installations of
fire prevention mechanisms such as heat sensors and sprinklers
have on older Americans? Second, do you believe it would be
significantly and meaningfully helpful to increase the safety
of older Americans toward housing fire dangers?
Dr. Parekh. Senator Gillibrand, thank you for that question
and this important public health issue.
I think certainly, there is data to support automatic
sprinkler systems. Heat sensors also can be a sensitive way to
detect a fire, so I do think that these interventions should be
looked at, certainly the feasibility, the cost studies, as
well.
I will also say that, more broadly in terms of fire
prevention if you look at older adults, the most common cause
of home fire deaths in the elderly still is smoking, so smoking
cessation I think is critical here, ensuring that their smoke
alarms are battery operated, ensuring that there is cooking
safety, space heater safety, the use of space heaters, all of
these prevention tools in addition to the interventions that
you are articulating I think could make a big difference in
reducing fire deaths in the elderly population.
Senator Gillibrand. Most older adults prefer to remain in
their homes and communities as they age, yet many older adults
face significant challenges to safety and independence because
of modifiable risk factors in their homes. Unintentional home
injuries cause more than 30,000 deaths and 12 million non-fatal
injuries annually in the United States. Home improvements,
modifications, and repairs can enhance home accessibility over
a person's life span and reduce the risk of unintentional
injuries.
These improvements may include addressing unsafe furniture
or appliances or supporting balance to reduce risk of falls.
For Ms. McGee, thank you for sharing your story. I know
that it cannot be easy but I appreciate you bringing the
awareness to this issue.
You mentioned the STURDY Act that would help prevent
injuries and harm from furniture tipping over. Can you please
describe the standards this legislation would set to stabilize
furniture and how it would help prevent dangerous incidents of
future furniture tipping?
Ms. McGee. Absolutely. Thank you for this question,
Senator.
As many people on the call know, the Consumer Product
Safety Commission released an NPR last year after four-plus of
investing the tip-over issue. Their 1,200 page document was a
lot to read but it does say one thing very clearly, and that is
that the current safety standard is woefully inadequate.
We, as parents, already knew this. We knew of units that
meet today's safety standards that have fallen over. We
actually have a parent in our group who lost her son in 2017
from a dresser that meets today's safety standard and is still
being sold in stores today.
We know that change is coming. Manufacturers know change is
coming. We stakeholders are all in agreement that STURDY is the
best way to get this done. The STURDY Act requirements would
hold manufacturers accountable not only because it would be a
mandatory standard rather than voluntary, but also because it
would test for those real-world use scenarios that I had
mentioned that are not being tested for today, so dressers
being loaded with clothes, which is how we use them, multiple
drawers being open at once, dressers being used on carpeted
surfaces, and the dynamic force being put on dressers during
real use scenarios.
Senator Gillibrand. Yes.
Thank you very much, and thank you, Mr. Chairman, for this
important hearing.
The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Gillibrand.
We will next turn to Senator Braun.
Senator Braun. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I have had a lot of interaction with builders back in
Indiana and their main concern, in fact one that is trying to
find that sweet spot of where you abide by the regulations but
still can build something affordable, whether it is regular
housing, elderly, kind of low-income housing.
I would be interested to hear from each panelist, each
witness, the one or two regulations out there that you most
often hear about that well-intended but cause a
disproportionate amount of expense and cost, and I can think of
one related to WOTUS, and I am one that is very sensitive about
taking care of the environment, but in talking to developers,
that constantly was an issue that could raise the cost of any
development.
I would like to start with Ms. Cleveland-Leggett and let us
go through to where each of you take maybe a minute or so and
tell me what you hear most often, the regulations that need to
be maybe changed, that would give us the biggest bang for our
buck to find a sweeter spot, especially on individual housing
but I think it would across the board.
Go ahead, Ms. Cleveland-Leggett, to start off.
Ms. Cleveland-Leggett. Yes.
There is not a specific regulation that comes to mind but I
do think it is so critical that there be public-private
partnerships involved. One of the things that most developers
that do low-income housing, the talk about the tax credits.
That is something that is issued by the Treasury Department and
ultimately utilized and distributed by the State, so each State
is allocated a certain number of tax credits. That is a must in
developing low-income housing. They need those tax credits, so
that is not really a regulation, but it is a necessary
component to developing low-income housing.
I believe that putting our minds together, one of the
things that we have been able to do in the past is work
together to come up with what works. There are some situations
where it does not necessarily work, but most developers who are
in this space have come up with ways to make it work and that
primary way is through low-income tax credits.
Senator Braun. Thank you there. We have got about maybe 30
to 40 seconds for the other witnesses to chime in, as well. Go
ahead.
Dr. Parekh. I will just say very briefly, Senator, our
Senior Health and Housing Task Force at the Bipartisan Policy
Center was very much in support of the Low-Income Housing Tax
Credit and also made a recommendation in line with what Ms.
Cleveland-Leggett talked about but reforming zoning laws to
allow for accessory dwelling units.
The long and the short of it is that seniors, there is a
dearth of affordable housing out there and we need to look at
all ways where we can ensure that seniors have accessible,
affordable housing and looking at those zoning laws locally, I
think, is one path forward.
Senator Braun. Anyone else want to weigh in?
If not, I think that whenever you are looking at
regulations, zoning ordinances, there is always I think the
lack of maybe trying to quantify how much that actually costs,
but it all gets, in kind of a nebulous way, built into the cost
of trying to get what we are after, something that is more
practical to make it affordable, so I think that most agencies
know that it adds to the cost, never take the time to maybe
figure out exactly how much that is per square foot.
I think it would be smart to do because a lot of what I
hear, in terms of getting the sweet spot, especially on entry
level single-family homes, it is about $30,000 to $40,000 away
from where it should be. In many instances, they think about
half of that cost could be due to regulations that they are
uncertain the value to say the eventual home owner or the
process and that there needs to be more attention paid on
actually when we do regulate what it costs even per board foot.
Observation here and a lot out in the field. Thanks for
taking the time to respond to the question. I appreciate it.
The Chairman. Thank you, Senator Braun.
Before moving to our next Senator, I want to acknowledge
Senator Kelly has joined the hearing.
Now we will turn to Senator Rosen.
Senator Rosen. Well, thank you, Chairman Casey and I am not
in the room but Ranking Member Scott, if you are there, thank
you as well for holding, of course, this really important
hearing, and the witnesses, thank you all for being here today.
We really appreciate you.
I just want to talk a little bit about enhancing assistive
technology for seniors at home. We know it is important to age
in place and we are increasingly seeing the benefits of new and
innovative technology changing the way seniors are living,
aging at home. Technology offers greater security and
independence for seniors, ultimately really preserving their
quality of life.
In Nevada, we are helping to lead the way in some of those
innovative work. For example, in 2017, members of UNLV's
student engineering team won first place in an Department of
Energy competition when they worked directly with Nevada
seniors to build a home designed to help older adults age in
place powered entirely by solar energy with smart homes and
health monitoring technology.
Dr. Parekh, as a clinician and a public health expert, how
do you think we can adapt the existing technology we have,
upgrade it however we need to, to meet the needs of seniors,
older adults, or as we age in place in our own home how can we
continue to upgrade?
Dr. Parekh. Senator, thank you for that question.
Congratulations to the UNLV team. Certainly technology is a
solution here. I think we have to meet seniors where they are
in realizing that many seniors may have vision or balance or
movement challenges. I think technologies that are easy to use,
user-friendly, that they can see, they can interface with their
health care provider or others, I think are going to be
absolutely critical.
There are so many technologies out there, so also ensuring
that we have research so that we know which of these
interventions and technologies lead to the best outcomes, I
think is really important.
Broadband is absolutely going to be critical, as well,
here, and then we need to increase awareness of those
technologies, ensure that they are accessible. That could be
reimbursement through insurance or that could be through tax
credits or grants in the private sector taking the lead.
I think there are a number of things here. We have to make
them user-friendly. We have to make the research is there, make
sure that there is awareness, and make sure, particularly for
low-income Americans, that the public and private sector are
supporting access for them.
Senator Rosen. That is great.
I want to build on that because I stepped away from my
career to take care of my parents and in-laws, and so I want to
be sure that we have to ensure that families caring for their
aging relatives like I did have access and aware about the new
technologies.
You talked about broadband. It is particularly important
for low-income families and for telehealth for those families
that do not have easy access to health care providers.
Do you have any ideas about what more we can do to help the
caregivers and ensure that families have access to health care?
Dr. Parekh. Well, I think the telehealth piece is so
critical. We have seen the importance of telemedicine during
this pandemic. Remote monitoring technologies are so important,
as well. There are many consumer-facing apps that are evidence-
based that promote self-management, so I think we have to
continue pushing the envelope on telehealth.
I would say it is not only important from a directed health
perspective but, Senator, we are also facing a significant
public health challenge in this country of social isolation and
loneliness amongst elders, Social isolation increases mortality
by 29 percent, increases the risk of chronic conditions, leads
to the cost to the Medicare program. Connectivity through
broadband, connecting seniors or loved ones with family,
friends, the resources and supports they need, I think are
going to be so critical moving forward.
Senator Rosen. Well, I am actually glad you brought that up
because that was actually my next question was senior isolation
and some of the safety issues around senior isolation like
preventing falls, so you set me right up for the next question
because falls are the leading safety concern for older
Americans. A quarter of Americans aged 65 and older fall each
year, billions of visits to the emergency room, 34,000 deaths
among adults aged 65 years and older annually from falls.
We also know COVID, seniors were so isolated. It really has
an impact on your mental health and then your physical health.
I am curious to learn a little bit more about the creative ways
communities are responding the prevent falls in the home and
also to address the social isolation.
How do you think--have you seen some research? Or what can
we do to be sure that we increase the safety from falls
specifically and really try to decrease that feeling of social
isolation?
Dr. Parekh. Yes, I think the most important thing we can do
is to support seniors in ensuring that they are physically
active and that they are seen and can be seen.
The best data I have seen is from the National Poll on
Healthy Aging out of the University of Michigan. It does appear
that during the pandemic more seniors were less active, their
physical conditioning decreased, they experienced more falls.
This was more common in women and those who lack companionship,
so all of this social isolation, falls, they are all connected.
I do not know how families have mitigated this but my
hypothesis, Senator, would be that what we need to do is ensure
that they feel connected, that they are seen, that they are
visited, and they are engaged physically. Physical activity is
also critical to reducing falls.
Senator Rosen. Well, improving access to broadband and
telemedicine and visitation, community, other kind of
engagement are really important.
Thank you so much. I yield bank.
The Chairman. Senator Rosen, thanks very much for your
questions.
I will turn next to Ranking Member Scott.
Senator Tim Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
What an interesting hearing, by the way, and I think are
panelists are doing a really good job of distilling some of the
important issues, from health care to housing, that we all see
our seniors facing and looking for ways to overcome them, so
thank you very much for holding this hearing. I am so thankful
for the panelists for bringing your expertise to bear against a
very important issue.
Ms. Cleveland-Leggett, seniors are a growing share of the
housing market as our population ages. I think you said
something that caught my attention, that one out of five
Americans in the years coming will be seniors. I have also
heard statistics that we are on the verge of having more people
becoming seniors than we have births in our Nation. That is a
challenge for a nation that is not yet replacing ourselves, so
we have a lot of work that needs to be done.
The private sector is increasingly recognizing the trend in
the aging of our population. Some companies are starting to
offer expanded home modification and assistive technology
services and expertise.
Could you help us understand the role of the private sector
and innovative small businesses in meeting seniors' housing
needs?
Ms. Cleveland-Leggett. The private sector is critical for a
number of different reasons. The public sector does not have
the wherewithal to bear the burden by itself. You have got HUD,
you have got HHS, you have got the VA with VASH Vouchers. You
have got other Federal organizations.
However, alone they cannot bear the burden, and so it is a
necessary component, the private sector is critical not only
for innovation but also their dollars. Them putting forth the
backbone, the backup financially, and then bringing that to the
table, because the private sector dollars coupled with the
public sector dollars makes a difference.
I have seen from organizations that come to play with
public dollars, with Choice Neighborhoods grants, $30 million.
That sounds like a lot of money, but when you start building
and putting together the kind of communities that we need, the
$30 million in a Choice Neighborhood grant is also enhanced
when you have got a private developer coming in and adding to
that financially and adding their ability to put together
innovative housing.
The private sector is critical. We cannot continue and we
cannot develop the way that we want to just on government
funding. It really will not work.
I have seen it time and time again in the places that I
have visited and it is critical. From every State that I
oversaw to Puerto Rico to the USVI it is absolutely an
essential component to have the private sector as partners in
this.
As I said earlier, what are some of the things that brings
them to the table? Bringing them to the table are the tax
credits. That helps them pencil out, that helps them make sense
of what they want to do because, of course, they are there to--
they are not non-profit, so they are there to make money, which
is not a bad thing. However, many of them have come to the
table with the right mission.
That is why I am with Integral, because of their mission.
They are mission oriented. Yes, they are a private developer,
but they have also incorporated in their mission that they are
going to change the trajectory of the lives of the people that
they serve, whether it is elderly, whether it is low-income, no
matter who it is, and there are other developers who have done
that, but in my estimation, no one has done it as well as
Integral.
Senator Tim Scott. Thank you very much for the answer.
Mr. Chairman, I will certainly have answers for another
round perhaps, depending on time. I will use my last 10 seconds
to just acknowledge the fact that you think about public
housing for our seniors. The backlog for repairs is over $70
billion, so we have a lot of work that needs to be done to make
sure that even accessible and safe public housing is up to code
for our seniors, so to speak.
Thank you for the time.
The Chairman. Ranking Member Scott, thanks very much for
your questions in the second round. We are going to have to
conclude but I wanted to just have some closing comments before
turning again to the Ranking Member.
Today, in this hearing, our witnesses helped us better
understanding both health and safety issues within the home.
Our witnesses of course, and we are grateful for their
testimony and their presence today, our witnesses demonstrated
that Congress most do more to prevent tragedies caused by
unintentional home injuries.
I believe we must support older adults aging safely in
their homes through passage of bills like the Preventive Home
Visit Act that I mentioned earlier, Senator King's legislation.
We learned that falls can be prevented through common sense
and cost effective home modifications and evidence-based
programs.
We also have to ensure furniture sold to consumers is
tested for both safety and stability. I believe we owe this to
children like Teddy McGee, Katie Lambert, Curren Collas, and so
many other children and to their families, and to every family
who last lost a loved one from a preventable injury like a fall
or a furniture tip-over, whether that individual is a child or
a senior.
This starts with passage of the bipartisan STURDY Act, a
bill that will save children's lives. As Ms. McGee noted in her
testimony, a coalition of consumer groups, parents, and
industry partners have come to an agreement on advancing the
STURDY Act legislation. They have done the hard work for us,
all these months--longer than months now--working on an
agreement, so now it is time for the Senate to take on its
responsibility to ensure that our homes are safe.
I will turn next to Ranking Member Scott for his closing
remarks.
Senator Tim Scott. Let me just thank each and every person
who provided testimony in today's hearing, so valuable was the
testimonies that we have heard, the answers to the questions
provided more light into solutions.
I am always a fan of public-private partnerships to meet
the problems and the challenges of this country, especially in
the housing area. I think we heard excellent testimony, heart-
wrenching testimony around the challenges of falls and
furniture falling on kids particularly and overall falls by
seniors, more than 36,000 a year.
You all provided us a number of solutions. I also want to
note the fact that the use of virtual health or telemedicine is
becoming an important part of senior living and one that we
should all be excited about and look forward to having more
hearings and more discussions around providing excellent
quality health care without seniors having to necessarily drive
to appointments but having the opportunity to have those
appointments from where they live.
In fact, as we think about where they live, making sure
that affordable, safe housing is a part of the primary
responsibility as we think about the golden years of our
seniors would be an incredibly important part of the
engagement.
Thank you all for being here.
Mr. Chairman, I yield back.
The Chairman. Ranking Member Scott, thanks very much.
I want to note, for the record, that we may have set a
record this month. We have had three Committee hearings. I want
to thank Ranking Member Scott for his work and his cooperation,
as well as the staffs of both of our teams, all of the hours
that they put into have three hearings in a month. Ranking
Member Scott, I think it is a record but it is probably not a
record we want to set every month. Scott
Senator Tim Scott. Some records should lie, they should
stay set forever.
The Chairman. But it is, we are grateful for all of the
work that they did.
Senator Tim Scott. Indeed.
The Chairman. For today's hearing, I want to once again
thank all our witnesses for contributing both their time and
their expertise and their personal experiences that bring to
bear on so many of these issues that involve safety.
For the record, if any Senator has additional questions for
witnesses or statements to be added to the record, the hearing
record will be kept open for 7 days until next Thursday, April
7th.
Thank you again everyone for participating.
This concludes today's hearing.
[Whereupon, at 11:25 a.m., the Committee was adjourned.]
=======================================================================
APPENDIX
=======================================================================
Prepared Witness Statements
=======================================================================
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
=======================================================================
Questions for the Record
=======================================================================
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
=======================================================================
Statements for the Record
=======================================================================
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
[all]