[House Hearing, 116 Congress]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]



 

                         MARKUP OF: H. RES. 755,
                    ARTICLES OF IMPEACHMENT AGAINST
                       PRESIDENT DONALD J. TRUMP
                                VOLUME X

=======================================================================

                                HEARING

                               before the

                       COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY
                        HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

                     ONE HUNDRED SIXTEENTH CONGRESS

                             FIRST SESSION

                               ----------                              

                          DECEMBER 11-13, 2019

                               ----------                              

                           Serial No. 116-69

                               ----------                              

         Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary




               [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]





        Available http://judiciary.house.gov or www.govinfo.gov




                              __________
                              
                              
                U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE                   
                              
39-410                  WASHINGTON : 2020                              






                       COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY

                   JERROLD NADLER, New York, Chairman
ZOE LOFGREN, California              DOUG COLLINS, Georgia, Ranking 
SHEILA JACKSON LEE, Texas                Member
STEVE COHEN, Tennessee               F. JAMES SENSENBRENNER, Jr., 
HENRY C. ``HANK'' JOHNSON, Jr.,          Wisconsin
    Georgia                          STEVE CHABOT, Ohio
THEODORE E. DEUTCH, Florida          LOUIE GOHMERT, Texas
KAREN BASS, California               JIM JORDAN, Ohio
CEDRIC L. RICHMOND, Louisiana        KEN BUCK, Colorado
HAKEEM S. JEFFRIES, New York         JOHN RATCLIFFE, Texas
DAVID N. CICILLINE, Rhode Island     MARTHA ROBY, Alabama
ERIC SWALWELL, California            MATT GAETZ, Florida
TED LIEU, California                 MIKE JOHNSON, Louisiana
JAMIE RASKIN, Maryland               ANDY BIGGS, Arizona
PRAMILA JAYAPAL, Washington          TOM McCLINTOCK, California
VAL BUTLER DEMINGS, Florida          DEBBIE LESKO, Arizona
J. LUIS CORREA, California           GUY RESCHENTHALER, Pennsylvania
MARY GAY SCANLON, Pennsylvania,      BEN CLINE, Virginia
  Vice-Chair                         KELLY ARMSTRONG, North Dakota
SYLVIA R. GARCIA, Texas              W. GREGORY STEUBE, Florida
JOE NEGUSE, Colorado
LUCY McBATH, Georgia
GREG STANTON, Arizona
MADELEINE DEAN, Pennsylvania
DEBBIE MUCARSEL-POWELL, Florida
VERONICA ESCOBAR, Texas

        Perry Apelbaum, Majority Staff Director & Chief Counsel
                Brendan Belair, Minority Staff Director


                            C O N T E N T S

                              ----------                              

                                VOLUME X

                          DECEMBER 11-13, 2019

                              A. MINORITY

                                                                   Page
Minority, 2018FY OMB Budget Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................     1
Minority, Advising the President: Rules Governing Access and 
  Accountability of Presidential Advisors Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................    54
Minority, Application of the Anti-Nepotism Statute--OLC Opinion 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................    58
Minority, Article, ``JPMorgan's Investment Bank in Hong Kong 
  Agrees to Pay $72 Million Penalty for Corrupt Hiring Scheme in 
  China,'' November 17, 2016 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................    72
Minority, Article, Antac, ``Repeated Failures by Ukraine General 
  Prosecutors Office,'' January 1, 2018 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................    75
Minority, Article, ``Schiff: There is Now `More Than 
  Circumstantial Evidence' of Trump-Russia Collusion,'' March 22, 
  2017 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...................    84
Minority, Article, Burisma, ``Hunter Biden Joins the Team of 
  Burisma Holdings,'' Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins....    86
Minority, Article, Buzzfeed, ``Biden Son Sign On to Ukrainian Gas 
  Company,'' May 13, 2014 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins    88
Minority, Article, Buzzfeed, ``Biden's Son, Polish Ex-President 
  Quietly Sign On to Ukrainian Gas Company,'' May 13, 2014 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................    92
Minority, Article, CBS, ``A Guide to Trump's Past Comments About 
  NATO,'' April 12, 2017, Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins    96
Minority, Article, CNN, ``CNN Poll: Fewer Support Impeaching 
  Trump,'' December 17, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   101
Minority, Article, Crain's New York Business, ``Top Dem: Trump 
  Impeachment Would Have to be Bipartisan'' Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   104
Minority, Article, Factbase, ``Speech: Donald Trump Delivers A 
  Speech in Grand Rapids, MI,'' December 21, 2015 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Doug Collins.....................................   110
Minority, Article, Financial Times, ``Ukraine's Leaders Campaign 
  Against `Pro-Putin' Trump,'' August 28, 2016 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   161
Minority, article, Gorshenin Institute, ``Fighting Corruption in 
  Ukraine: Ukrainian Style--Round Table,'' March 7, 2011 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   164
Minority, Article, Kyiv Post, ``Court Seizes Property of Ex-
  Minister Zlochevsky in Ukraine,'' March 14, 2012 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Doug Collins.....................................   166
Minority, Article, Kyiv Post, ``People First: The Latest in the 
  Watch on Ukrainian Democracy,'' September 30, 2012 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Doug Collins.....................................   168
Minority, Article, Kyiv Post, ``Prosecutors Put Zlochevsky, 
  Multimillionaire Ex-Ecology Minister, on Wanted List,'' January 
  18, 2015 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...............   177
Minority, Article, Kyiv Post, ``Under Yanukovych, Ukraine Slides 
  Deeper in Ranks of Corrupt Nations,'' December 1, 2011 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   181
Minority, Article, Kyiv Post, ``Update: Publication of Manafort 
  Payments Violated Law, Interfered in US Election, Kyiv Court 
  Rules,'' December 12, 2018 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   185
Minority, Article, National Law Journal, ``Top Profs: Not Enough 
  to Impeach,'' October 5, 1998 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   190
Minority, Article, NBC News, ``Trump Admin Cancels $300M Aid to 
  Pakistan Over Terror Record,'' September 2, 2018 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Doug Collins.....................................   194
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``Donald Trump Used Over 
  $250,000 From Charity for Business Disputes, Report Says,'' 
  September 20, 2016 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.....   197
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``Harry Reid Cites Evidence of 
  Russian Tampering in U.S. Vote, and Seeks FBI Inquiry,'' August 
  29, 2016 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...............   200
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``I am Part of the Resistance 
  Inside the Trump Administration,'' September 5, 2018 Submitted 
  by the Honorable Doug Collins..................................   203
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``Joe Biden Lectures 
  Ukraine,'' December 11, 2015 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   207
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``Joe Biden, His Son and the 
  Case Against a Ukrainian Oligarch,'' December 8, 2015 Submitted 
  by the Honorable Doug Collins..................................   209
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``Ukraine Ousts Victor Shokin, 
  Top Prosecutor, and Political Stability Hangs in the Balance,'' 
  March 29, 2016 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.........   211
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``US Slaps Egypt on Human 
  Rights Record and Ties to North Korea,'' August 22, 2017 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   214
Minority, Article, NPR, ``US Suspends $800 Million in Aid to 
  Pakistan,'' July 10, 2011 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   216
Minority, Article, Op-Ed by the Ambassador of Ukraine to the USA 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   221
Minority, Article, Politico, ``Freshman Rep. Tlaib: Dem Majority 
  Will `Impeach the motherf--er,''' January 4, 2019 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Doug Collins.....................................   225
Minority, Article, Politico, ``Pelosi Calls for Probe of Possible 
  Russian Blackmail of Trump,'' February 5, 2017 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   228
Minority, Article, Politico, ``Sen. Boxer Calls for Probe Into 
  Trump Model Management,'' September 7, 2016 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   230
Minority, Article, Politico, ``Trump in Trouble Over `Second 
  Amendment' Remark,'' August 9, 2016, Submitted by the Honorable 
  Doug Collins Support Document..................................   232
Minority, Article, Politico, ``Ukranian Efforts Sabotage Trump 
  Backfire,'' January 11, 2017 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   236
Minority, Article, Politico, ``Warner: `Enormous Amounts of 
  Evidence' of Possible Russia Collusion,'' March, 3, 2019 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   247
Minority, Article, Radio Free Europe, ``Poroshenko Addresses U.S. 
  Congress, Asks for Military Aid, Special Security Status,'' 
  September 18, 2014 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.....   250
Minority, Article, The Guardian, ``Pentagon Pick Ashton Carter 
  Discusses Iraq and Ukraine at Senate Hearing--As It Happened,'' 
  February 4, 2015 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.......   253
Minority, Article, The Guardian, ``The Money Machine: How a High-
  Profile Corruption Investigation Fell Apart,'' April 12, 2017 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   260
Minority, Article, The Guardian, ``Welcome to Ukraine, the Most 
  Corrupt Nation in Europe,'' February 6, 2015 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   272
Minority, Article, The Guardian, ``Why Shouldn't Hunter Biden 
  Join the Board of a Gas Company in Ukraine?,'' May 14, 2014 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   284
Minority, Article, The Hill, ``Schiff Claims There's Already 
  `Direct Evidence' of Collusion by Trump Campaign,'' March 3, 
  2019 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...................   287
Minority, Article, The Hill, ``Ukraine's Ambassador: Trump's 
  Comments Send Wrong Message to the World,'' August 4, 2016 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   289
Minority, Article, USA Today, ``25 Companies That Pay Their Board 
  of Directors a Shocking Amount,'' December 14, 2018 Submitted 
  by the Honorable Doug Collins..................................   292
Minority, Article, USA Today, ``Adam Schiff: There is `Ample 
  Evidence' of Collusion Between Trump Campaign, Russians,'' 
  February 14, 2018 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins......   298
Minority, Article, USA Today, ``Exclusive: Nancy Pelosi Vows 
  `Different World' for Trump, No More `Rubber Stamp' in New 
  Congress,'' February 14, 2018 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   301
Minority, Article, USA Today, ``Poll: Americans Split 42%-42% on 
  Impeaching Trump,'' July 25, 2017 Submitted by the Honorable 
  Doug Collins...................................................   307
Minority, Article, Vanity Fair, ``Will Trump Be Impeached,'' 
  November 14, 2016 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins......   311
Minority, Article, Wall Street Journal, ``Biden's Son, Kerry 
  Family Friend Join Ukrainian Gas Producer's Board,'' May 13, 
  2014 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...................   319
Minority, Article, Wall Street Journal, ``Trump, in August Call 
  With GOP Senator, Denied Official's Claim on Ukraine Aid,'' 
  October 4, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........   323
Minority, Article, Wall Street Journal, ``U.S. to Ship Modified 
  Radar Systems to Ukraine,'' October 21, 2015 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   327
Minority, Article, Wall Street Journal, ``Ukraine to Get More 
  U.S. Aid, But Not Weapons; Obama Refuses to Budge on Lethal Aid 
  Despite Poroshenko's Passionate Plea in Congress,'' Submitted 
  by the Honorable Doug Collins..................................   331
Minority, Article, Wall Street Journal, ``Ukrainians See Conflict 
  in Biden's Anticorruption Message,'' December 7, 2015 Submitted 
  by the Honorable Doug Collins..................................   346
Minority, Article, Washington Examiner, ``Attorney General Jeff 
  Sessions Names Prosecutor to Probe FBI, DOJ Wrongdoing,'' March 
  29, 2018 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...............   350
Minority, Article, Washington Examiner, ``Biden Son Accepts 
  Position as Private Citizen,'' May 13, 2014 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   352
Minority, Article, Washington Examiner, ``Joe Biden Emerges as 
  Obama's Trusty Sidekick,'' April 25, 2014 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   354
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``John Lewis Says Trump Isn't 
  Legitimate President,'' January 14, 2017 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   357
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``About The Fact Checker,'' 
  January 1, 2017 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........   362
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``Democrats Ask the FBI to 
  Investigate Trump Advisers' Russia Ties,'' August 30, 2016 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   374
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``Hunter Biden's New Job at a 
  Ukrainian Gas Company is a Problem for U.S. Soft Power,'' May 
  14, 2014 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...............   380
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ```I'm Not for Impeachment' 
  Without Bipartisan Support, Pelosi Says, Roiling Fellow 
  Democrats,'' March 11, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   385
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``Pelosi Tamps Down Talk of 
  Impeachment,'' January 6, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   393
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``Rep. Rashida Tlaib 
  Profanely Promised to Impeach Trump. She's Not Sorry,'' 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   397
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``The Campaign to Impeach 
  President Trump Has Begun,'' January 20, 2017 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   400
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``The Trump Administration 
  Has Sprung a Leak. Many of Them, in Fact,'' February 5, 2017 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   406
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``Trump Revealed Highly 
  Classified Information to Russian Foreign Minister and 
  Ambassador,'' May 15, 2017 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   410
Minority, Article, Washington Post, ``U.S. Ends Aid to United 
  Nations Agency Supporting Palestinian Refugees,'' August 31, 
  2018 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...................   417
Minority, Assertion of Executive Privilege Over Communications 
  Regarding EPA's Ozone Air Quality Standards and California's 
  Greenhouse Gas Waiver Request, June 19, 2008 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   424
Minority, Assertion of Executive Privilege Over Documents 
  Generated in Response to Congressional Investigation Into 
  Operation Fast and Furious, June 19, 2012 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   430
Minority, Assertion of Executive Privilege Regarding White House 
  Counsel's Office Documents, May 23, 1996 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   438
Minority, Assertion of Executive Privilege with Respect to 
  Clemency Decision, May 23, 1996 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   441
Minority, Bluestar Novelli Contacts Emails Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   448
Minority, Burisma, ``Attorney John Buretta: In the Case of 
  Burisma and Zlochevskit I Met With Prosecutor General Yury 
  Lutsenko,'' February 1, 2017 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   451
Minority, Chris Heinz Email to State Submitted by the Honorable 
  Doug Collins...................................................   454
Minority, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform v. Eric 
  Holder Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.................   455
Minority, Congressional Requests for Confidential Executive 
  Branch Information Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.....   479
Minority, Fact Sheet, GOP Attacks on IRS Commissioner are Not 
  Impeachment Proceedings Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins   489
Minority, Final Vote Results for Roll Call 21 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   491
Minority, History of Refusals by Executive Branch Officials to 
  Provide Information Demanded by Congress, December 14, 1982 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   495
Minority, Holder Motion for Summary Judgment Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   526
Minority, House Opposition to Motion to Dismiss: Committee on 
  Oversight v. Holder Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins....   529
Minority, Immunity of Counsel to the President from Compelled 
  Congressional Testimony Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins   594
Minority, Immunity of Former Counsel to the President from 
  Compelled Congressional Testimony, July 10, 2007 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Doug Collins.....................................   596
Minority, Immunity of the Assistant to the President and Director 
  of the Office of Political Strategy and Outreach from 
  Congressional Subpoena, July 15, 2014 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   599
Minority, Journal, ``Private Letters and Public Diplomacy: The 
  Adams Network and the Quasi-War, 1797-1798'' Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   613
Minority, Latner, the Kitchen Cabinet and Andrew Jackson's 
  Advisory System Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........   643
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to 
  Michael Duffey (OMB), October 11, 2019 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Andy Biggs...........................................   666
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to Brian 
  McCormack (OMB), November 1, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable 
  Andy Biggs.....................................................   668
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to Brian 
  McCormack (OMB), October 24, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable 
  Andy Biggs.....................................................   670
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to 
  Counsel of Michael Ellis (NSC), November 3, 2019 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Andy Biggs.......................................   672
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to John 
  Eisenberg (NSC), November 1, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable 
  Andy Biggs.....................................................   679
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to John 
  Eisenberg (NSC), October 30, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable 
  Andy Biggs.....................................................   681
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to 
  Michael Ellis, (NSC), October 30, 2019 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Andy Biggs...........................................   683
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to Mick 
  Mulvaney (White House), November 5, 2019 Subpoena Submitted by 
  the Honorable Andy Biggs.......................................   685
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to Robert 
  Blair (White House), October 24, 2019 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Andy Biggs...........................................   690
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to 
  Russell T. Vought (OMB), October 11, 2019 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Andy Biggs...........................................   692
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to Counsel of 
  Robert Blair (White House), November 3, 2019 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Andy Biggs...........................................   694
Minority, Letter From Chairman Eliot Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam 
  Schiff (HPSCI), Chairwoman Carolyn Maloney (HCOR) to Wells 
  Griffith (NSC), October 24, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable 
  Andy Biggs.....................................................   701
Minority, Letter from Matthew Morgan (Office of the Vice 
  President) to Chairman Eliot L. Engel (HFAC), Chairman Adam B. 
  Schiff (HPSCI), and Chairman Elijah E. Cummings (HCOR), October 
  15, 2019 Submitted by the Honorable Andy Biggs.................   703
Minority, Letter from Reno: Assertion of Executive Privilege for 
  Documents Concerning Conduct of Foreign Affairs with Respect to 
  Haiti Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins..................   705
Minority, Letter from Senator Robert Menendez, Senator Richard 
  Durbin, Senator Patrick Leahy to Yuriy Lutsenko (Office of the 
  Prosecutor General of Ukraine), May 4, 2018 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   708
Minority, Memorandum for Fred F. Fielding Counsel to the 
  President Re: Congressional Testimony by Presidential 
  Assistants Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.............   710
Minority, Memorandum to All Heads of Offices, Divisions, Bureaus 
  and Boards of the Department of Justice Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   712
Minority, Money Laundering Investigation Opened--Serious Fraud 
  Office Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.................   719
Minority, Press Release, ``Congressman Nadler Resolution of 
  Inquiry Into Conflicts of Interest, Ethics Violations, and 
  Russia Ties Voted Down in Party-Line Vote,'' February 28, 2017 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   720
Minority, Press Release:, House Foreign Affairs Committee, 
  ``Royce, Engel Press for Swift Action Following Disappearance 
  of Jamal Khashoggi,'' October 12, 2018 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   723
Minority, Ranking Member Schiff (HPSCI) Opening Statement During 
  Hearing on Russian Active Measures Submitted by the Honorable 
  Doug Collins...................................................   726
Minority, Report, ``2014 Director Compensation Report'' Submitted 
  by the Honorable Doug Collins..................................   734
Minority, Report, ``People and Corruption: Citizens' Voices From 
  Around the World'' Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.....   758
Minority, Report, 14th Global Fraud Survey, ``Corporate 
  Misconduct--Individual Consequences,'' Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................   771
Minority, report, Anti-corruption reforms in Ukraine 4th round of 
  monitoring of the Istanbul Anti-Corruption Action Plan, 2017 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................   819
Minority, Report, Atlantic Council, Brookings, The Chicago 
  Council on Global Affairs, ``Preserving Ukraine's Independence, 
  Resisting Russian Aggression: What the United States and NATO 
  Must Do,'' February 2015 Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................   987
Minority, Report, Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental 
  Affairs Report on ``State Secret: How An Avalanche of Media 
  Leaks is Harming National Security'' Submitted by the Honorable 
  Doug Collins...................................................  1004
Minority, Report, CRS, ``The President's Cabinet: Evolution, 
  Alternatives, and Proposals for Change,'' September 12, 2000 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................  1028
Minority, Report, Deloitte, ``2014 Board Practices Report'' 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................  1065
Minority, Report, USAID, ``Corruption Assessment: Ukraine,'' 
  February 10, 2006 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins......  1145
Minority, Retweet by Donald Trump of a tweet by Mark Zaid, 
  January 30, 2017 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.......  1228
Minority, Subpoena from House Permanent Select Committee on 
  Intelligence to Brian McCormack, November 1, 2019 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Andy Biggs.......................................  1229
Minority, Subpoena from House Permanent Select Committee on 
  Intelligence to John Eisenberg (NSC), November 1, 2019 
  Submitted by the Honorable Andy Biggs..........................  1230
Minority, Subpoena from House Permanent Select Committee on 
  Intelligence to Mick Mulvaney (White House), November 4, 2019 
  Submitted by the Honorable Andy Biggs..........................  1231
Minority, Treaty with Ukraine on Mutual Legal Assistance in 
  Criminal Matters Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.......  1235
Minority, Trump Announcement of Candidacy--Democracy in Action 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................  1264
Minority, Tweet by Donald Trump on NATO, July 9, 2018 Submitted 
  by the Honorable Doug Collins..................................  1269
Minority, Tweet by Donald Trump, August 8, 2014 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................  1270
Minority, Tweet by Donald Trump, December 13, 2013 Submitted by 
  the Honorable Doug Collins.....................................  1271
Minority, Tweet by Donald Trump, July 1, 2013 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................  1272
Minority, Tweet by Donald Trump, July 13, 2015 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................  1273
Minority, Tweet by Donald Trump, July 2, 2013 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................  1274
Minority, Tweet by Donald Trump, July 23, 2013 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................  1275
Minority, Tweet by Jerrold Nadler, September 21, 2016 Submitted 
  by the Honorable Doug Collins..................................  1276
Minority, United States v. Nixon Submitted by the Honorable Doug 
  Collins........................................................  1277
Minority, World Bank, Ukraine Economic Update, October 5, 2015 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................  1345
Minority, Article, Deutsche Welle, ``Who are Hunter Biden's 
  Ukrainian Bosses?,'' May 16, 2014 Submitted by the Honorable 
  Doug Collins...................................................  1347
Minority, Article, Fox News, ``Dem Rep Brushes Off Pelosi 
  Pushback, Says He'll Pursue Trump Impeachment,'' March 12, 2019 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................  1350
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``Transcript: Donald Trump 
  Expounds on His Foreign Policy Views,'' March 26, 2016 
  Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins........................  1354
Minority, Article, New York Times, ``Ukraine Court Rules Manafort 
  Disclosure Caused `Meddling' in U.S. Election,'' December 12, 
  2018 Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins...................  1382
Minority, Article, NPR, ``After Trump's NATO Criticism, Countries 
  Spend More On Defense,'' May 18, 2018 Submitted by the 
  Honorable Doug Collins.........................................  1384
Minority, Memorandum for the Honorable John D. Ehrlichman 
  Assistant to the President for Domestic Affairs Re: Power of 
  Congressional Committee to Compel Appearance or Testimony of 
  ``White House Staff.'' Submitted by the Honorable Doug Collins.  1387



               [GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]