<?xml version="1.0"?>
<?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="billres.xsl"?>
<!DOCTYPE bill PUBLIC "-//US Congress//DTDs/bill.dtd//EN" "bill.dtd">
<bill bill-stage="Introduced-in-Senate" dms-id="A1" public-private="public" slc-id="S1-OLL21781-6T1-CC-0FC"><metadata xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/">
<dublinCore>
<dc:title>117 S2228 IS: Disincentivizing Internet Service Censorship of Online Users and Restrictions on Speech and Expression Act</dc:title>
<dc:publisher>U.S. Senate</dc:publisher>
<dc:date>2021-06-24</dc:date>
<dc:format>text/xml</dc:format>
<dc:language>EN</dc:language>
<dc:rights>Pursuant to Title 17 Section 105 of the United States Code, this file is not subject to copyright protection and is in the public domain.</dc:rights>
</dublinCore>
</metadata>
<form>
<distribution-code display="yes">II</distribution-code><congress>117th CONGRESS</congress><session>1st Session</session><legis-num>S. 2228</legis-num><current-chamber>IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES</current-chamber><action><action-date date="20210624">June 24, 2021</action-date><action-desc><sponsor name-id="S350">Mr. Rubio</sponsor> (for himself and <cosponsor name-id="S397">Mr. Braun</cosponsor>) introduced the following bill; which was read twice and referred to the <committee-name committee-id="SSCM00">Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation</committee-name></action-desc></action><legis-type>A BILL</legis-type><official-title>To amend section 230 of the Communications Act of 1934 to correct shortcomings in how that section addresses content moderation, content creation and development, and content distribution.</official-title></form><legis-body><section id="S1" section-type="section-one"><enum>1.</enum><header>Short title</header><text display-inline="no-display-inline">This Act may be cited as the <quote><short-title>Disincentivizing Internet Service Censorship of Online Users and Restrictions on Speech and Expression Act</short-title></quote> or the <quote><short-title>DISCOURSE Act</short-title></quote>.</text></section><section id="idFD6F1CC7E6DE42778BDB472FBC4E1163"><enum>2.</enum><header>Content moderation, creation and development, and distribution</header><subsection id="id5EED7422D94E4907A316AE70604B8718"><enum>(a)</enum><header>Treatment as publisher or speaker contingent on content management practices</header><text>Section 230 of the Communications Act of 1934 (<external-xref legal-doc="usc" parsable-cite="usc/47/230">47 U.S.C. 230</external-xref>) is amended—</text><paragraph id="idF6360501F2FE4F4BAAC8A0BD5FD97BD1"><enum>(1)</enum><text>in subsection (c)(1)—</text><subparagraph id="id3F30814E3F974F38BA0DE6E1626477D1"><enum>(A)</enum><text>by striking <quote>No provider</quote> and inserting the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="id3042D3BB390345FC81B48452C635FE26"><subparagraph id="idEA6F92BD512446D2A40B3775861A1EB2"><enum>(A)</enum><header>In general</header><text>Subject to subparagraph (B), no provider</text></subparagraph><after-quoted-block>; and</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></subparagraph><subparagraph id="id4BE703B6E81F45CABBA48A42D46BC8F7"><enum>(B)</enum><text>by adding at the end the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="idEBA37FFF15E944D18B9DC3A750251F93"><subparagraph id="id506E2D0F2E334BB0A5C425223A66BA16"><enum>(B)</enum><header>Notification of parental control protections</header><text>Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to a provider of an interactive computer service with a dominant market share that violates subsection (d).</text></subparagraph><after-quoted-block>; and</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></subparagraph></paragraph><paragraph id="idE86A099798CB4797BFA5922C35754541"><enum>(2)</enum><text display-inline="yes-display-inline">in subsection (f)—</text><subparagraph id="id38C53CF1031843709398CA17117B1809"><enum>(A)</enum><text display-inline="yes-display-inline">in paragraph (3)—</text><clause id="id46CF9B0DD02046EF9658139DEDF30ABB"><enum>(i)</enum><text>by striking <quote>The term</quote> and inserting the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="id32E8416B33644C2F8D60A37489B30276"><subparagraph id="id90E0732075C043C78C69E3C7B4F49626"><enum>(A)</enum><header>In general</header><text>The term</text></subparagraph><after-quoted-block>; and</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></clause><clause id="id941766F299154C36B78A075E36525C78"><enum>(ii)</enum><text>by adding at the end the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="idB34D61E205D94D95AF0ED09DF160688C"><subparagraph id="idAD751C7921314059BE24FE190C2DEDC1"><enum>(B)</enum><header>Content moderation</header><text>If an interactive computer service provider with a dominant market share—</text><clause id="id5781BE70F9DA42AEBB44A98B9F5CDCB6"><enum>(i)</enum><text>engages in a content moderation activity that reasonably appears to express, promote, or suppress a discernible viewpoint for a reason that is not protected from liability under subsection (c)(2), including reducing or eliminating the ability of an information content provider to earn revenue, with respect to any information, the interactive computer service provider shall be deemed to be an information content provider with respect to that information; or</text></clause><clause id="id8C20896FAD3742E2AA46908D4AAD91D4"><enum>(ii)</enum><text>engages in a pattern or practice of content moderation activity that reasonably appears to express, promote, or suppress a discernible viewpoint for a reason that is not protected from liability under subsection (c)(2), including reducing or eliminating the ability of an information content provider to earn revenue, the interactive computer service provider shall be deemed to be an information content provider with respect to all information that is provided through the interactive computer service.</text></clause></subparagraph><subparagraph id="id2D13B80315BF42EBB6D9D2493E262648"><enum>(C)</enum><header>Use of targeted algorithmic amplification</header><clause id="id910B7536157A4C9BA65E79167DA889F3"><enum>(i)</enum><header>In general</header><text>If an interactive computer service provider with a dominant market share—</text><subclause id="id4D668FF6859D4DA49FD5348BE76F33D8"><enum>(I)</enum><text>amplifies information provided by an information content provider by using an algorithm or other automated computer process to target the information directly to users without the request of a sending or receiving user, the interactive computer service provider shall be deemed to be an information content provider with respect to that information; or</text></subclause><subclause id="id318E386E91FB48AEA7DBB55561390AD4"><enum>(II)</enum><text>engages in a pattern or practice of amplifying information provided by an information content provider by using an algorithm or other automated computer process to target the information directly to users without the request of a sending or receiving user, the interactive computer service provider shall be deemed to be an information content provider with respect to all information that is provided through the interactive computer service.</text></subclause></clause><clause id="idA2C24D477C514156B09368DA255B5125"><enum>(ii)</enum><header>Exceptions</header><text>Clause (i) shall not apply to the use of an algorithm or other computer process to—</text><subclause id="id05507B640DAD43F7939F6444BE9B4FE1"><enum>(I)</enum><text>amplify or target directly to a user any information that is the result of a search function performed by the user; or</text></subclause><subclause id="idD0E95E41A59945908EA6A6B8B1D7D270"><enum>(II)</enum><text>sort data chronologically or alphabetically.</text></subclause></clause></subparagraph><subparagraph id="id9A2F849DFAB64496B54CDF7177C5AF56"><enum>(D)</enum><header>Information creation or development</header><text>If an interactive computer service provider with a dominant market share—</text><clause id="id722ABD2E9C8A44D98FA97DC4F1FD2F25"><enum>(i)</enum><text>solicits, comments upon, funds, or affirmatively and substantively contributes to, modifies, or alters information provided by an information content provider, the interactive computer service provider shall be deemed to be an information content provider with respect to that information; or</text></clause><clause id="idC1F86801478A49C18CEFF867D4D12ACA"><enum>(ii)</enum><text>engages in a pattern or practice of soliciting, commenting upon, funding, or affirmatively and substantively contributing to, modifying, or altering information provided by an information content provider, the interactive computer service provider shall be deemed to be an information content provider with respect to all information that is provided through the interactive computer service.</text></clause></subparagraph><after-quoted-block>; and</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></clause></subparagraph><subparagraph id="idF413FC170DB54160966A20CE632B699E"><enum>(B)</enum><text>by adding at the end the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="id00092D4F19914BBC9C1D1D338AAE0549"><paragraph id="id3FD7DEEF68EE470586E27D1AB3A0F3D9"><enum>(5)</enum><header>Content moderation activity</header><text>The term <term>content moderation activity</term> means editing, deleting, throttling, limiting the reach of, reducing or eliminating the ability of an information content provider to earn revenue from, or commenting upon, information provided by an information content provider, or terminating or limiting an account or usership, if the activity is based on content-based criteria.</text></paragraph><paragraph id="idD7152B3BFFED45BD839E29E0DD752799"><enum>(6)</enum><header>Pattern or practice</header><text>The term <term>pattern or practice</term> means any formal or informal policy or rule, whether created by a human or generated by a computer, as applied or used by an interactive computer service provider.</text></paragraph><after-quoted-block>.</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></subparagraph></paragraph></subsection><subsection id="id68043E0C54C443C0A833D881A55C0286"><enum>(b)</enum><header>Clarifying categories of objectionable material</header><text display-inline="yes-display-inline">Section 230(c)(2) of the Communications Act of 1934 (<external-xref legal-doc="usc" parsable-cite="usc/47/230">47 U.S.C. 230(c)(2)</external-xref>) is amended—</text><paragraph id="id1D673037031E4AF58B5E66141E780BBD"><enum>(1)</enum><text>in subparagraph (A)—</text><subparagraph id="id35C213DBBA634A7AA0A6C4D72599F56A"><enum>(A)</enum><text>by striking <quote>considers to be</quote> and inserting <quote>has an objectively reasonable belief is</quote>;</text></subparagraph><subparagraph id="idD81365071CC444FDA7CE44905B00362B"><enum>(B)</enum><text>by inserting <quote>promoting terrorism or violent extremism,</quote> after <quote>violent,</quote>; and</text></subparagraph><subparagraph id="id24E99430EDE144969C34F46E1885654D"><enum>(C)</enum><text>by striking <quote>or otherwise objectionable</quote> and inserting <quote>promoting self-harm, or unlawful</quote>; and</text></subparagraph></paragraph><paragraph id="idC17A95955303480B8DC576A5D37DAF90"><enum>(2)</enum><text>in subparagraph (B), by striking <quote>paragraph (1)</quote> and inserting <quote>subparagraph (A)</quote>.</text></paragraph></subsection><subsection id="id38C412CD40E04FE692BDCDBD6C728290" commented="no"><enum>(c)</enum><header>Religious liberty exception to civil liability protections</header><text>Section 230(c)(2) of the Communications Act of 1934 (<external-xref legal-doc="usc" parsable-cite="usc/47/230">47 U.S.C. 230(c)(2)</external-xref>), as amended by subsection (b), is amended—</text><paragraph id="id852855FA950C48E5A60E257EEB744ED0" commented="no"><enum>(1)</enum><text>by redesignating subparagraphs (A) and (B) as clauses (i) and (ii), respectively, and adjusting the margins accordingly;</text></paragraph><paragraph id="id6C4D191FE27C45C6A2036A24E25A5ED9" commented="no"><enum>(2)</enum><text>by striking <quote>No provider</quote> and inserting the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="idDB98A20BEF7B414788137DAA3D7C464C"><subparagraph id="idA90F2940543548CE9261B9415BB2A22F" commented="no"><enum>(A)</enum><header>In general</header><text>Except as provided in subparagraph (B), no provider</text></subparagraph><after-quoted-block>;</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></paragraph><paragraph id="id19212C31BEBF4FFCA97E3C9C425BDD3E" commented="no"><enum>(3)</enum><text>in subparagraph (A)(ii), as so designated, by striking <quote>subparagraph (A)</quote> and inserting <quote>clause (i)</quote>; and</text></paragraph><paragraph id="idA606E5BA7C4244D69D7F37B26047CB0F" commented="no"><enum>(4)</enum><text>by adding at the end the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="idBE7A6C5263ED42188718D86229938CC8"><subparagraph id="idD3D4FEBC051643D187CE7C9C8CEECE9E" commented="no"><enum>(B)</enum><header>Religious liberty exception</header><text>Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to any action taken with respect to religious material in a manner that burdens the exercise of religion, as defined in section 5 of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 (42 U.S.C. 2000bb –2).</text></subparagraph><after-quoted-block>.</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></paragraph></subsection><subsection commented="no" id="id1E1C0705238B4A16B2764CBC3A30024F"><enum>(d)</enum><header>Disclosure of content management mechanisms and practices</header><text>Section 230(d) of the Communications Act of 1934 (<external-xref legal-doc="usc" parsable-cite="usc/47/230">47 U.S.C. 230(d)</external-xref>) is amended—</text><paragraph commented="no" id="id28F35217F6BE42CD9E39EFA87D776F26"><enum>(1)</enum><text>by striking <quote>A provider</quote> and inserting the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="idDF49471C52C24D12AB780C8680C493FC"><paragraph id="idEA8440947E3341F983D297D139E528C3"><enum>(1)</enum><header>Parental control protections</header><text>A provider</text></paragraph><after-quoted-block>; and</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></paragraph><paragraph commented="no" id="idD435206B399548649D9F79B2D918930D"><enum>(2)</enum><text>by adding at the end the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="id8CC862BE1FDC4A079A1D651451FC8035"><paragraph id="idFB313C4195B04CC3AB5A1068F39B2182"><enum>(2)</enum><header>Disclosure of content management mechanisms and practices</header><subparagraph id="id755e0cf9c3ca4cd6bb5e5a83b6c4ef2d"><enum>(A)</enum><header>In general</header><text>A provider of an interactive computer service that provides the service through a mass-market offering to the public shall publicly disclose accurate information regarding the content moderation activity of the service, including editing, deleting, throttling, limiting the reach of, reducing or eliminating the ability of an information content provider to earn revenue from, or commenting upon, information provided by an information content provider, terminating or limiting an account or usership, and any other content moderation, promotion, and other curation practices, sufficient to enable—</text><clause id="id5AFD66D34ABE41CAB2525D692BBC7557"><enum>(i)</enum><text>consumers to make informed choices regarding the purchase and use of the service; and</text></clause><clause id="idA030843362DB45249616CD8EBBD66D73"><enum>(ii)</enum><text>entrepreneurs and other small businesses to develop, market, and maintain offerings by means of the service.</text></clause></subparagraph><subparagraph id="id86F1B7C2DD184F66B0D5F748F3502D0A"><enum>(B)</enum><header>Manner of disclosure</header><text>A provider of an interactive computer service shall make the disclosure under subparagraph (A)—</text><clause id="id28C21639A24248739853AAAD2E9BFAE3"><enum>(i)</enum><text>through a publicly available, easily accessible website; or</text></clause><clause id="idA274E02A3D3040169616406E32521D16"><enum>(ii)</enum><text>by submitting the information described in that subparagraph to the Commission, which shall make the information available to the public through the website of the Commission.</text></clause></subparagraph></paragraph><after-quoted-block>.</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></paragraph></subsection><subsection commented="no" id="idBF8FD7A03F9D4DF5955B831FB53AA9DF"><enum>(e)</enum><header>Clarifying that immunity is an affirmative defense</header><text>Section 230(c)(1) of the Communications Act of 1934 (<external-xref legal-doc="usc" parsable-cite="usc/47/230">47 U.S.C. 230(c)(1)</external-xref>), as amended by subsection (a)(1), is amended—</text><paragraph commented="no" id="id893B3F7739554AF981F78F270A6981EB"><enum>(1)</enum><text>in subparagraph (A), as so designated, by striking <quote>subparagraph (B)</quote> and inserting <quote>subparagraphs (B) and (C)</quote>; and</text></paragraph><paragraph commented="no" id="idF49F8B071F3B4D57BFA2BD2E9AB3BF36"><enum>(2)</enum><text>by adding at the end the following:</text><quoted-block style="OLC" display-inline="no-display-inline" id="id3167D652EBA04873B7C752F7FC307688"><subparagraph id="idE66F481935EF4A9F80C370601EE29DD6"><enum>(C)</enum><header>Affirmative defense</header><text>In a criminal or civil action against a provider or user of an interactive computer service that treats the provider or user as the publisher or speaker of any information, the provider or user shall bear the burden of proving that the provider or user is not an information content provider with respect to that information for purposes of subparagraph (A).</text></subparagraph><after-quoted-block>.</after-quoted-block></quoted-block></paragraph></subsection></section></legis-body></bill> 

