[House Hearing, 111 Congress]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]
PUTTING AMERICA BACK TO WORK THROUGH CLEAN WATER INFRASTRUCTURE
INVESTMENT
=======================================================================
(111-129)
HEARING
BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON
WATER RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENT
OF THE
COMMITTEE ON
TRANSPORTATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
ONE HUNDRED ELEVENTH CONGRESS
SECOND SESSION
__________
July 15, 2010
__________
Printed for the use of the
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure
----------
U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE
57-485 PDF WASHINGTON : 2011
For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing
Office Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512-1800;
DC area (202) 512-1800 Fax: (202) 512-2104 Mail: Stop IDCC,
Washington, DC 20402-0001
COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE
JAMES L. OBERSTAR, Minnesota, Chairman
NICK J. RAHALL, II, West Virginia, JOHN L. MICA, Florida
Vice Chair DON YOUNG, Alaska
PETER A. DeFAZIO, Oregon THOMAS E. PETRI, Wisconsin
JERRY F. COSTELLO, Illinois HOWARD COBLE, North Carolina
ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee
Columbia VERNON J. EHLERS, Michigan
JERROLD NADLER, New York FRANK A. LoBIONDO, New Jersey
CORRINE BROWN, Florida JERRY MORAN, Kansas
BOB FILNER, California GARY G. MILLER, California
EDDIE BERNICE JOHNSON, Texas HENRY E. BROWN, Jr., South
GENE TAYLOR, Mississippi Carolina
ELIJAH E. CUMMINGS, Maryland TIMOTHY V. JOHNSON, Illinois
LEONARD L. BOSWELL, Iowa TODD RUSSELL PLATTS, Pennsylvania
TIM HOLDEN, Pennsylvania SAM GRAVES, Missouri
BRIAN BAIRD, Washington BILL SHUSTER, Pennsylvania
RICK LARSEN, Washington JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas
MICHAEL E. CAPUANO, Massachusetts SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO, West
TIMOTHY H. BISHOP, New York Virginia
MICHAEL H. MICHAUD, Maine JIM GERLACH, Pennsylvania
RUSS CARNAHAN, Missouri MARIO DIAZ-BALART, Florida
GRACE F. NAPOLITANO, California CHARLES W. DENT, Pennsylvania
DANIEL LIPINSKI, Illinois CONNIE MACK, Florida
MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii LYNN A WESTMORELAND, Georgia
JASON ALTMIRE, Pennsylvania JEAN SCHMIDT, Ohio
TIMOTHY J. WALZ, Minnesota CANDICE S. MILLER, Michigan
HEATH SHULER, North Carolina MARY FALLIN, Oklahoma
MICHAEL A. ARCURI, New York VERN BUCHANAN, Florida
HARRY E. MITCHELL, Arizona BRETT GUTHRIE, Kentucky
CHRISTOPHER P. CARNEY, Pennsylvania ANH ``JOSEPH'' CAO, Louisiana
JOHN J. HALL, New York AARON SCHOCK, Illinois
STEVE KAGEN, Wisconsin PETE OLSON, Texas
STEVE COHEN, Tennessee TOM GRAVES, Georgia
LAURA A. RICHARDSON, California
ALBIO SIRES, New Jersey
DONNA F. EDWARDS, Maryland
SOLOMON P. ORTIZ, Texas
PHIL HARE, Illinois
JOHN A. BOCCIERI, Ohio
MARK H. SCHAUER, Michigan
BETSY MARKEY, Colorado
MICHAEL E. McMAHON, New York
THOMAS S. P. PERRIELLO, Virginia
DINA TITUS, Nevada
HARRY TEAGUE, New Mexico
JOHN GARAMENDI, California
HANK JOHNSON, Georgia
(ii)
Subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment
EDDIE BERNICE JOHNSON, Texas, Chairwoman
THOMAS S. P. PERRIELLO, Virginia JOHN BOOZMAN, Arkansas
JERRY F. COSTELLO, Illinois DON YOUNG, Alaska
GENE TAYLOR, Mississippi JOHN J. DUNCAN, Jr., Tennessee
BRIAN BAIRD, Washington VERNON J. EHLERS, Michigan
TIMOTHY H. BISHOP, New York FRANK A. LoBIONDO, New Jersey
RUSS CARNAHAN, Missouri GARY G. MILLER, California
STEVE KAGEN, Wisconsin HENRY E. BROWN, Jr., South
DONNA F. EDWARDS, Maryland Vice Carolina
Chair TODD RUSSELL PLATTS, Pennsylvania
SOLOMON P. ORTIZ, Texas BILL SHUSTER, Pennsylvania
PHIL HARE, Illinois MARIO DIAZ-BALART, Florida
DINA TITUS, Nevada CONNIE MACK, Florida
HARRY TEAGUE, New Mexico LYNN A WESTMORELAND, Georgia
ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON, District of CANDICE S. MILLER, Michigan
Columbia ANH ``JOSEPH'' CAO, Louisiana
MICHAEL E. CAPUANO, Massachusetts PETE OLSON, Texas
GRACE F. NAPOLITANO, California VACANCY
MAZIE K. HIRONO, Hawaii
HARRY E. MITCHELL, Arizaon
JOHN J. HALL, New York
BOB FILNER, California
CORRINE BROWN, Florida
JOHN GARAMENDI, California
HANK JOHNSON, Georgia
JAMES L. OBERSTAR, Minnesota
(Ex Officio)
(iii)
CONTENTS
Page
Summary of Subject Matter........................................ vi
TESTIMONY
Hawkins, George S., General Manager, District of Columbia Water
and Sewer Authority............................................ 4
Holloway, Caswell F., Commissioner, New York City Department of
Environmental Protection....................................... 4
Marcason, Hon. Jan, City Council Member, City of Kansas City,
Missouri, on behalf of the National League of Cities........... 4
Soth, Jeffrey, Assistant Director, Department of Legislative and
Political Affairs, International Union of Operating Engineers,
on behalf of the National Construction Alliance II............. 4
Vander Molen, Dennis, President, Vermeer Midsouth, Inc., on
behalf of the Associated Equipment Distributors................ 4
PREPARED STATEMENTS SUBMITTED BY MEMBERS OF CONGRESS
Johnson, Hon. Hank, of Georgia................................... 30
Mitchell, Hon. Harry E., of Arizona.............................. 34
PREPARED STATEMENTS SUBMITTED BY WITNESSES
Hawkins, George S................................................ 35
Holloway, Caswell F.............................................. 39
Marcason, Hon. Jan............................................... 46
Soth, Jeffrey.................................................... 51
Vander Molen, Dennis............................................. 55
SUBMISSION FOR THE RECORD
Holloway, Caswell F., Commissioner, New York City Department of
Environmental Protection, response to request for information
from the Subcommittee.......................................... 44
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
PUTTING AMERICA BACK TO WORK THROUGH CLEAN WATER INFRASTRUCTURE
INVESTMENT
----------
Thursday, July 15, 2010
House of Representatives,
Subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment,
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure,
Washington, DC.
The subcommittee met, pursuant to call, at 2:40 p.m., in
room 2167, Rayburn House Office Building, Hon. Eddie Bernice
Johnson [Chairman of the Cubcommittee] presiding.
Ms. Johnson. The Committee will come to order and let me
first apologize for being late, it is because of votes. And I'm
aware that Mr. Holloway has to leave not later than 3:30, and
we will try to make sure you get your testimony in before.
Today's hearing, of course, will focus on the success of
clean water infrastructure funding and how that investment has
helped to create and sustain jobs during the current economic
downturn.
Since Congress passed the Recovery Act, this committee has
been tracking its progress, particularly in terms of
investments of Recovery Act dollars and clean water
infrastructure. Successful implementation of this legislation
has been essential to our collective efforts to turn our
economy around and create well-paying jobs here in America. I
am happy to report that of the $4 billion provided by the
Recovery Act for the Clean Water State Revolving Fund programs.
The Environmental Protection Agency has awarded 100 percent
of these funds and capitalization grants to States. Further,
according to the EPA, some 5,177 jobs were created with these
monies. That really is good news, sometimes we can't tell it.
In my home State of Texas, as of May 31st, 2010, all of our
funds have been committed and are under contract, and all of
the projects are underway. Approximately, $172 million has been
allocated for 20 projects. And according to figures collected
by this committee, this funding has created a sustained 286
jobs in May of this year alone. Those are jobs that would have
been lost or never created. And these are 20 projects that
never would have seen the light of day.
I would like to see this the continued success through the
Clean Water State Revolving Fund. In order for that to happen,
Congress needs to reauthorize the program to allow for more
adequate appropriations to EPA, to make capitalization grants
to States for clean water infrastructure. This House has
already passed the Water Quality Financing Act of 2009 which
would do just that.
Also, the Energy and Commerce Committee has done their part
by moving their legislation to reauthorize the drinking water
state revolving fund out of their committee. We hope that the
House will soon have the opportunity to vote on it. The Senate
has also moved their legislation to reauthorize both the Clean
Water State Revolving Fund and the Drinking Water State
Revolving Fund out of the environmental and public works
committee.
It is my sincere wish that both Chambers will meet in
conference so that we can finally get this vital legislation
signed into law. We need to do this so that these important
programs can continue to fund this critical infrastructure and
provide more good jobs for working Americans. I look forward to
hearing from all of our witnesses today on the importance of
continuing investment in clean water infrastructure.
The chair now recognizes our ranking member, Mr. Boozman.
Mr. Boozman. Thank you, Madam Chair for holding this
important hearing. The Congressional Budget Office EPA and the
Water Infrastructure Network have estimated that it could take
between 300 and $400 billion to address our Nation's clean
water infrastructure needs over the next 20 years to keep our
drinking water and waterways clean and safe. This is twice the
current level investment by all levels of government. These
needs are being well documented in our subcommittee prior
hearings. It was 1 year ago today that we held a similar
hearing on the benefits of wastewater infrastructure. Our
Nation's quality of life and economic well-being rely on clean
water. Our Nation has invested over 250 billion on wastewater
infrastructure to provide adequate wastewater treatment so that
we can keep our waters clean.
This investment has provided significant, environmental and
public health benefits and contributes over $300 billion of
economic benefits to the Nation each year. The challenge to
continue providing clean water remains as our existing national
wastewater infrastructure is aging and deteriorating and in
need of repair, replacement and upgrading.
In March 2009, the House of Representatives passed
legislation that would authorize increased funding for
wastewater infrastructure through a reauthorization of the
Clean Water State Revolving Loan Fund administered by EPA. This
bill is designed to help communities meet their growing demand
for wastewater infrastructure needs and improve water quality.
While I remained genuinely concerned regarding the adverse
effects that the Davis-Bacon providing wage requirements will
have on jobs and clean water. I supported the legislation on
balance. If we do not start investing in our wastewater
infrastructure now, it is going to cost our Nation billions
more in the future. And when we do invest Federal funds in
infrastructure, we need to do it in ways that will give us the
best clean water value for the dollar.
For many families in America, the recession is far from
over as unemployment continues to increase. We can debate the
merits and demerits of the stimulus package enacted in 2009,
but I think we have a bipartisan agreement here on the
committee that not enough money has been devoted to job
creating infrastructure projects. Today's hearing will
highlight the positive ripple effects in the economy provided
by investments in clean water infrastructure projects.
The debate has moved beyond the calculation of job creation
statistics. Debating job creation and its associated statistics
are irrelevant. We all know that a robust economy produces
jobs. Yet, according to the Associated General Contractors,
22,000 jobs were lost in the construction trades market during
the month of June and unemployment construction trades remains
at 21 percent. These are not positive trends and it is clear
that the stimulus bill did little to create jobs.
Too many stimulus dollars were allocated to other types of
frivolous spending while too few dollars were devoted to
infrastructure projects that not only produce jobs, but also
lasting public benefits.
The administration claimed the stimulus package would help
the unemployment from going above 8 percent. However the Nation
has had an unemployment rate of close to 10 percent for the
last year. Now some of the administration are saying that the
stimulus package was necessary to keep unemployment from below
12 percent. Given the fact that the transportation projects and
other infrastructure projects like flood damage reduction and
wastewater treatment projects provide economic benefits to the
Nation, the administration and the Congress need to place a
higher priority on the work of the Army Corps of Engineers and
EPA's Clean Water State Revolving Loan benefit loan fund and
Brownsville program.
Without efficient transportation systems the Nation's
competitives will suffer. Without a strong economy, the
Nation's environment will suffer, without--it is evident that
we are now paying a heavier price for a stimulus bill that
shortchanged the infrastructure investment.
I would like to offer special welcome to one of our
witnesses, Dennis Vander Molen, whose company has a number of
important facilities in my congressional district in Arkansas.
I thank you, Madam Chair, for holding this important hearing
again, and I look forward to hearing from our witnesses.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much. I now will go directly to
the panel. Our first witness this afternoon is Councilwoman Jan
Marcason, she is a city council member for the City of Kansas
City, Missouri. However, today she is testifying on behalf of
the National League of Cities.
Next is Mr. Caswell Holloway. Mr. Holloway is Commissioner
of the New York City State Department of Environmental
Protection. I know you have to leave. In your testimony that
you submitted, you talked about the timing of which this had to
come and it could have been better used. Would you comment on
that when you are testifying?
And our third witness is Mr. George Hawkins. He is the
general manager of the District of Columbia water and sewer
authority.
Our fourth witness is Mr. Dennis Vander Molen. He is
testifying on behalf of the Associated Equipment Distributors
today.
And lastly, Mr. Jeffrey Soth, who will testify on behalf of
the National Construction Alliance II. Your full statements
will be placed in the record so we ask you to limit your
testimony to 5 minutes.
STATEMENTS OF HON. JAN MARCASON, CITY COUNCIL MEMBER, CITY OF
KANSAS CITY, MISSOURI, ON BEHALF OF THE NATIONAL LEAGUE OF
CITIES; CASWELL F. HOLLOWAY, COMMISSIONER, NEW YORK CITY
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; GEORGE S. HAWKINS,
GENERAL MANAGER, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA WATER AND SEWER
AUTHORITY; DENNIS VANDER MOLEN, PRESIDENT, VERMEER MIDSOUTH,
INC., ON BEHALF OF THE ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT DISTRIBUTORS; AND
JEFFREY SOTH, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF LEGISLATIVE AND
POLITICAL AFFAIRS, INTERNATIONAL UNION OF OPERATING ENGINEERS,
ON BEHALF OF THE NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION ALLIANCE II
Ms. Johnson. We know we are late, and I know some of you
are on a tight schedule now so thank you and I now recognize
Ms. Marcason.
Ms. Marcason. Good afternoon, Madam Chairman and Ranking
Member Boozman and members of the Committee. I am Jan Marcason,
a city councilwoman from Kansas City, Missouri. I am here on
behalf of the National League of Cities, the oldest and largest
organization representing cities and towns across America. I
appreciate the opportunity to share our perspective on the
important role of water infrastructure investment in creating
jobs, protecting the environment and improving the quality of
life in our home towns, and specifically, in my hometown of
Kansas City, Missouri.
Thank you, Madam Chairwoman, for your resent visit to
Kansas City to see firsthand the green infrastructure solutions
that our city is incorporating in its overflow control plan. We
were also pleased to host Chairman Oberstar who came to Kansas
City to learn more about our infrastructure plan. As you
witnessed, Kansas City is implementing an innovative and
ambitious plan to improve the city's water quality by
overhauling our sewer system and implementing green
infrastructure solutions such as rain gardens and bioretention
facilities to intercept, store and infiltrate storm water
runoff, thereby significantly reducing discharges of untreated
sewage that overflows into our lakes, streams and rivers.
Kansas City's plan was developed with the significant input
of our community stakeholders. We undertook a large scale
community involvement project to gather information from
residents about the kinds of improvements that they would like
to see in their neighborhood. The Wet Weather Community Panel
was comprised of 20 citizens and subject matter experts that
met every month for 5 years. I served as the city council
liaison to that panel. It became clear that the community
wanted more than just new pipes and treatment facilities. They
wanted multiple benefits often called the triple bottom line.
The multiple benefits include environmental, social and
financial benefits from our infrastructure improvements.
Residents and business owners both want clean water, but they
also want attractive sidewalks to encourage walking and way to
reduce speeding on their neighborhood streets. They want
infrastructure improvements to encourage business development
in underserved neighborhoods in particular. And they want a
system that is affordable for residents and business customers.
The plan that Kansas City developed is a cost-effective
approach to addressing our aging infrastructure. Green
solutions actually reduced the cost of implementing our plan.
In the target green pilot project area of 100 acres, the city
will save an estimated $10 million by implementing green
solutions instead of the traditional retention tanks that were
first proposed to address storm water runoff. The investment
our city is making will have a tremendous impact on our local
economy. Our plan is a 25-year, $2.5 billion program, the
largest economic development project in our city's history. It
is projected that it will create nearly 20,000 good paying jobs
over the life of the project, some in the areas of the emerging
technology, and others in design, engineering and construction.
The 28 communities served by Kansas City Water Services
Department will all be direct beneficiaries of these
improvements and will also benefit from the economic
development opportunities provided by the system.
Local engineering companies, nonprofit job training
organizations, and educational institutions are all working
together to prepare the workforce for the multitude of jobs
that implementing our plan will require. To the extent that our
water infrastructure is properly maintained and can adequately
meet the needs of our communities, it will help ensure the
long-term vitality of our cities.
As Kansas City is demonstrating investment in water
infrastructure and other infrastructure systems will create
good paying jobs and enable business development that is the
essential component to a thriving local economy. However,
improving the infrastructure system to protect the public
health and promote our local economies requires a substantial
investment.
The latest U.S. EPA clean water sheds needs survey of
January 2008 documents a nearly $300 billion need for
wastewater and storm water management over the next 20 years.
My own State of Missouri documented needs totaling 6 per $5
billion.
Federal assistance in meeting these needs has declined by
75 percent over the last 20 years, while municipal costs for
operation and maintenance of our aging systems has dramatically
increased. Given the level of need governments at all levels
must do more to protect and modernize our Nation's water
infrastructure systems. In terms of the Federal Government,
this means reauthorizing and fully funding the Clean Water
State Revolving Loan Fund program by fully funding this program
and its companion, the Drinking Water SRF, and including
requirements that States make a portion of such funds available
as grants to local governments.
The Federal Government can help ensure that communities
have the resources needed to protect and maintain the
wastewater and drinking water treatment facilities that serve
our residents and businesses. To help fund implementation of
our plan, Kansas City is requesting Clean Water SRF funds loans
and grants from the State of Missouri. However, the city is
relying on user fees and rate increases to residents to pay for
our overflow control plan. So far, these fees and rate
increases have not been insignificant. Since 2008 the average
residential water utility bill has increased 44 percent. In
order to keep future fees and rates affordable to our citizens
and our businesses, the availability of funds through the SRF
program is essential.
The National League of Cities wants to thank the committee
for its leadership in approving legislation and reauthorizing
the Clean Water SRF program. NLC supported the Water Quality
Investment Act of 2009 that passed the House last year, and
continues to urge the Senate to bring similar legislation to
the floor for consideration. I want to thank you for the
opportunity to speak to you on behalf of America's cities and
towns. On behalf of the National League of Cities, I have
submitted written testimony for your consideration and I look
forward to your questions later on. Thank you.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much. Mr. Holloway.
Mr. Holloway. Thank you, good afternoon, Madam Chair. I am
Cas Holloway, Commissioner of the New York City Department of
Environmental Protection, or as we are known in New York City,
DEP. On behalf of Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, thank you for the
opportunity to testify about the critical water on wastewater
infrastructure challenges that we face serving 9 million New
Yorkers, 8 million in the city and 1 million more upstate in
New York.
Over the past 7 years we have invested $19 billion in our
water and wastewater infrastructure and our budgeted amount for
the next 4 years is $6 billion. We employ 6,000 men and women
who provide water and sewer services to the residents of New
York City as well as commuters and out-of-towners. We manage
the city's water supply providing more than a billion gallons
of water a day from a watershed that extends 125 miles from New
York City.
We have 7,000 miles of aqueducts, tunnels and water mains
that bring water to homes and 7,400 miles of sewer lines that
take approximately 1.3 billion gallons of wastewater to one of
our 14 in-city treatment plants every day. That infrastructure
could crisscross the country twice.
DEP also has one of the largest construction budgets in the
region. We currently have $11 billion of work under
construction, and 3 billion more in planning or design. And as
I noted, our capital budget for the next 4 years is
approximately $6 billion, which we estimate will generate
approximately 9,200 construction jobs. We receive 219 million
in ARRA funding, and that was critical. We estimated it will
create as many as 1,400 jobs to do vital work in the wastewater
and water area that I will discuss in a minute or two.
A majority of DEP's capital spending over the past 8 years
has been dedicated to meeting unfunded Federal and State
regulatory mandates that require the simultaneous completion of
massive capital projects on tight construction schedules. Some
of our largest current projects went to bid at the height of
the construction market in 2006 and 2007. Not because of a
pressing public health need, but because of Federal and State
mandates that didn't take account of New York City's particular
needs.
Many of our mandates could have been stretched or modified
without any appreciable impact on public health of the
environment. Which would have enabled us to build less at the
same time and focus more resources on maintaining our current
infrastructure in a state of good repair.
It is time for the national clean water strategy to evolve
from a one-size-fits-all mandate and enforcement approach to a
strategy that recognizes and funds the individual needs of
water and wastewater utilities based on clearly demonstrated
public health need and water quality benefits. And I think the
funding that we have seen in the ARRA Act and its support for
things like green infrastructure are really a trend in the
right direction.
Using our own history as an example, about 69 percent of
the $19 billion that we spent in the last 7 years have been
used to fund construction for Federal and State mandates and
they have contributed to a 24 percent increase in water rates
over that same period.
Many of the increases that I just mentioned don't always go
where the cities most needs it. For example, there are still
thousands of New Yorkers who lack sanitary sewer and tens of
thousands of New Yorkers who lack storm sewers, completing the
full build out of that system is an important priority for New
York. But we have had to defer many projects until legally
mandated work is complete. For example, as a result of a
mandate, we recently completed construction on a $422 million
tank to deal with combined sewer overflow that will have a
valuable but extremely limited impact on one tributary in New
York Harbor.
What we are looking to do is move forward with a broader
green infrastructure approach and Council Member Marcason
mentioned that. And we think that the fact that the 2009 ARRA
allowed up to 20 percent of the $4 billion that was put in the
State revolving funds to be used for green infrastructure is a
great step in the right direction.
The ultimate success, though, is going to depend on the
willingness of our regulators at the State and Federal level,
that is, the EPA and State DEC, to embrace these new methods in
a collaborative and flexible approach rather than a one-size-
fits-all approach.
Now, the grand provisions of ARRA were an extremely welcome
return to the pattern of Federal environmental funding that
drastically declined at the end of the 1980's and essentially
ended at the end of the 1990's. We received $219 million, as I
noted, and we are moving forward with nine separate projects
that are going to reduce our energy emissions, make our plants
more efficient, and provide update critical infrastructure that
really wouldn't have moved forward at all, but for this
critical funding.
Overall, ARRA has allowed DEP to move on projects that
would have been shelved or delayed. However, using the State
Revolving Fund Loan program did create certain difficulties as
it has restrictions and administrative burdens that don't allow
us to use money as flexibly as we would like to.
If Congress considered a second ARRA program, we recommend
making it a 100 percent grant program and perhaps add an
element that provides for direct grants to localities like New
York City, with the demonstrating capacity to put dollars to
work quickly and create jobs and provide the public benefit,
Madam Chair, that you and Mr. Boozman talked about at the
beginning of the hearing.
We also recommend an extension of the Build America Bonds
program which is providing our water and sewer system with more
cost effective financing for capital projects.
Before closing, I just want to say a couple quick word
about the Water Quality Investment Act of 2009, which embodies
a comprehensive approach to clean water initiatives and
infrastructure financing. The reauthorization of 13.8 billion
over 5 years recognizes the range of needs, large and small,
for water and wastewater systems. We support the 30 percent SRF
funds to be used for forgiveness of principle and negative
interest loans. We support authorizing 2.5 billion over 5 years
for grants for combined sewer overflows. And we support the
elements for water conservation, which were important parts of
the Mayor's PlaNYC program. Our blueprint for a sustainable
city that has become a national model.
We are pleased to see that the legislation seeks more
research about pharmaceuticals while the presence of the
potential pharmaceutical and the water supply has raised a lot
of attention lately. It is critically important that any new
regulation in this area be based on demonstrated public health
need and not simply the availability of monitoring or treatment
technology.
In conclusion, I believe that ARRA has been a success when
it comes to projects undertaken by DEP. Those funds allowed us
to create jobs and productive assets that serve the public for
years to come. However, much remains to be done to ensure that
Federal standards, if they are to be imposed, actually achieve
water quality and public health benefits and come with the
funding necessary to carry them out. Otherwise, unfunded
mandates will continue to substitute Federal and State
judgement about system needs for the judgment of cities like
New York with expertise and experience to make smart
investments that have a large public health return with lowest
cost. Thank you very much for the opportunity to testify and I
look forward to your questions.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much.
Mr. Hawkins.
Mr. Hawkins. Good afternoon. Good afternoon Chairwoman
Johnson, Ranking Member Boozman, members of the Subcommittee of
Water Resources and the Environment. My name is George Hawkins,
the general manager of the DC Water, the utility that provides
water to every building in the District of Columbia, including
this one. One of my goals some day is actually to have D.C.'s
finest up here as the drinking water and can talk to you about
that in the days ahead.
I am delighted to be here to testify with one fundamental
message: It is my thesis that a dollar spent on water and
wastewater infrastructure is the single best Federal dollar
that can be invested in this country, and I would like to do a
very short summary to suggest why.
First is to the benefits of using DC Water as the example.
Number 1, this is a dollar that achieves vital environmental
improvements. In the Chesapeake Bay, we know how much attention
has been applied to the Chesapeake Bay. There is only one place
that achieve the 2010 goals, clean-up goals for the Chesapeake
Bay nitrogen removal, that was the DC Water's Blue Plains
Treatment plant just in the southern part of the city. That was
a billion dollar investment over the last 10 years made by the
Federal Government, made by Washington, D.C., and with
jurisdictions in Maryland and Virginia, able to achieve the
goals for 2010.
We will also achieve with a $900 million expenditure the
next level of goals for the Chesapeake scheduled for 2015. So
there is direct and immediate environmental benefits to water
features and natural resources that are absolutely vital to us
as a society.
Second is the service which provide. There is no job, there
is no business, there is no building, there is no home that can
get a certificate of occupancy without adequate connection for
water and sewer service. That is one of the only obligations
you must have, and without with you cannot get in a building. I
have been there because I used to run the permitting agency. In
that respect, I believe water and wastewater can take some
credit to every job in Washington, D.C. Because they all rely
fundamentally on the service we offer. But the second feature
of that is I regularly attend when we have disruptions to
service, I will discuss in the minute the age of the system in
our fair national capital city, but when this service is not
available, there is an immediate negative consequence to every
homeowner, to every business and to every neighborhood when you
are not able to provide water and wastewater services. The
restaurants close, the hotels close, the businesses close,
because they can't stay open without our service. There is a
fundamental service.
Third is obviously the jobs, DC Water has 1,200 members of
what I call team blue. We have five unions and one of the
largest blue collar workforces in Washington. We have direct
connection to training programs in the high schools in the city
as well as the University of District of Columbia. These are
not only jobs, but many of these jobs are entry-level positions
that are accessible to people who are not always part of the
rest of the job market. We offer positions and opportunities
that are unique in this city and are growing. Over the next 10
years, we anticipate we will be hiring more through
contractors, 7 to 900 more jobs in order to continue improve
infrastructure the city. So a dollar spent on infrastructure
provides environmental benefit, provides services and provides
jobs.
What is the need? I will use our fair city as the example.
The average age of the water pipes that serve this building and
every other building in this city is 77 years. Ten percent of
the pipes in the city were put in before 1900, 3 percent before
the Civil War. It is no wonder that they break with regularity.
We have, as a country, not been investing the funds needed to
update these absolutely critical infrastructure. And who is
surprised when the line straight up Pennsylvania Avenue 21st
just 2 weeks ago broke when it was put in the ground in 1857,
that is an infrastructure need that is critical, it is daily
and in every major city in the United States.
We are doing our part. Of course, we seek support from the
Federal Government. I just finished 20 outreach meetings all
over the city including one last night. We have proposed a 12-
1/2 percent rate increase for our residents in D.C. to provide
this service; that is no small task in the middle of a
recession, but that is what we feel is necessary in order to
improve the infrastructure that is so vital to all of us.
And last, your role. There is no question in our mind that
funds that come to us with the clean revolving fund as well as
the drinking water revolving fund as supplemented by ARRA funds
had been integral to our ability to provide this service, to
drive additional jobs and do additional projects and to lessen
the burdens on our rate payers. It is city agencies, in many
respects, that are doing a lot of these expenditures. And as
much as other lobbies and otherwise legitimately raise concerns
about costs to their members. Fair enough. But remember who has
been bearing the burden in this city and so many others, it is
some of our lowest income people who have suffered these rate
increases, including here in Washington, DC.
I stood in front of an audience last night presenting 12-1/
2 percent increase, this was after a 9 percent increase last
year and a projected 9 percent increase next year. So we are
stepping up at the local level with the people who serve us,
and we are so grateful of the support that has been supported
in the past from the Federal Government. But as I have
suggested, the dozens, we have 97 projects ultimately that are
planned, that are connected to stimulus funds, not as many as
we would have liked have been initiated, they are all under
contract. The permitting process, I am now actually the
regulated party, I was the regulator for years. We have been
waiting to be able to get some of our permits, but there will
be hundreds of jobs in this city connected to people who need
them, driven by Federal funding that will then support the city
that we so much love. So I am grateful for the opportunity, I
will be delighted to answer questions. Glad to be here today,
thank you.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much.
Mr. Vander Molen.
Mr. Vander Molen. Thank you, and good afternoon, Chairman
Johnson and Ranking Member Boozman and other distinguished
members of this subcommittee. It is my pleasure to appear
before you today both as a small business owner who is directly
affected by the water infrastructure investment, and also in my
capacity as the 2010 AED chairman. AED is an international
trade association that represents independent authorized
distributors of construction, mining, forestry and agricultural
equipment. And Vermeer Midsouth is a family-owned company which
headquarters in Memphis, Tennessee, and we rent, and sell, and
support Vermeer construction equipment throughout the four
States of Mississippi, Arkansas, north Louisiana and west
Tennessee. And of course, we have a couple of locations in
Congressman Boozman's areas of Russellville and Springdale.
I appreciate the opportunity to come before this
subcommittee to discuss how equipment distributors and other
small companies are affected by the State Revolving Fund
programs and water infrastructure investment in general. I
would like to really take my time to highlight three key
issues.
First, the construction equipment industry has been
affected as much as any other in this economic downturn. For
us, the recession has been nothing short of a depression. A
study conducted last year by Global Insight for AED and the
Associated Equipment Manufacturers painted a very grim picture.
From 2007 to 2009, spending on construction machinery fell 50
percent. Over the last 3 years, equipment manufacturers
distributors and maintenance providers shed 257,000 jobs,
representing a stunning 37 percent of our workforce. The
effects of our industry downturn have been felt well beyond the
dealer yards and manufacturing plants. Global Insight also
estimated that the equipment industry depression has cost an
additional 274,000 jobs in a broader economy. In total, the
downturn in the equipment industry has cost 550,000 jobs
nationwide since 2006.
My second point is that the water infrastructure investment
including a multiyear reauthorization of both the drinking
water and the Clean Water State Revolving Fund programs is one
of the keys to the recovery in the equipment industry. An
estimated $0.12 of every dollar invested in water
infrastructure construction is used by contractors to buy and
rent and service equipment. The Water Quality Investment Act,
which would authorize more than 14 billion over 5 years for the
Clean Water SRF would create an estimated 1.68 billion in
market opportunity for our members over the life of that bill.
I would commend this subcommittee for its leadership on
this important legislation which will put people back to work
in well paying, manufacturing and sales and product support
jobs in communities throughout the country.
My third and final point is that increased water
infrastructure investment at the Federal level will have
benefits well beyond the equipment industry. Last summer, the
Clean Water Council of which AED is a leading member announced
the results of a highly anticipated study regarding the
economic impact of water infrastructure investment.
Specifically, the report showed that a $1 billion investment in
water infrastructure generates 2.87 and 3.46 billion in
economic activity, and creates more than 26,000 new jobs. About
half of those jobs are in industries outside of water and
wastewater construction, further illustrating the broad reach
of the initial investment. Each $1 billion invested also
generates approximately 82.4 million in State and local tax
revenue.
In addition to the positive economic impact, the increased
water infrastructure investment will have significant
environmental and public health benefits. EPA recently released
a new clean water sheds needs survey which estimated that as of
January 1, 2008, national capital investment needs for
wastewater pollution control are $298 billion. Those needs are
in addition to the 334 billion investment EPA estimates to
repair and rebuild our Nation's water infrastructure.
To sum it up, our Nation faces an unparalleled
infrastructure crisis. Immediate and aggressive congressional
action is necessary to ensure that our water infrastructure
systems do not deteriorate further, and that the Federal
Government has the resources it needs to address the crisis.
The problem will be only more expensive to solve as the time
goes on. It is for the foregoing reasons that AED urges
Congress to rapidly enact long-term sewer and drinking water
SRF reauthorization bills to dramatically increase investment
and to create sustainable revenue strains and funding
mechanisms.
We look forward to working with the members of this
subcommittee and with your House and Senate colleagues in a
bipartisan manner to achieve these goals. Thank you for the
time to share with you, and I would be glad to answer any
questions.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much.
Mr. Soth.
Mr. Soth. Thank you, Chairwoman Johnson, Ranking Member
Boozman and distinguished members of the Water Resources and
Environment Subcommittee. My name is Jeffrey Soth. While I am
the assistant director of the legislative and political
department for the International Union of Operating Engineers,
I am testifying today on behalf of the National Construction
Alliance II, a partnership between two of the Nation's leading
construction unions, my union, the Operating Engineers, and the
United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners.
The two unions of the Alliance represent nearly 1 million
workers, many of the same workers who built the Nation's clean
water infrastructure. We sincerely appreciate the opportunity
to join you today and testify.
Chairwoman Johnson, NCA II sincerely values the commitment
made by Congress and the administration in the Recovery Act to
reenergize the national economy through infrastructure
investments, particularly clean water investments. Those
outlays, quite literally, pulled the construction industry back
from the precipice. The sector, however, is still on the ledge.
But one thing is perfectly clear, more can and should be done
by Congress to put America back to work through clean water
infrastructure investment. Construction spending was down over
13 percent in the first 4 months of 2010 as compared to 2009.
And as you know, 2009 was one of the worst years on record for
the industry.
Last year the unemployment rate peaked at over 21 percent.
This year, the employment rate in construction reached over 27
percent. The unemployment rate today is still over 20 percent.
Since its peak in 2006, construction employment has fallen by
over 2.1 million jobs, or 28 percent of the construction
workforce in the industry.
Unfortunately, the same holds true for employment in the
water and sewer systems sub sector of construction. I refer you
to the chart on the last page of my testimony where you can see
the precipitous drop in employment in the last 2 years from
2007 to 2009. Employment in the subsector dropped by over 21
percent between those years.
Obviously there are thousands of carpenters and operating
engineers' families behind those numbers. The NCA II firmly
believes that the best way to restart the ailing construction
economy is to get Americans back to work by building the
Nation's wastewater systems. These investments will employ
thousands of construction workers, clean up the Nation's
environment, improve the public health of Americans, and
accommodate the country's growing population. The Nation simply
cannot afford to keep losing construction jobs. The future of
the industry is quite literally at stake.
In partnership with our construction contractors, the
carpenters and operating engineers maintain apprenticeship and
training programs to train the next generation of skilled craft
workers. The apprenticeship model delivers careers, not merely
jobs for hard working members of the NCA II and other
construction crafts. But in order to bring an individual
apprentice through their program, which for carpenters and
operating engineers, typically consists of 3 or 4 years of on-
the-job training and classroom instruction there must be
continuity of work. The apprenticeship model indeed depends on
employment and on-the-job training. Widespread unemployment
jeopardizes the future of the industry making it impossible to
deliver their required on-the-job training hours for a worker
to develop his or her skills. Further congressional action is
necessary to reverse this trend.
Madam Chairwoman, despite all the committee's hard work,
the Nation's water infrastructure needs call out for further
investment. There are four steps that NCA II recommends that
Congress take to restore employment in water and sewer
construction. First, please continue to exercise your
aggressive informal oversight of States and local governments,
encouraging them to undertake the construction spending that
Congress devoted to them in the Recovery Act. Members of the
NCA II and other construction workers in Louisiana, for
example, where one-third of clean water projects are not yet
underway, need you to bring pressure to bear on the State
government that it has failed to put your investments to work.
Second, make another investment in clean and safe drinking
water in the annual appropriations process. Last year's
appropriation process more than doubled the fiscal year 2009
appropriation, clean water infrastructure and construction
workers urgently need more, and the sooner the better.
Third, pass the Clean Water Act State Revolving Fund
Reauthorization. As the committee is painfully aware, it has
been over 20 years since the last authorization was enacted
into law. Despite bipartisan support and passage of H.R. 1262
in the House Chamber and bipartisan support for S. 1005 in the
Senate Environment Public Works Committee as it was passed, the
legislation awaits Senate floor action. We are closer than ever
to reauthorize the program. We would encourage you to seek
immediate passage of the bill in the Senate without further
delay.
Lastly, NCA II urges you to support the bipartisan Water
Protection and Reinvestment Act, H.R. 3202. As you know, it
delivers a water trust fund with dedicated revenues for clean
and safe drinking water investments. This approach would commit
long-term financing to the Nation's water infrastructure needs
while relieving pressure on general revenue.
Chairwoman Johnson and members of this subcommittee, we
must not lose momentum on the Nation's economic recovery, the
economy, the construction sector in particular is still too
fragile. We are eager to work with you in what is left in this
111th Congress to advance the cause of putting America back to
work through clean water infrastructure investment. Thank you
very much.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much.
Mr. Holloway, I know your time is very short, but I would
like you to elaborate just a little bit more on the time in
which the money was received and how it interfered with your
work schedule and what can we do to improve that. I know that
recovery money came at a time that we didn't have much choice,
and it had to be rapid turnaround. That might be what you are
talking about.
Mr. Holloway. Well, I want to make sure.
In terms of the ARRA funding, we really worked closely with
the State, and we were able to get projects funded. In fact,
the bids for our work came in a little bit lower, so we were
able to fund four more projects that initially we wouldn't have
been able to fund. So, for us, that is good.
Our main concerns with the funding mechanism are
flexibility and, overall, the ability to make investments that
we think are going to the greatest needs in the system. So,
while the State Revolving Funds are a good mechanism, number
one, making more of the available moneys--grants--we believe
100 percent grants is the way to go. Then in terms of the State
Revolving Fund, while it is a useful mechanism, doing direct
grants to cities like New York City that are responsible,
really, for maintaining the ultimate infrastructure we think
would be an improvement.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much.
I will call on Mr. Boozman.
Mr. Boozman. Yes, ma'am. Thank you.
Again, I know you have to go. I enjoyed your testimony,
both your written and then your stated testimony.
You know, I think what I am seeing is that--you know, as
was said, you know, the Federal standards aren't actually
achieving the public benefit in all cases, and you know, you
mentioned that a majority of your capital spending over the
last 8 years was Federal mandates. Many times those mandates do
not appear to be--you know, you are there on the ground, you
know, knowing your city as well as anybody and trying
desperately, you know, to keep rates down, and you do what you
feel like is in the best interest of the public. Yet those
don't seem to match up many, many times, and we see that, you
know, in the huge area that you have got, and then you are
seeing that all throughout America.
But as we commit to increasing funding, it does seem like
there is a black hole out there that doesn't address, as Mr.
Hawkins pointed out, you know, these 1860, you know, areas that
need to be replaced and that, you know, we are saying that we
have got to get a standard that can--you understand what I am
saying.
Before you leave, can you just follow up on that a little
bit? Then we will visit with the rest of the panel about it.
Mr. Holloway. Absolutely. Thank you for your consideration.
I apologize for having to get back up to New York City, but I
think there are a couple of things in terms of what I said in
the testimony.
First, we think that our system has incredible
infrastructure needs. As Mr. Hawkins talked about, he has 1,200
employees; we have 6,000; we have 14,000 miles of pipe; we have
14 wastewater treatment plants, each of them with 5,000 moving
parts. The state of good repair of that infrastructure and
Federal funding--not to do all the work, but Federal support
for decisions that we make at the local level we think is,
number one, the best way to achieve what we need to do, which
is treatment; and then achieve water quality standards.
In terms of the standards themselves, there are certain
investments. Really, this becomes an issue of scale,
particularly in New York City, where a standard will be set.
And because it is a national standard, even if it is delegated
to the State, you know, the State has the obligation to enforce
what the Federal standard is. Then even if you are able to
demonstrate through analysis--and we do some of the most
rigorous analysis out there--that a particular investment
either isn't going to achieve the water quality benefit or
isn't needed, because the public health risk isn't there, we
would rather dedicate those funds then to dealing with the
water maintenance and the wastewater treatment plants. We are
constrained. We can't do that.
Mr. Hawkins talked about raising water rates 9 percent last
year and 12.5 this year. We just had to raise rates. We are a
couple months ahead of you, I guess, at 12.9 percent. That was
the fourth double-digit year of increases.
I think one important thing with mandates is that Mayor
Bloomberg has made unprecedented investments in water quality,
and he is going to continue to do so. With PlaNYC, he wrote the
book, in a way, on creating this sustainable blueprint; but
what mandates do is they constrain your time, the time in which
you have to build and make certain investments, and they tend
to look at water quality issues in this mandate and enforcement
way that doesn't take the overall needs of the whole system
into consideration.
So a reauthorization of State revolving funds, a grant
program that takes those things into account and gives maximum
flexibility to localities but also looks at the overall
regulatory picture.
I think, you know, the pharmaceuticals is an interesting
example for us. We made a substantial investment in looking at
our watershed, and we did a level of testing, and they
developed, basically, a new science to do a level of testing to
detect at the parts per trillion.
Now, if you read the language in the bill about
pharmaceuticals, it could be interpreted at some point down the
line to say, well, the intention was to actually, you know,
prevent these or treat them in the system, but that should only
happen if there is a demonstrated need to do that treatment.
Otherwise, you know, we should try to make sure that the
dollars go where they are needed.
I think, overall, we share the same goal as the committee,
as the EPA, as our regulators: clean drinking water, clean
waterways. The mayor wants to open up 90 percent of New York
City's waterways to recreation, but we need the maximum amount
of flexibility to do it and on a timeline that is affordable.
You know, in water investment, in the water investment world,
the reality is, if it happens this year, next year, you can do
things over a time period and still achieve the overall goals.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much.
What we are going to do is ask the members who have
questions to ask the questions. Could you submit the responses
in writing so that you will be able to go?
Mr. Holloway. Absolutely. Thank you.
Ms. Johnson. First, what I would like to have you elaborate
on is the cooperative partnerships and how we could improve
that.
Congresswoman Edwards.
Ms. Edwards. Thank you.
I just have this one question for Mr. Holloway, and it has
to do with your point about flexibility.
I also want to submit for the record a letter from the
Washington Suburban Sanitary Commission, our system that really
talks about wanting flexibility. I was curious from you what
kind of flexibility you think that you need that you don't have
now in terms of your ability to spend and use Federal dollars.
Mr. Holloway. Well, flexibility for us, I think, works on
two levels. One is flexibility in terms of spending the
funding, and the way that that works right now--the way it
worked in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act is the
entire $4 billion went through the State revolving funds. The
State revolving funds have set up--each State differs in terms
of the rules and the requirements and the level of
environmental review that you need to go through for a project
to qualify.
So, while one thing you can do is work with the State to
make those regulations as flexible as possible, another way to
do it is to create parts of the funding that can go directly to
the localities. You know, we have seen this in the Homeland
Security funding as a model that has worked where you have
both, you know, going through the UASI funding, going through
the State executive, and part of the funding going to the major
UASI cities. That has been effective. So we think a mix is a
way to get the flexibility.
For example, just as an example, because in New York City,
as I said, we have 14,000 miles of water and sewer main, we
open up streets all the time. We try to coordinate our water
and sewer replacement projects with our Department of
Transportation and, in some cases, utility projects. We don't
do an individual environmental review. Every time we open up a
street and replace a water main, we do a lot of environmental
reviews. We don't do them for those projects. It just so
happens that the New York State rules require an environmental
review, so none of the clean water money can be used for those
kinds of projects. Now, the Federal grant doesn't establish
that restriction, but by putting it through the State revolving
fund, that restriction then is raised for us.
So that is flexibility on the funding side. I didn't want
to--I saw you were------
Ms. Edwards. No. I am just curious as to whether you have
encountered any issues with respect to EPA requirements around
disadvantaged communities.
Mr. Holloway. Do you mean in terms of the Davis-Bacon or--
----
Ms. Edwards. No, not disadvantaged businesses.
Disadvantaged communities and applying Federal funding.
In the ARRA, for example, there were requirements for
serving disadvantaged communities, and that impacted at least
our local ability to set priorities in a different kind of way.
And I just wondered if you had encountered any of those same
issues.
Mr. Holloway. To my knowledge, we didn't encounter that as
a particular issue in terms of the projects that we could fund.
I think that--but let me get back to you on that. I want to
make sure that we--because I know we were able to ultimately
define the projects that were able to take advantage of all the
funding that was made available to us, but I can get back to
you on that.
Ms. Edwards. Then, lastly, what do you perceive as your
flexibility in being able to set your own priorities for
Federal funding rather than have those, you know, set either
outside or by other kinds of regulatory requirements?
Mr. Holloway. Well, right now, for example, New York City
is, as I am sure many--the council member and I were talking
before this about consent orders and meeting requirements.
One of the things that has been certainly at the Federal
and State levels is the way that you approach, for example,
combined sewer overflows, which is through tanks, building what
is now called ``gray infrastructure'' and putting it in the
ground.
You know, the one example that I have been using over and
over since I came to the agency is we have a 50-million-gallon
tank that we are about to turn on in Brooklyn that cost $422
million to build. Now, that will have a substantial impact on
one tributary in New York Harbor, and for that tributary that
is undoubtedly a good thing, and you want to stop as many CSOs
as you possibly can.
However, when you do the modeling and you ask, ``Well, for
that $422 million, what is the overall water quality impact in
the harbor in New York City?'' the improvement is projected to
be less than 1 percent.
So then the question becomes, ``Well, what would you do
with that half billion dollars?'' which is basically what it
is. What we are looking at in cities--I think D.C. is making
some move here, and Philadelphia has put in proposals.
We think green infrastructure and trying to do more to
capture, at the source, stormwater and being able to make these
investments on a timeline. A lot of these technologies have to
be tested. You know, of New York City's permeable surfaces, we
don't have much permeable surface. In fact, we are, you know,
creating the green infrastructure projects that will actually,
meaningfully, capture stormwater and deal with it. It is
something that I actually brought in a new commissioner for,
sustainability, whose primary job is to deal with this issue.
Now, in order for us to succeed, the funding is starting to be
there. I think the ARRA funding that was specifically made
available for green infrastructure is a great signal.
On the regulatory side, though, there has to be a
willingness to say, Well, wait a minute. If you are going to be
making these investments, then green infrastructure can not
only give you the water quality improvement but also the long-
term public benefit of a park or a swale or trees or all of the
things that those kinds of investments can provide.
Are we going to be able to have the willingness to open up
the current agreements and orders and negotiate timelines and
frameworks that are going to enable us to try, fail and try
again, but ultimately get to the same water quality standard in
the end, which we think we can do? That is a big challenge, and
EPA has made some good--we have heard some good things from the
EPA on that, but the proof is really going to be in the pudding
there.
Ms. Johnson. Mr. Holloway, you passed the time for you to
go.
Mr. Holloway. Well, thank you very much.
Ms. Johnson. If there is any other testimony you would like
us to know about, you may send it, and we will be happy to
receive it.
Mr. Holloway. Absolutely. Thank you.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you.
Now we will go back. Thanks to all of you for your patience
in allowing him to complete his work and to get back.
Before we go to Mr. Boozman, our chair of the full
committee has come in. He is always very knowledgeable, so I am
going to recognize him.
Mr. Oberstar. Thank you, Madam Chair.
I just want to sit here and listen and take in the
testimony. I wanted to thank the Commissioner from New York for
his contribution and to welcome City Council Member Jan
Marcason and to thank her for the warm welcome I received in
Kansas City, the city of water and fountains and beauty. I had
never visited before, and I was treated to a great eye-opening
experience. Thank you very much.
I look forward to hearing your testimony.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you.
Mr. Boozman.
Mr. Boozman. Mr. Hawkins, you testified about all of the
areas and of running into different roadblocks, you know, as
far as getting your permits and things. It sounds like you are
an old permitter, and now you are, you know, on the other side
of the fence. You know, we have statistics about how long it
takes to complete a road, you know, once the project--and, you
know, with all of the hoops you have to jump through.You know,
it might take 9 or 10 years, you know, to do that.
Tell us about, you know, the similar stuff that goes on in
getting through the permitting process.
I guess the other thing I would like to know--and you all
are welcome to jump in--is how much does that cost the system,
as far as in the road situation, if we could get rid of some of
the duplication, you know, some of the permitting process, and
not do away with what we are trying to accomplish, you know, in
protecting the public, protecting the environment, doing things
right? You know, if we could streamline the process, how much
money would that save you as you try and grapple with these
difficult situations?
Mr. Hawkins. Thanks for that question.
If I may just for one second respond on the issue of my
compatriot from New York, I would state that, as to his notion
that direct grants to cities offers more flexibility, in fact,
because the District of Columbia is both a city, a county and a
State, that is, in fact, what has happened here, and we have
had great flexibility as a result. So it does, in fact, work
that way.
The last time I actually testified before this hearing, I
was here as the director of the Department of the Environment,
which regulates my current agency. I can't believe some of
those decisions I made when I was a regulator, but we took 80
percent of the Clean Water revolving funds that we have coming
into the city of the District and are distributing them to
projects, greening everything you can imagine. We are greening
police stations, parks and rec centers, libraries, median
strips, roadways.
We have this multiplicity of projects because of the
flexibility we were able to administer since we were a city
directly gaining money and distributing it. So I can testify
that, on the only occasion like this where the city is also the
State, it does work well and it enables flexibility, so it is a
good thing.
As far as the permits, it is a fascinating question. Since
you know the city, on 17th and 18th Streets, going right up
through Adams Morgan, there is a lot of work that has been
going on along those streets for a long time. The way this
works is we, DC Water, produce our capital program to the
District Department of Transportation 2 years in advance so
they can plan ahead so that, when we are doing roadwork in the
street or if they are working in the street, you coordinate it.
Of course, ARRA--we aren't complaining, but that came in in
the midst of the process outside of the standard planning
system. What started to happen is that we would initiate a
project that was ARRA-stimulated off schedule, and we would end
up with a project that was not coordinated with DDOT, not
because anyone had done anything wrong.
So a number of the projects got held up. That the standard
permitting system is done in advance is for good reason: so
that you don't end up with DDOT resurfacing a road and then us
coming in 2 months later and digging it back up again and
replacing the pipe. We want to do that both at the same time.
So there have been challenges in trying to match up the
existing permitting system, which is done with many years of
advance preparation with a system that is putting new money in
on a very short time frame, for obvious reasons.
As to the capacity to improve the speed of decisions as far
as how much money it would save, there is no question we spend
a lot of money on coordination. In fact, I just authorized--we
are going to put on the Web here in the District a visual. We
just authorized it with the Department of Transportation. You
or anyone else will be able to look at the city and any street
on a GIS basis and see every project that is coming visually.
So everyone becomes an overseer of us because they can all
check whether or not we have managed and planned, and we are
hoping that that is going to substantially increase the
efficiency of being able to integrate new funding along with
existing funding.
The last point that is interesting about the District is,
in the study, you have heard much about the $300 million that
EPA has estimated for this massive need for infrastructure. The
highest per-capita need in the United States of America for
wastewater infrastructure is Washington, D.C.--$4,315 per
capita. That is not per customer. That is per capita in
Washington, D.C. in order to improve the wastewater
infrastructure for this city.
So the need is just--it is extraordinary what we face, and
we have charted out rate increases, and they are constant for
the next 20 years. This is going to be a system. We will get
better at it because of its scale, but it is really daunting
when you think of what we need to do for the public that we
serve.
Mr. Boozman. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you.
Congressman Garamendi.
Mr. Garamendi. Madam Chair, a couple of quick questions.
Like our witness from New York, airplanes to the west coast are
hard to find.
I want to go to section 220, which no longer is in the law,
and get to the question of whether it makes sense to put it
back in. A couple of things come immediately to mind. One is
the question about the greening, which we heard both from New
York and Washington. Those are and can be alternative water
supply systems as well as sanitation issues. Certainly, this is
an issue that we are seeing a lot of in California, which is
where we have serious problems.
Also on the sanitation side, those alternate systems which
once could have been funded by section 220, can supply potable
water, such as recycled water, which, at least west of the
Rocky Mountains, is a very, very big deal.
So I don't know if I have a question. I think it is just a
comment to the chair and to the committee members that we give
very serious consideration to reauthorizing the section 220
funding programs that they provide.
If there are any comments from any of the witnesses, we
would love to hear them. I would have asked the fellow from New
York to be very specific about exactly what kinds of mandates
he does not need. I would suggest that he probably needs those
mandates upstream of his water supply but maybe not downstream,
since his system exits into the ocean. But that is a question I
will ask him in writing.
Mr. Garamendi. So, if anybody would like to comment on the
220 section, I would be happy to hear that quickly, and then I
am running.
Mr. Hawkins. I would have a quick comment.
On the question of the flexibility for the mandates, DC
Water has a $3.8 billion capital campaign for the next 10
years. Half of that is dictated by Federal mandates. So fully
half of what we must do is not for engineering excellence--
although, we, of course, will employ it--but the first category
is what we just have to do to comply with the laws, whether or
not we would have done it otherwise.
When we prioritize all of our projects, the second category
is health and safety. The third category is what we have to do
for our fellow agencies. The fourth category is best
engineering practices.
Now, we hope to do all four, but some might argue that
because it is a mandate doesn't necessarily mean it is the
engineering practice you would implement otherwise.
Mr. Garamendi. Excuse me. I did receive your correspondence
in the bill, the water bill, that said it had to do with the
storm drains and the sanitation drains being together and you
needed to find some way to deal with that. The reason you need
to deal with it is, when you have a storm you are dumping some
really nasty stuff into the Potomac River.
Is that a mandate you would like to do away with?
Mr. Hawkins. No. The mandate that we would like--well, not
``do away with,'' but open to flexible interpretation.
At the moment, our response is to combining sewers. Of
course we want to respond to that. There are 3 billion gallons,
most of which go to the Anacostia, actually, not to the Potomac
River--Rock Creek. But the mandate is the solution. The
solution, which is a consent decree, is the underground
concrete and steel caverns. We are actually just about to start
a 26-foot boring all the way up the Anacostia River, from down
at Blue Plains up to Poplar Point and then to RFK.
The question is, can we open up--there is the MS4 permit
system becoming more stringent------
Mr. Garamendi. Excuse me.
Mr. Hawkins. Yes.
Mr. Garamendi. For all the witnesses who are interested in
the mandate issue and our fellow from New York, if you could,
be very specific about how the present mandates impact you and
how you would change the law.
Mr. Hawkins. OK. Sure.
Mr. Garamendi. I am out of time in many, many ways. I thank
you so very much.
Madam Chairman, thank you for your courtesy.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you.
Ms. Marcason.
Ms. Marcason. I am going to have to get back to you on the
specifics.
When we created our overflow control plan, we made it an
adaptive plan, and I think one thing that we--with over 25
years of the plan, we hope that there are a lot of new emerging
technologies that we can take advantage of. But once you have a
consent decree in place, you are locked into the technology
that you set out in your plan.
So another part of that is we need to make sure that we can
modify our plans going forward to make sure that we are able to
capture the benefit of new ideas, new technologies, new thought
processes that are coming down the road.
Mr. Garamendi. I have 18 seconds remaining here.
That specific kind of information, how would you change the
law to give you that flexibility? Understanding that the
consent decree--you know, it is legal, but you need the
flexibility. So how would you change the law to accomplish
that? That is what I would like to have because, ultimately,
that is what we must do here.
Ms. Marcason. Right.
Mr. Garamendi. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Ms. Johnson. Did you want to answer?
Ms. Marcason. I would rather research that and talk to the
people back at the National League of Cities and in my
community. I am sure we could come up with some good
suggestions, though, so I appreciate the opportunity to do
that.
Ms. Johnson. Mr. Chairman.
Mr. Oberstar. Madam Chair, if I may intervene at this point
so I can get off to another matter dealing with the oil spill
legislation, I very much appreciate this panel. I have already
spoken of my session with Ms. Marcason in Kansas City and, Mr.
Hawkins, of your splendid stewardship here in the District and
of your contributions on the Chesapeake Bay cleanup, and of the
contributions of the other two members of the panel.
What is the age of the oldest sewer and the oldest
waterline in the WSSC system?
Mr. Hawkins. The WSSC I can't speak to. The WSSC serves
Montgomery and Prince George's.
Mr. Oberstar. Sure, the metropolitan area. Right.
Mr. Hawkins. And DC Water--actually, we serve WSSC. A lot
of their flow comes from the Blue Plains plant. We have
assessed the age of our waterlines. Now, sewer is much harder
to tell. They are deeper in the ground, and there is not as
much pressure. We have waterlines in this city that were put in
before the Civil War, and we have a report that I can send you
that gives you the age of the waterlines. As for the sewer
lines, most of our lines, we are not sure how old they are, so
we don't have as clear an answer.
Mr. Oberstar. Before the Civil War. Some of those are
probably still wooden lines.
Mr. Hawkins. We believe we have gotten all the wooden lines
out of the city distribution system. I can actually show you
some as kind of a tour, but I think we have gotten all the
wooden lines.
Mr. Oberstar. Do you still have clay pipe in the ground
anywhere?
Mr. Hawkins. Again, nothing that we know of having clay
pipe, but we do have--we have pipes that are remarkably old,
but we don't believe we have any clay or wood pipes in this
system that we have.
Mr. Oberstar. Clay works very well in acid soil. We have
concrete, and that tends to be deteriorated by acid.
I ask this because, all over the country, we are at a stage
of--kind of over the tipping point of the capability of the
existing water and sewer lines to serve the increasing demand
for water and wastewater treatment. The replacement cost is
just escalating enormously from the time when I started on the
Hill as the clerk of the Subcommittee on Rivers and Harbors in
1963. It seems like an eternity ago. We were talking then about
aging water and sewer systems, and we still are, and the
replacement of those systems is still a very costly matter
whether in real dollars, actual dollars or in updated dollar
costs.
Since the Reagan administration terminated the grant
program, it put smaller jurisdictions under greater financial
pressure because, right at that time in 1981-1982, it was the
point at which the wastewater treatment grant program was to
switch from a preponderant 60 percent of the funds going to
major metropolitan areas to 60 percent of the funds going to
municipalities under 250,000, even under 50,000.
With President Reagan and his Budget and Reconciliation
Act, I remember being on that conference committee so very
clearly it is like it happened yesterday, and the Senate voting
against our House proposal 5-4 without even asking the
Democratic members on the Senate conference committee. They
just voted it down and converted it from a $6 billion grant
program to a $2 billion for 1 year and then converted it to a
revolving loan fund. That meant that smaller jurisdictions,
rural communities, had to shoulder a higher cost than they
otherwise would have, had there been a grant program.
So now we have those costs continue, so there have been
fewer dollars invested because municipalities had to borrow
money at a higher cost and raise their fees. I know that in
Minnesota, if you live anywhere within the seven-county Twin
City Metropolitan Area, your water/sewer bill is about $15 a
month. If you live outside the seven and if you are in a
municipality of 2,500 or less and if you live outside Twin City
Metro Area with the same sized population area, your monthly
sewer bill is around $54.
That is a huge jump, a huge cost, to people who have fewer
options. Municipalities have less revenue and less opportunity
to generate the debt retirement that they need to make the
investments in their water and wastewater treatment systems. So
there is the continuing age of our systems, the continuing
vulnerability of older material to deterioration.
You mentioned, Mr. Hawkins, the blowouts that occurred, the
big one on River Road. There was one just yesterday morning as
I was driving in, and I heard the radio. Of course, I didn't
have to avoid it, it was up in Montgomery County. And then you
regularly have these blowouts in the District of Columbia.
How do you keep up with this? Is INI, infiltration inflow,
sufficient technology? What else do you need to do to keep
track of your system and then make the investments necessary?
Ms. Marcason, and I will ask our other two witnesses as
well.
Mr. Hawkins. I mean the average residential single-family
bill in Washington, D.C. Is slated on September 1 to go up to
$61. In New York, the average monthly bill is about $80, so
they are very expensive. We have gone up, as I said, 30 to 40
percent over the last 3 or 4 years.
Our biggest challenge, I think, in many of the major cities
in the country is that most of the systems that were put in--
the average age of waterlines in Washington, D.C. is 77 years,
so they were put in before most of our current ratepayers were
here. What we have been funding for the last four our five
decades is operation and maintenance costs of these systems--so
how much it takes to keep it going, but not a capital
replacement program.
So in Washington, D.C., our budget for capital improvement
is one-third of 1 percent of the infrastructure in any given
year, which means it would take us 300 years to replace the
scheme.
The rate proposal that I have made for 2011, should the
board decide to approve it, which they will do in September--I
hope--will allow us to increase our capital replacement program
to 1 percent a year, which would allow us to replace the system
in 100 years. That is actually double the national average. The
national average is a half a percent a year. That increased by
triple when I looked at my compatriots to my left. We have got
to hire people. We need trucks. We need material. These are
jobs that can't be exported. They must be done on the line.
They are so meaningful to the neighborhoods and the people
that are the recipients of the service. There is such a direct
connection between our ability to raise the revenue to do
fundamental infrastructure--the jobs, the equipment we buy, the
trucks we purchase, and all the attendant pieces that come
together.
The biggest single challenge we have--we have a fair amount
of knowledge of this system. We have tested it. We know what we
need to do--is converting the awareness of our ratepayers to
capital cost replacement, which literally hasn't been on most
bills for a long period of time. At the same time, we are also
doing these giant, long-term control plans, which--your city
has done a remarkable plan, but it is $1.5 billion or $2.5
billion.
Ms. Marcason. $2.5 billion.
Mr. Hawkins. Ours is $2.8 billion. That is on top of the
capital replacement. So it is expensive even when you are
innovative, and you add these costs together, and they become
extraordinarily daunting to cities of every size.
Mr. Oberstar. Is the revolving loan fund of use to you,
then, in that construct?
Mr. Hawkins. Absolutely. The projects that we are doing--
because of Washington, D.C., the drinking water revolving
funds, for example, come directly to DC Water, and we are using
those funds to replace valves. It is very operational. We are
getting out into the system and making operational capital
improvements to the system that we would not have otherwise
made. So when you see a project--when you are driving around
town and you see someone digging down, replacing a valve, that
is likely a stimulus project.
Mr. Oberstar. Oh, I clap and I cheer when I see that. In
fact, I would like you to build all those water and sewer lines
about 2 feet aboveground so people will bump into them and know
what we have done for them, because we bury our good deeds in
the water and sewer systems.
Mr. Hawkins. Yes, that is true.
Mr. Oberstar. The public never sees them.
I think Mr. Boozman will fully appreciate that and will
agree with me on that. We want constituents to know what we
have done on their behalf.
Tell me, before I go to Ms. Marcason, where is the Potomac
swimmable above Blue Plains?
Mr. Hawkins. I don't know the answer to that question. It
is not swimmable for its length--well, actually, when I was at
the Department of the Environment, we had an exception for
professional athletes in triathlons; but otherwise, the water
in the Potomac or any of the waterways in the District are not
swimmable. And I think that is true fairly far to the north,
but I am not sure exactly where the cutoff is.
Mr. Oberstar. Certainly to Little Falls of the Potomac, the
pumping station.
Ms. Marcason.
Ms. Marcason. I think, you know, cities and towns all
across America have the same issue.
Our water pipes are 1850's. Men went off to fight the Civil
War, and came back and completed our Main Street water/sewer
system. So it is not just the water system. We have aging
infrastructure on our roads, in our buildings, and so it just
compounds the issue. But we have increased our rates 44 percent
since fiscal year 2008 in Kansas City, and we have double-digit
rate increases scheduled throughout our overflow control plan
for the next, probably, 5 to 7 years. Depending on the success
of our project, you know, that could be extended. I mean we
hope to see a leveling off, but then at the end of the project,
if we do have to build those big tunnels, they will jump up
again.
So I think that is part of the reason we are trying to make
sure these green solutions could be an option. They are,
hopefully, less expensive, but we are having to do a lot of
testing. You know, they are a little bit untested. We are doing
a lot of modeling right now. I think that is why we got an
additional 5 years. We got 25 years to do our plan. Part of
that is so we can gauge the effectiveness of the massive
project we are doing, and if that is true and since it did save
us $10 million in one area, we hope that is something that
could be replicated, and it could be a way that we could
address this in a more cost-effective manner.
Mr. Oberstar. Well, permeable parking areas and shopping
centers and sidewalks and even roadways--or at least shoulders
on roadways--are very important, very critical support
mechanisms for our dealing with runoff.
Ms. Marcason. Right.
Mr. Oberstar. We are having vastly more runoff than we did
100 years ago or even 50 years ago. We have paved over more of
America.
Ms. Marcason. That is right.
Mr. Oberstar. It isn't an increased amount of rainfall; it
is an increased amount of runoff. We need to save that water.
We need to get it into groundwater, and so these are very good
solutions.
Mr. Vander Molen, that doesn't do much for equipment
dealers, does it? You want to have more of your customers
buying equipment and putting it to work.
In the stimulus program from our committee of, roughly, $4
billion, 100 percent of that money is out. Let me just check my
report card. Of $3.8 billion, 100 percent is out to bid; 1,962
projects out to bid; 1,957 are under contract; and for 1,884
projects work is underway. So your equipment is working, and
there are some members of the operating engineers who are out
there operating that equipment.
Now, if the Senate were to rise from its slumber and pass
something and move the Clean Water Revolving Fund, what would
that do for your sector and your members?
Mr. Vander Molen. If I could say so, our industry has got a
lot of unused resources right now that are ready to go to work.
With jobs the way they are and with infrastructure the way it
is, our equipment and facilities and inventories--they are
ready to go to work.
Congresswoman, I have to excuse myself. I have got a plane
to catch to go back to Jackson, Mississippi. If you have got
other questions that you would like to address to me, I would
be glad to respond to them in writing, but I really appreciate
the opportunity to be a witness here at this subcommittee.
Mr. Oberstar. Thank you for your splendid contribution. We
appreciate that.
Ms. Johnson. Yes, thank you very much.
The only thing I would ask is whether or not the equipment
has changed to the point that it interferes with your
investment or the technology you are using on these projects.
Mr. Soth. Madam Chairwoman, the equipment improves
dramatically from year to year. This is equipment that we are
pleased to operate, some equipment of which is Vermeer
equipment. Our members are pleased to take advantage of the
opportunities offered by Congress for this job creation. We
have advocated for an increase in the appropriations.
Mr. Chairman, we have appreciated your informal oversight
of the State and local governments on the Recovery Act. We
would just assert that more can still be done there. We
appreciate your help, but we have got States like Louisiana
that have yet to undertake a third of their construction
projects. More can be done there.
We are a year and a half, almost, into the Recovery Act,
and States that have failed to go ahead and undertake those
projects to which you have devoted major resources are still a
problem for us. And with 20 percent-plus unemployment in the
construction industry--and it is certainly higher for some of
our local unions around the country--we desperately need your
assistance in exercising your informal oversight, even though
those State governments have complied with the letter of the
Recovery Act.
Mr. Oberstar. We are watching them, and for those who
haven't been in compliance and who haven't gotten their
projects under contract, Ms. Johnson and I have sent letters
out to the Governors and to the heads of the Public Utilities
Commissions and told them to get started.
Now, unfortunately, the Senate struck our language that
imposed the requirement of ``use it or lose it.'' If within 120
days you haven't used your funds by obligating and getting bids
out, then that money would go to States that could use it. The
Senate struck that language, but we thought that was a very
powerful forcing mechanism to get States to comply.
Mr. Hawkins. If you will permit me, on the question of
equipment or hiring, I would say that, in fact, the low-impact
development--the kind of strategies that are in Kansas City, in
fact--are driving purchases of equipment that are quite
dramatic.
One of the weaknesses--or not weaknesses, but unknowns in
the low-impact development arena--is to build a big concrete
tunnel. You are pretty clear about how you maintain it over
time and how you keep it together to attain performance.
One of the big questions on the low-impact development is,
after you put in this incredibly dispersed system of thousands
of installations of low impact, whether it is on the streets or
walkways or roofs, you need equipment, new equipment, to go out
and maintain this over time. Who goes back to the rain garden 5
years after it was installed to make sure that, when it fills
up with silt, there is something to remove it? We are buying
new equipment to implement maintenance programs for the new Bay
savers that are part of this street design that remove
pollutants.
So, in fact, there are enormous equipment needs in building
an infrastructure we, in fact, don't have to a great extent,
which is an infrastructure around the long-term maintenance of
low-impact development.
I can also tell you that to attain the projects we are
planning over the next 2 to 5 years, we are probably hiring 20
to 40 engineers at DC Water and a much larger number as
contractors. So there is no question that when this work does
gear up, we will directly need the kinds of services that are
provided on that front.
Mr. Oberstar. Thank you for your energy, for your
enthusiasm and for your remarks. We really appreciate seeing
your members out on the job sites, running that equipment and
making things work.
I am going to yield at this point, and Chairwoman Johnson
has an important announcement to make.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much.
As of 3:47 p.m., the oil spill has been capped, and there
is no more leaking. That is the best news I have heard for a
while.
Now, Ms. Edwards had a question.
Ms. Edwards. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. That is the best
news that we have heard in a long time, so thank you for that.
I really appreciate your testimony today.
Especially Ms. Marcason, I have been working really hard to
try to pass legislation to create investments in green
infrastructure like you are working on in Kansas City and
across the country. My legislation, H.R. 4202, the Green
Infrastructure for Clean Water Act of 2009, was really designed
to help communities like Kansas City address these vexing water
pollution problems.
You know, just as I was listening to the testimony, I
actually thought about our recent Fourth of July, and over the
Fourth of July--I have a water system that is principally
serviced by the Washington Suburban Sanitary Commission, which
is serving 1.8 million customers in Prince George's and
Montgomery Counties. Over the Fourth of July, we had water
restrictions because of a major flaw which was going to lead to
a break--a 96-inch pipe. Thankfully, because of detection
equipment technology that had been installed, the system was
able to look at that and know that it was failing, even though
it meant for our 1.8 million customers, water restrictions over
a major holiday and when we would have had fireworks. So, you
know, very odd.
But WSSC, I think like Kansas City and like jurisdictions
across the country, has a water deficit. We talk about all
kinds of deficits. We have a water infrastructure deficit in
this country, and it means that we are not spending what we
need to on our water infrastructure that is about productivity
and efficiency. It is about business survivability.
Can you imagine if that 96-inch main had actually broken?
It would have interrupted all kinds of business and commerce
throughout our communities, and we know that those needs are
great around the country.
So I want to thank you all for the work that you do, but we
just have to put people to work improving our Nation's water
and sewer infrastructure. In my view, there is no bad spending
that goes on there. If in our jurisdiction we have $10 billion
in unmet needs, that is 180,000 jobs. In your jurisdiction, it
is $6.5 billion in unmet needs. For every billion, as you point
out in your testimony, Ms. Marcason, that is 18,000 jobs.
So I hope that we over these next several weeks will really
also begin to make the commitment to green infrastructure as a
technique so that we can use it in terms of prioritizing our
needs in our communities, and that we can use green
infrastructure and the new technologies that are available that
relieve the pressure on these sort of high-intensity and high-
cost projects in some of our communities.
The legislation that I have introduced would require the
Environmental Protection Agency to really examine how green
infrastructure approaches can be incorporated into clean water
programs, including permitting and enforcement, and we heard
testimony about that earlier.
My question for you is that we are at this really critical
time right now, with our infrastructure deteriorating, and
investments really that need to be made to the most
deteriorating infrastructure needs.
Can you explain, if you would, Ms. Marcason--and
particularly Mr. Soth--what this means in terms of creating
jobs apart from the--you know, so the real question is
improving our Nation's water infrastructure. Tell me what kind
of jobs. Tell me how much those jobs pay. Tell me what that
means to our business community in terms of its productivity.
I will start with you, Ms. Marcason.
Ms. Marcason. Well, we are very excited about the range of
jobs that the green infrastructure offers.
There is traditional engineering, because it takes an
engineering plan. But it is also for people who like to work
outside, if you like to work with plants--people who might not
want a desk job. So we are doing a lot of job training with the
using of plants. We have a training program of young people in
a disadvantaged neighborhood who are learning how to lay
sidewalks, permeable sidewalks. There are some very important
construction-type jobs, and there is also, obviously, the
engineering and the architectural and the traditional jobs.
We see the opportunity to get young people very involved in
new job skills, to get them excited about doing this and
excited about the contribution they can make to making their
community a safer and a better place to live. We feel like that
is going to have the additional benefits of getting them
invested in beautifying their community and having a good job.
So we have really looked at how we can tap into the
resources of people who have been underemployed, and we work
very closely with our unions and with those types of job
training programs in making sure that we do address the needs
of each of the communities, but also of our workforce. It is
really unacceptable to have such a high unemployment rate. We
feel like these types of emerging jobs will have many benefits.
I just want to say, your district is very lucky because we
have another advocate for the green programs in our Congressman
Cleaver, and it really does take that political will to get the
communities moving in that direction. So I am sure your
community will benefit from that.
Ms. Edwards. Thank you.
Ms. Marcason. Did I answer your question?
Ms. Edwards. You did.
Mr. Soth, I wonder if you could tell me, though really
specifically, tell me the kinds of jobs that your workers could
be employed at. You know, say, in my community, it is 180,000
jobs with this $10 billion of deficit and spending and water
infrastructure that we have. Who is working? What kind of job
are they working at? What are they paid at? If you are an
apprentice and you start out and you go through the number of
weeks and months and years that it takes to train, then, you
know, where does that land you?
Mr. Soth. Our apprenticeship model in the operating
engineers is typically a 4-year apprenticeship program.
Oftentimes, an apprentice will start out at 50 or 60 percent of
a journey-level worker's wages and then progress. As that
individual gets more on-the-job training, more classroom
instruction, that individual will advance their wages to a
place that they are earning journey-level worker wages.
The most recent Bureau of Labor Statistics labor market
data suggests that an average wage for a construction worker, a
nonsupervisory production worker in construction, is over $23
an hour. Of course, operating engineers and carpenters, because
of their skill levels, are oftentimes able to earn more money
than that.
I think projects vary, obviously, a little bit, so you will
get a different composition of craft workers on each individual
project, but it is common that you would find an operating
engineer operating a backhoe or a crane. Obviously, there are a
lot of labor union members--pipe layers, for example, building
wastewater in the ditch, as we say, laying that pipe. So,
really, there is a whole range of crafts there. A lot of that
work is performed by unions, like the carpenters and the
operating engineers, and we are pleased to do as much of it as
we can.
As I mentioned, the high unemployment rate has put a lot of
pressure on the families of carpenters and operating engineers,
and anything we can do to get back to work would be much
appreciated. We would like to think that those four policies
outlined and suggested by NCA, too, are going to be helpful in
that regard in putting America back to work through these clean
water infrastructure investments that you have been so kind to
commit to restoring the American economy.
Ms. Edwards. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Madam Chairwoman.
The point is there are jobs. There are jobs now, and it is
infrastructure that we know that we have to fix. Otherwise, it
interferes with our competitiveness for the 21st century.
Thank you, Madam Chairwoman.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you.
Ms. Marcason, you indicate in your testimony that you would
like to see the passage of H.R. 1262.
Due to the proposed sewer overflow grant program, and the
set-aside is 20 percent of those grants for communities
implementing green infrastructure and other water and energy
efficiency improvements, do you feel there would be an
opportunity for your district to be able to access that?
Ms. Marcason. Definitely. Definitely.
We are doing a lot of demonstration projects right now, and
I feel like we need to probably do more so we can know what is
going to work the best. I mean this is still an emerging
technology, so I think the investment is very important up
front. Some of the strategies may be more successful than
others, so we are working toward 20 percent. I am not sure that
we are quite there yet, but I think it is going to pay off down
the road if we make the investment in emerging technologies
now.
Ms. Johnson. Thank you very much. That is kind of new for
everyone. I think that ends our hearing today, and let me thank
all of you for coming as witnesses. All of you have been very
helpful. Thank you.
[Whereupon, at 4:20 p.m., the subcommittee was adjourned.]
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]